3 ms·
> In short, it treats the cycle as a car, but with access to less information. This is just not even remotely true. I cycle all the time in Manhattan and Broo
by crazygringo 7y ago
> In short, it treats the cycle as a car, but with access to less information.
This is just not even remotely true.
I cycle all the time in Manhattan and Brooklyn and for the same destination, the car and cycling routes are drastically different.
Cycling routes give tremendous preference for roads with actual cycling lanes, and do their best to avoid main arteries to give you a safer side street instead.
You can verify this yourself in Google Maps by turning on the "Bicycling" layer to see the green-marked bicycle routes, picking random intersections to get directions between, and observe how it tries to route you along bike lanes. (Of course, Manhattan streets are tricky, so it's not the case 100% of the time because giving too much preference to bike lines can result in a much longer trip.)
Quick searching also reveals that Google absolutely uses the elevation data to try to route riders along flat roads, that uphill shows a longer estimated time, and you can even see an elevation map of the route.
So as far as I can tell, this article is just 100% factually wrong, based on an entirely false premise.
Is Google Maps perfect for cyclists? Of course not (e.g. it has no idea cobblestone streets are something to avoid), but it's not perfect for cars either (thinks I ought to drive down a pedestrian staircase in LA).
But there's clear evidence that Google Maps "discovered" cyclists sometime around 2014, if not before. It's been a while. (My biggest wish is for it to integrate bike sharing into directions.)
- wiredfool 7y agoIt varies greatly, depending on the country. Portugal doesn't have any cycling info. The routes in Spain and France tend to go down things that are marginally identifiable as roads or cycling paths, and more likely to be hiking paths. Definitely the sort of thing that I'd not take a road bike down, but a MTB would be ok.
- crazygringo 7y agoYes. I wonder to what extent that has to do with countries/municipalities providing data though? I know there are huge variances in the quality of government-provided data, as well as whether governments provide them at all. And that while Google Maps has Street View as a ground truth in some parts of the world, it doesn't everywhere, and especially often where there are bike paths that aren't next to a road for cars. So without knowing more in any particular circumstance, the government may be just as likely to blame as Google.
- Nav_Panel 7y ago> My biggest wish is for it to integrate bike sharing into directions. This is why I always use Citymapper to find the nearest Citibike racks to my start and end points, then switch over to Google Maps to generate my route. It does a better job than Citymapper at actual bike directions, IMO.