3 ms·
> somebody will find a creative way to mess with them and a new rule or clarification will need to be added. Rules can be rewritten in a cohesive way or rules
by MattGaiser 7y ago
> somebody will find a creative way to mess with them and a new rule or clarification will need to be added.
Rules can be rewritten in a cohesive way or rules can be written as just an endless series of if statements which may contradict with other if statements.
It would be useful for laws to have an automated test suite so that known good uses cases wouldn't be broken down the road.
- fierarul 7y agoI agree that laws could / should approach software. But we've been having bugs and exploits in software since the beginning. And law has to cover an even wider field of situations.
- dataduck 7y agoNo way. Software works for predictable inputs producing well-defined desired outputs. Reality is nothing like this. Actually good rule systems are ambiguous or weak enough that when someone tries to abuse edge cases, people can turn round and say "no" and the rules don't get in the way.
- josinalvo 7y ago(mostly) Everyone likes this flexibility. The question is some people find the cost too much. Maybe it is better to have a law that is explicitly dumb, in exchange for fast, cheap and predictable (kinda like computers, if you think about it)
- gamblor956 7y agoHumans are not machines, language is not code, and the real world is not binary. An automated test suite for laws is NP-hard.