3 ms·
I think the assumption that jurors are invariably reasonable, as opposed to on average reasonable is a pretty heroic assumption not well supported by the histor
by notahacker 7y ago
I think the assumption that jurors are invariably reasonable, as opposed to on average reasonable is a pretty heroic assumption not well supported by the history of trial by jury though.
- ergothus 7y agoAnd yet, the US legal system is built around such assumptions, invalid as they may be.
- asperous 7y agoA jury selection process lets both sides of a case interview jurors and agree on impartial and reasonable jurors. Estimates of wrongful conviction are between .13%-5% (wikipedia, miscarriage of justice), however the main thing that trial by jury affords is transparency and perception of fairness, since you are convicted by your peers and not some politician with questionable incentives.
- pnw_hazor 7y agoDon't forget that the court decides what a jury gets to see or hear about a case. Juries are not perfect, but they are the best tool we have. Further, the prosecutor has real power that far outweighs the power of the accused. Juries imperfectly provide an offset to that power imbalance.