3 ms·
Norway uses a mixed system (it used to have juries for some cases; the very last jury decision after the law was changed was logically unsound - two questions,
by vidarh 7y ago
Norway uses a mixed system (it used to have juries for some cases; the very last jury decision after the law was changed was logically unsound - two questions, one of the four combinations was impossible; the juries returned that one) of panels of judges (from 1 to 7) depending on the type of case. For the most serious criminal cases the panel will have 2 professional legally trained judges and 5 "lay judges" - basically jurors of a sort, but unlike in a jury trial all of the judges (professionals and lay judges) deliberate together and vote together. In a 7 judge panel, at least 1 of the professional judges and at least 4 of the lay judges must vote guilty for a conviction.
This feels to me like it gets most of the benefit of both a jury and of professional judges. It avoids a lot of the issue of whether or not the lay judges understand the jury instructions and the legal aspects they're asked to judge on, but also ensures the prosecutor does need to convince both the lay judges and the professional judges for a conviction.
- pwned1 7y agoWe also have the tradition of jury nullification in the US where jurors are free to acquit if they feel as though the law itself is unjust. Professional jurors would no doubt shy away from that because their employment depends on the government. In addition, in the US, jurors don't make decisions on the law, just the facts.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 7y agoIn Norway jurors didn't make decisions on the law either, which is why the distinction between jurors and lay judges exists. It's kinda moot now as there aren't juries anymore, but both systems existed in parallel (for different types of cases and severity) It's not really that they are "free to acquit" either as much as that there is no mechanism for preventing it. The issue is controversial enough that the several circuits have made it clear courts can present jury instructions designed to minimize it and/or prevent the jury from being made aware of the ability. And this ability has also been extensively abused, e.g. for racist purposes. While it has also been used to attack unjust laws, I'm not convinced it is worth the risks.
- Amezarak 7y agoThe possibility of contradictory decisions is a feature of juries, not a bug. Juries are able to make decisions metalegally, not just legally. They are one of the most important checks on the power of the legal system. In the US, if you do not want a jury trial, you are free (and encouraged) to do so and settle for a bench trial, where everything is decided by a judge. I think that gives you the best of both worlds as a defendant.