5 ms·
> >Businesses rushed to apply for the loans, which the government said would be forgiven... > Forgiven? Then its not a loan anymore is it? Its a bailout. Was t
by gumby 7y ago
> >Businesses rushed to apply for the loans, which the government said would be forgiven...
> Forgiven? Then its not a loan anymore is it? Its a bailout. Was the intention to give a handout of cash to small businesses free of charge?
The intent was indeed to just hand out the cash. The weird mechanism was to try to do it quickly through infrastructure that already exists (SBA program implemented through banks already working with small businesses) with a little bit of control on how spent (if you don’t spend 75% of it on payroll or a few other things like rent then it remains a loan). The people writing the law knew it was a kludge but wanted to get the money flowing quickly,
I don’t want to defend the implementation nor especially a scumbag like Rubio, but he didn’t kill those businesses as much as fail to rescue them. Those megacorps got their lawyers to start working on angles while the legislation was being written; the small shops only started honking about it once the law came into effect.
- dhimes 7y agoKilling and failing to rescue are kind of the same thing here. Those big corporations should have been prevented first- and then let them sue later. Now it's the other way around. And you should definitely blame scumbags like Rubio. There's a reason reputation is a thing.
- Spivak 7y agoSelectively choosing who to rescue I think is much more of a grey area. Despite the cruise industry being healthy business that would not have failed any time soon outside of something crazy like a global pandemic people are trying to play political games with the recuse money because they don't like certain businesses. This isn't really about what's right or what people deserve, it's that when we come out of this we don't want to have whole industries wiped out arbitrarily and we certainly don't want to punish the companies that are paying their workers though this despite them not actually being able to work.
- incongruity 7y agoIf you’re on a boat and someone falls overboard have you killed them if: 1) You don’t have a life preserver to throw them? No 2) You don’t have a life preserver to throw them and you don’t look for one? Regrettable, but still probably not. 3) You have a life preserver and don’t throw it to them? Yeah, that’s kinda bad. 4) You have a life preserver but you throw it to your rich friend who is still on deck because he paid for your stateroom and he collects life preservers? Yeah - you’re a schmuck and a murderer. So is your rich friend.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoYou took a friend out on a boat without any safety gear? Yes, you’re a murderer. Failing to plan is planning to fail. We could’ve had the infrastructure in place to rapidly mitigate the economic impact of the pandemic; we made the choice not to. This was a conscious decision.