4 ms·
Given that the gatherings themselves would be illegal due to shelter-in-place orders, planning a protest would seem to be speech that "incites a violation of th
by kelnos 7y ago
Given that the gatherings themselves would be illegal due to shelter-in-place orders, planning a protest would seem to be speech that "incites a violation of the law that is both imminent and likely".
But then I guess you have to contend with the question of whether or not making gatherings illegal in the first place is constitutional, even for the purposes of curbing a public health crisis. I personally hope it is constitutional, but I'm no legal scholar.
- dahart 7y agoI wouldn’t frame it that way, it’s not a question of whether gatherings are constitutional. They are, and legal, peaceful protesting is protected in this country. But there already are some kinds of gatherings that are illegal and unprotected, so it’s not some kind of slippery slope. Whether it’s legal, protected and/or constitutional always depends on what kind of gathering you’re talking about.