5 ms·
The problem is that finding truth is so much more time consuming than lying. A couple friends and I looked at creating a Canadian fact-checking website as we do
by MattGaiser 7y ago
The problem is that finding truth is so much more time consuming than lying. A couple friends and I looked at creating a Canadian fact-checking website as we don't really have a Politifact up north, especially not for the smaller provinces.
We gave up when we went on Twitter to see just how much nonsense was floating around and realizing that even basic lies took 30 minutes each to refute. Assuming that we had perfect access to people's information feeds and assuming they all believed us anyway (and many wouldn't), we would still need 6x as many people as popular trolls/liars existed to fight back.
You would basically need to have a legion of volunteers willing to spend 30 minutes undoing 5 minutes of damage.
- chameleon_world 7y agoWould there be any way to crowdsource this kind of application? Like wikipedia. 'Heres one source to back up this claim' 'Heres 8 sources that go against this claim'
- iso947 7y agoSnopes
- battery_cowboy 7y agoSnopes is already seen as a 'leftist' source by those folks who need it most.
- dntbnmpls 7y agoThe problem is that snopes is actually leftist so the "folks who need it most" would see right through their agenda. Just like you see the obvious agenda of foxnews and others see the obvious agenda of msnbc/cnn/etc. But you are blind to the bias of msnbc/cnn/snopes/etc just like they are blind to foxnews/etc. It's hilarious seeing the most brainwashed and biased people thinking they are on the side of "truth/logic/science/etc". Whether you like it or not, all media is about pushing agenda/propaganda/etc. No media exists today and has ever existed to produce truth/facts/etc. The ones claiming to be the least biased or the ones you think are the least biased are actually the best at lying to you or deceiving you. Media is about control. If you think there is a media outlet that is honest, then you are one of the duped individuals.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoI wanted to reply earlier, but my eyes rolled out of my sockets due to your 'both sides' argument. It took me some time to get them from under my couch.
- dntbnmpls 7y agoNo. You are right. Only one side lies. What was I thinking?
- battery_cowboy 7y agoEveryone lies, but some lie more than others and some lies are worse. I'm not arguing with you, though, because you're clearly someone who doesn't understand nuance or scale.
- sfj 7y agoIn other words, the lies from my side are small and unimportant. The lies from your side are unimaginably dire and are destroying the world! Now where under the couch did my eyes roll to...
- battery_cowboy 7y agoYou're almost self aware, keep going!
- sfj 7y agoI have no idea what you're talking about. Maybe you could enlighten me, but that would mean you'd have to actually take a vulnerable position in which your thinking process would be there for everyone to see and could actually be challenged, so nah...
- belorn 7y agoI generally prefer politifact over snopes. Snopes seems to mix news with fact checking, and the search tool does not distinguish between fact checking and news. In addition, politifact ground their articles to political statements that can be sourced to a specific person, time and place. That create a framing for which a broader subject can be discussed, but also limits the scope to that specific statement.
- basementcat 7y agoSome experts argue that "fact checking" sites are a waste of resources. Those who believe the misinformation would not accept the "fact check" as plausible and those open to questioning the misinformation generally find the truth on their own. Relevant lecture from US Army War College: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUpCiA0WZ5k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUpCiA0WZ5k
- interestica 7y agoI think the value sometimes is in having relevant resources to point to when in localized arguments. (If someone is repeating a falsehood, I can direct them to resources that refute it rather than having to do all the searching repeatedly).
- ativzzz 7y agoSuch arguments are usually emotional and spouting off facts is unlikely to change the other person's stance and instead make them double down harder.
- coffeecat 7y agoI've attempted to engage with people in ideological echo chambers not by citing any specific facts that contradict their beliefs, but by asking them to state their own beliefs using more specific and concrete language. "What exactly is your definition of communism?", "Has Bernie made any specific statements indicating that he supports that policy? If not, what leads you to infer that he does?", etc. The results? No engagement at all.
- ativzzz 7y agoPeople do not want to be challenged in an echo chamber. Either talk to them (without convincing them of anything) outside the chamber, or walk away.
- sebwi 7y agoAgreed, often it's less about the person you are interacting with but about those reading your conversation.
- kabacha 7y ago> spend 30 minutes undoing 5 minutes of damage Cache. If there are 100 trolls posting: "all birds are blue" you only need to refute it once and link "Are all birds blue? No" article. 5 minutes of damage * 100 vs 30 minutes of undoing
- jaredmosley 7y agoYes, but there are infinitely more lies than there are truths. If 80% of lies result in a cache miss then you are in the same position. Especially when it is easy to create a lie that is very hard to disprove.