4 ms·
Does it strike anyone else as a bit weird to focus on R? It's obviously useful to know whether R is less than or greater than unity (subcritical or supercritica
by mindslight 7y ago
Does it strike anyone else as a bit weird to focus on R? It's obviously useful to know whether R is less than or greater than unity (subcritical or supercritical). But when R is greater than 1, then the growth rate over time seems more fundamental.
- dboreham 7y agoPerhaps the idea is to inform policy decisions, both government and personal. If I know the R0 is 10, I'm probably not going to leave my house. Otoh if it's 2 then with an N95 mask I'd think about grocery shopping.
- mindslight 7y agoExcept if that hypothetical R=10 is a slow acting virus that infects others over the course of a month, and the R=2 kills within a day...
- btilly 7y agoTo think this way is to misunderstand exponential growth. If you're concerned with personal risk, the biggest thing that matters is the current spread. Of course if everyone is concerned with that, nobody will be concerned until it is too late to prevent a large portion of us from getting it. However if you're concerned with the trajectory, all that you care about is whether R is less than or greater than 1. For both 2 and 10 it will hit a large part of the population, all at once. But 1.01 and 0.99 is the difference between "we all get it" and "only a small fraction of us get it".
- baq 7y agowell, if it has very high R and hospitalizations/deaths are what they are, it's actually good news - herd immunity will come much quicker, possibly avoiding future waves, assuming immunity persists for a few years (which I hear is a reasonable assumption).