3 ms·
> while someone on this thread is being called a white supremacist for defending the phrase "It's okay to be white". They're throwing around terms like "white
by monocasa 7y ago
> while someone on this thread is being called a white supremacist for defending the phrase "It's okay to be white".
They're throwing around terms like "white genocide", and saying that they wouldn't judge people who wear 1488 (just so we're clear, the 88 part means heil hitler). They're either a white supremacist, or a troll just pretending to be one.
You're not making a good case for the lack of specificity.
Going to your OK sign, obviously ok signs are fine in the general sense, but if someone is on a rant about how immigrants are ruining the country, then throws up an ok sign, it's explicitly a white supremacist calling card. It's all about context.
- ulucs 7y agoI agree that 1488 is a signal, but don't agree that it is invisible. The implied meaning is just a google search away. >if someone is on a rant about how immigrants are ruining the country I'd say this is the actual reason you think they are a white supremacist, rather than deciphering their dog whistle. Going on a rant on immigrants specifically is a much clearer indicator of their political alignment (my guess would be r/theDonald poster) and I wouldn't say the okay sign adds more signal. The real danger of dog whistles is when we start seeing things that aren't there, or when we let white supremacists or edgy shitposters dictate what our behavior means.
- monocasa 7y agoSo you agree that the person you had previously said is just innocuously defending "it's ok to be white" is actually a white supremacist or a troll pretending to be one? You keep pretending like there's these innocent victims, and it turns out these people where actually what we had said they were all along.
- ulucs 7y agoI am getting confused now. My ESL'ness might be getting in the way of us communicating. Based on how the okay sign thing went, with all of its false positives (which are the innocent victims), I don't think the "dog whistles" give a clear enough signal. Your examples also use judgement from context rather than the dog whistles which is in line with what I've said. The other poster turned out to be a clear troll, and arguing with them on what the dog whistles mean is giving them just what they want.
- monocasa 7y ago> Based on how the okay sign thing went, with all of its false positives (which are the innocent victims), I don't think the "dog whistles" give a clear enough signal. Your examples also use judgement from context rather than the dog whistles which is in line with what I've said. Can you give an example of one of these false positive victims?
- stale2002 7y ago> Can you give an example of one of these false positive victims? Sure, I can. There was a viral example when Zina Bash, a white house advisor, was sitting in a senate hearing, with her hand on her arms, in a way where her fingers kind of looked like the OK sign, but not really. As in, she did not "flash" the OK sign. Instead she had her hand resting on her arm in a certain position. And this went viral and everyone accused her of being a white supremicist because of it, even though the situation was clearly ridiculous. You can look it up, if you want more details.
- monocasa 7y agoI mean, one tweet called her out, and the left wing media and the ADL came out specifically to defend her, specifically calling out that it needed more context to be white supremacist symbol. Ie. what I've been saying this whole time. Also, it totally is an OK sign, she's just playing the circle game.
- stale2002 7y agoSome defended her and some attacked her. Thats the point. The fact that anyone was even attacking her in the first place, and this went viral at all, is still a problem.
- monocasa 7y agoSo you agree that the left came out to defend her on this? She isn't a victim of the this concept being called out, but instead the white supremacists who decided to start using a contextual clue that they're being explicitly racist a common sign just because of the chaos it causes, and not the people calling out that racists are doing this.