7 ms·
You are not alone. I've been using Mac OS X for two years and can't belive why the company that came up with iPad and iPhone still - have global menus (who rea
by eitland 16y ago
You are not alone. I've been using Mac OS X for two years and can't belive why the company that came up with iPad and iPhone still
- have global menus (who really wants that with todays screen resolutions and two monitors?)
- needs the worlds best trackpads because their laptop keyboards have misplaced ctrl and their default keybindings are so inconsistent that users would be lost without a good pointing device.
- forces developers to use the fn key to reach the function keys, but even then, maps some of the F-keys to operating system functions.
- doesn't get multiple desktops? Don't ask me why they ship them, because their window management is so broken that multiple desktops just doesn't work, at least not for me.
This becomes increasingly frustrating as
- none of the other manufacturers "gets" tablets even less ships them,
- none of them was capable of coming up with mag safe,
- Microsoft doesn't have the balls to stop OEMs from crippling a perfectly good enough (for less advanced users at least) operating system
- and Canonical have crippled Gnome to the point where you can't shut down your computer without either using a pointing device or resorting to a shell.
Edit: Forgot iTunes. Try have someone who doesn't know iTunes burn a cd. (Hint: You have to make a playlist out of it, then burn that playlist to a cd.) Also tried to tidy up this rant.
- bane 16y agoYou forgot - can only resize a window from one corner, and that corner may be off the screen in certain cases so that you can't move the window to a position where the corner is even visible (this just bit me this week) - still doesn't understand how to fullscreen programs (windows maximize function is the single best OS function I've seen that allows a user to focus on just ONE thing). I think this is fixed in the upcoming OS X but I don't have it. - liters the screen, the doc, the global menu with all kinds of state icons to show running programs and background services, but doesn't have a built-in notification system so that the users have to install http://growl.info/ http://growl.info/ and more and more. That said, it still manages to be a great OS. It was miles ahead of XP. About par with Vista. But sadly, it's lagging behind Windows 7. And the new OS X versions just don't make me terribly excited. I'm ready for something new.
- grinich 16y agoyour first two points are mostly solved in Lion.
- l0nwlf 16y agoAdding few more. - No cut-paste. - No tabs in Finder. - The missing delete key. (Backspace is renamed as delete) - The not-so-modern Terminal. (hence the wide usage of iTerm)
- jamroom 16y ago- Command-C / Command-V for cut and paste in OS X (if that's what you're looking for) - TotalFinder is a nice Finder replacement: http://totalfinder.binaryage.com/ http://totalfinder.binaryage.com/ - includes tabs and some other nifty features. Hope that helps a bit...
- l0nwlf 16y agoCommand-C / Command-V is copy-paste. Also I do use TotalFinder as a finder replacement. :)
- slyn 16y agoCommand+x is cut, same as ctrl+x on windows. Might be application specific as I only tried in Chrome and Textedit but I'm fairly certain it is OS wide.
- JadeNB 16y ago> Command+x is cut, same as ctrl+x on windows. Might be application specific as I only tried in Chrome and Textedit but I'm fairly certain it is OS wide. As mdaniel (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2294066 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2294066) mentions, it bizarrely does not work in one very specific, and presumably intentional, place—the Finder.
- jamesbkel 16y ago
- m3koval 16y agoOut of the box, window management with Mac OS X is a pain in the ass. Once I installed and configured BetterTouchTool, however, most of my complaints went away. Binding keyboard shortcuts and trackpad gestures to window management form a great balance between a floating and tiling window manager. Even if it doesn't solve all of the problems with the operating system, it is a large improvement.
- GHFigs 16y agomisplaced ctrl, default keybindings are inconsistent, forces developers to use the fn key to reach the function keys All of this can be adjusted to your liking in the Keyboard preference pane.
- eitland 16y agono, other pc's often have a bios setting to swap fn and ctrl. FWIW I can't find ANY documentation on how to fix this on Macbooks. Please prove me wrong.
- blahedo 16y agoI agree with all your points except the first (I'm especially bitter about Spaces, in fact). But as for that one: > "have global menus (who really wants that with todays screen resolutions and two monitors?)" Because there are a lot of operations you can do that are not specific to a particular document/window, or in some cases don't apply to any windows at all. And, even more importantly, sometimes you want to close all the windows for an application without closing the whole application! I've run into this problem in a variety of applications, including DrRacket and Logisim as well as more widespread ones like Word: I want to go through several documents sequentially. Naturally I want to close one before I open the next, so that I don't have a whole pile of old windows open. But if I close the only open window I quit the whole application, so I have to leave one of the docs open as I sequence through the rest. The behaviour of several "close" operations (e.g. clicking the window's close button) varies according to whether there are other windows (close window) or not (quit app). Some apps get around this by opening a dummy "new document" window if you close the last open window, but that's still a little jarring and counts more as a workaround hack than anything else. I don't have these problems when I'm working on a Mac. Oh, and I almost forgot: Fitts's Law. The global menu bar is a mile high, and it's way way WAY easier to acquire than a menu bar inside a window.
- DudeWithPriorIP 16y agoApp controls should live in the dock icon. As Chrome, Word, and most modern Microsoft software has shown us, there's really no need for the standard "File, Edit, etc" menu bar today.
- jujjine 16y agohave global menus (who really wants that with todays screen resolutions and two monitors? I never had a problem with that. With a 13" device it's possible to have 2 to 4 windows open at the same time, since the windows themselves use space efficiently. So at best this argument is subjective to the user. needs the worlds best trackpads because their laptop keyboards have misplaced ctrl and their default keybindings are so inconsistent that users would be lost without a good pointing device Not being accustomed to the keyboard layout is rather an excuse than an argument. Also my impression of the key bindings is that they are well done and consistent. Do you have examples to prove your case? forces developers to use the fn key to reach the function keys, but even then, maps some of the F-keys to operating system functions. As an developer you should be able to tackle more difficult tasks than finding out that the custom fn keys can be disabled in the system preferences->keyboard pane(if it is important enough for you to write about publicly). doesn't get multiple desktops? Don't ask me why they ship them, because their window management is so broken that multiple desktops just doesn't work, at least not for me Window management is a problem for me too. Tools like Shiftit make it easier, but it does't feel like THE solution. I'm curious though if that problem is considered solved on any other platform. The last times I used Windows (XP to 7) it did not do any better. Try have someone who doesn't know iTunes burn a cd At some point it was easier to do that(e.g. dedicated button), but given that disc-drives are on the leave in PCs, burning is of less importance to users (at least I can't remember someone burning cd's recently). As one of the most used peaces of software iTunes has a pretty good help documentation, which describes how to burn a cd nicely. The procedure is also quite reasonable, introducing few concepts apart from standard procedures(creating a playlist).
- anonymoushn 16y agoWindows 7 ships with something similar to Shiftit (windows key+arrow keys). Between that and spaces' habit of randomly rearranging my windows on the z-axis I prefer Windows to OSX for window management. I think the problem is solved, but only for people who don't use OSX or Windows and take a month or two learn how to use a scriptable tiling WM =/
- code_duck 16y agoResorting to a shell? I prefer the shell. I'd like to see users of other operating systems turn off their computers from bed without resorting to VNC.