2 ms·
They're over-fitting noisy data. Huge changes in R over the course of a week, as for Idaho, has to be an illusion. One problem is that some states and some hos
by Animats 7y ago
They're over-fitting noisy data. Huge changes in R over the course of a week, as for Idaho, has to be an illusion. One problem is that some states and some hospitals don't report daily data on weekends, and new cases and deaths are charged to Monday.
Low-pass filtering helps smooth the curves, but adds lag, of course. Centered low-pass filtering is useful but can only be applied retrospectively. There's no magic bullet for dealing with noisy data.
- acqq 7y agoThe cases not being "perfectly spread" over the seven week days is observable also outside of the U.S. It's simply an artifact how most of the workers work. So the would-be-modelers should really be able to handle at least that! Another very common pattern is that the cases / deaths / was test performed / whatever data which is to be reported gets "stuck" and then released in a bunch at some moment of time, sometimes only once in some week. It's really surprising to me that such simple truths aren't recognized.
- mzs 7y agoIt does do smoothing, plus the ranges are very plausible for this Bayesian approach: $ head -1 rt.csv state,date,ML,Low_90,High_90,Low_50,High_50 $ awk -F, '$1 == "ID" { printf("%s: %.2f - %.2f\n", $2, $6, $7) }' rt.csv | tail -7 2020-04-13: 0.07 - 0.54 2020-04-14: 0.10 - 0.59 2020-04-15: 0.32 - 0.92 2020-04-16: 0.50 - 1.16 2020-04-17: 0.51 - 1.17 2020-04-18: 0.47 - 1.11 2020-04-19: 0.32 - 0.94