4 ms·
It does seem crazy that New York still has two man operation. A machine is also capable of confirming correct alignment to some marker, and won't get distracted
by tialaramex 7y ago
It does seem crazy that New York still has two man operation. A machine is also capable of confirming correct alignment to some marker, and won't get distracted or confused. I assume it's a union thing?
If you are going to spend millions of dollars (yes really) paying for an extra person on every train, clearly having them fixed in a place where they can point at a board so as to not automate an easy problem is a poor use compared to them roaming the train. Of course New York's trains still also don't have open gangways, so it wouldn't be easy to do that either. But a guard who actually strolls up and down the train helping passengers might actually make a useful difference compared to replacing a trivial mechanical sensor with a well-paid human.
- innocenat 7y agoI know nothing about subway in the US, but living in Japan, most systems here still have 2 staff per train. The conductor job here includes confirming overall safety of the train (including confirming stop position), open-close door, and general communication to the passengers. There are systems here that use 1 man to operate, but those are generally the lower throughput system.
- hudibras 7y agoFor a high-traffic train, you need to have someone manually open and close the doors. You can't use automatic doors like on an elevator because someone will invariably keep them from shutting, either on purpose or by accident.
- downerending 7y agoYou really need an attentive person to keep people from being dragged--there is no substitute. (And in some curved stations, the driver can't even see to the rear end of the train.) In principle, everything could be enclosed, like an elevator, but in practice most stations would be all but impossible to retrofit.
- majewsky 7y agoThen why does it work just fine with one conductor in most other metro systems? > And in some curved stations, the driver can't even see to the rear end of the train. Mirrors and CCTV are a thing. At the Berlin metro, the platform has a big mirror or a CCTV screen array next to where the train cockpit stops. Other metros' stations have wireless CCTV systems that show up inside the cockpit while the train is stopped.
- downerending 7y agoNote that NYC trains have just one conductor, AFAIK. The second person is the driver. For dragging, it's not just where the train stops. You have to be able to see the entire side of the train as it leaves the station (e.g., for 100 meters, at least). Video might be possible, but it'd need to be attached to the train, because that's where the dragging happens. Realistically, though, NY doesn't have the money for this conversion. And more importantly, the driver needs to attend forward, not be carefully watching the dragging video.
- majewsky 7y ago> Note that NYC trains have just one conductor, AFAIK. The second person is the driver. Sorry, that was lost in translation. By "conductor", I meant "driver". All the metro trains that I know have only one personnel on board, the driver. Also, what do you mean by "dragging"? People or clothes getting stuck in a door? It seems to be very important, but I've never heard of this being a large problem in practice.
- downerending 7y agoDragging as in clothes, backpack, or an arm caught in a door, or someone falling in the crevice between the train and platform, or trying to "surf" the train, etc. Not sure, but I think incidents happen with some regularity in NY. If you haven't seen it, it might be hard to visualize just how out-of-date and decrepit some of this infrastructure is. I never saw anyone injured, but I did see a couple of close calls that still make me shudder.
- pas 7y agoNY metro is a very real mess. Were it a uniform mess it had been already modernized, automated and in general de-messed. NYC suffers from the fact that it's currently in a local minima and no one wants to put up the insane amounts of money that would be needed to modernize the system. Sure, some parts are getting modernized, but it just means you'll have the same mismatch of various parts in a big ball of track. (The "tragedy of the anticommons" - https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2019/11/29/penn-station-robert-caro-073564 https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2019/11/29/penn-stati... )