3 ms·
Whether you go on a cruise or not, it’s essentially impossible to live a modern life and not have a net negative effect on the environment. The marginal damage
by paulcole 7y ago
Whether you go on a cruise or not, it’s essentially impossible to live a modern life and not have a net negative effect on the environment. The marginal damage done by existing plus going on cruise vs. just existing is infinitesimal.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe juicy question is how much damage is one entitled to?
- paulcole 7y agoAs much as we want. Let’s just be honest about the fact that hardly anyone cares as much as they claim to.
- easyat 7y agoReally? Believing that your entitled to externalize as much damage onto the world as you feel like is psychopathic
- paulcole 7y agoLook around bud. How many people do you think are taking significant steps to minimize the damage they do? We act like eating a little less meat or buying a Tesla is the equivalent of a the Nobel Peace Prize but it’s just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic. Let’s get real and enjoy this ride while it lasts.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI don’t know why you’re being downvoted because very few people take the steps that actually reduce environmental damage such as not flying anywhere, living in small residences in dense urban areas, and dramatically reducing driving. Which to me clearly show the truth of your comment. You can swap out all the plastic bags for cloth bags and buy a Tesla and spend an hour sorting your trash every week, but taking that flight for a honeymoon to Tahiti or living in a suburb and driving everywhere negates all of it and more.
- paulcole 7y agoYep, people really want to feel like they’re doing their part when they’re really as much a part of the problem as the people they look down on. I’ve never lived in an apartment bigger than 600 square feet, have never driven a car, don’t fly, eat a plant based diet, and will never have kids. We’re about a generation or two from a total disaster and everybody wants to think tiny insignificant changes are enough. Glad I’ll be be long dead by then.
- damnyou 7y agoLook at you, person doing more environmental damage than 80% of the people on the planet, looking down on others at the 85th percentile. I fly maybe once a year, avoid red meat, and live in a dense neighborhood. I'm doing more environmental damage than most people and I've made my peace with it.
- perl4ever 7y agoI agree with your claim that "everybody is doing it wrong"...except that I think your conclusion just ends up being the same fallacy as everyone else's. Specifically, you can't assume a flight to Tahiti does or doesn't negate plastic bags or whatever. The only realistic and honest way to assess overall impact is put a number on your total consumption. There are a million ways that can be skewed, but averages don't vary as much as you think - as an overall reality check, if you make and spend your $50K salary every year, that is going to be the order of magnitude of your environmental impact. Mostly, someone who consumes $500K worth of stuff is going to have 10x the impact, and someone who consumes $5K will have 1/10th the impact. How you spend it is second order. This attitude will never catch on, because people feel, innately and through socialization, that misers are bad, "bean counters" are bad, simple but difficult solutions are bad, and focusing on specific actions, symbols, in-groups and out-groups, is what drives normal social activity and fulfillment. The psychology of "saving the environment" reminds me a lot of dieting for people who struggle with their weight, or budgeting for people who live paycheck to paycheck. It's the total that matters, not the parts, and yet it's very difficult to approach it any way other than piece by piece.
- 7y ago
- eru 7y agoReasonably well-off individual people could easily negate the damage they do to the environment. (Though we couldn't all do that, I guess.) Just buy as many carbon offsets or similar as necessary for your existence to come out net positive.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI doubt it. It's impossible to calculate how much damage one does to the environment, but the single biggest cause for extra fuel use (which correlates almost perfectly with environmental damage) is living in non dense environments since all the mass required for living has to be moved that much further. I don't think it's possible for anyone, even a well off individual, to offset what living in 1/4 acre or more lots does to society as a whole, since mass transit is no longer feasible, which means density is less feasible, and it causes a whole chain reaction of extra fuel use.
- eru 7y ago> It's impossible to calculate how much damage one does to the environment, [...] You can use approximations. > I don't think it's possible [...] to offset what living in 1/4 acre or more lots does [...] Sure, dense living has a smaller footprint. But individuals can still buy enough offsets. It's just going to be more expensive. You can also get more creative with your offsets. For example, I could try to find two people who are currently living sparsely and convince them with a bit of money to move to a dense neighbourhood. That would more than offset any personal decision to live in a sparse neighbourhood. (Slatestarcodex had a similar idea about eating meat: just bribe other people to become vegetarian, if you are worried about your net impact but still want to eat tasty, tasty meat. Obviously, normal well-adjusted humans don't take kindly to trading in such indulgences.)
- lotsofpulp 7y agoPublic transportation is not something you can dump on others. Everyone is using it, or no one is since you simply can’t design infrastructure for both at the same time. You can’t have surface streets for cars and optimize them for pedestrians and bicyclists. And obviously people will choose cars as who wouldn’t want the comfort and privacy of their own vehicle, so the upper class in society won’t be participating in the public transportation, which also has predictably negative effects on the politics of it. This is one example of something you can’t offset.
- viceroyalbean 7y ago>The marginal damage done by existing plus going on cruise vs. just existing is infinitesimal. Depends on your definition of "just existing". I can't claim to live in a way that's very good for the environment, but I do try to limit meat consumption, purchases of new goods etc. Most online calculators for carbon footprints give me a ~8 ton yearly Co2 equivalent. According to [1] a cruise from Southhampton to New York (one way) is ~4.5 tons per person, so that would be a whopping 50% increase for me, and more than double if I did a return trip. That's just the Co2 emissions too, so not factoring in the various ocean-polluting effects (also mentioned in [1]). [1] https://www.theguardian.com/travel/2006/dec/20/cruises.green https://www.theguardian.com/travel/2006/dec/20/cruises.green