8 ms·
There are negative side effects from consuming the mushrooms which you don't get from purified psilocybin. Dosage is important. There isn't a way to test for p
by colechristensen 7y ago
There are negative side effects from consuming the mushrooms which you don't get from purified psilocybin.
Dosage is important. There isn't a way to test for potency which would ensure a reliable dose.
Argument fallacies:
* your anecdotal positive experiences
* suggesting superiority because something is "from nature"
* referring to "mistakes from the past" without naming any
* suggesting superiority that "has been (done) for thousands of years"
Think about why these kinds of arguments are made on different topics which you disagree with and then rethink why you are making them here.
- ianai 7y agoCouldn’t dosage be averaged out by simply drying, “powdering”, and mixing the mushrooms as batches? I think similar is used in winemaking.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoThis is what people do exactly.
- msla 7y agoHow is that highly artificial process any better than making a pill? Plus, how do you know what other ingredients are in the mushrooms?
- 34679 7y agoThe cannabis industry has learned that "what other ingredients" are in the cannabis has a significant effect on the high produced by THC. This is known as the entourage effect. You simply do not get the full benefits with THC alone.
- msla 7y agoWe'll need to figure out what those ingredients are, and how they work, and what negative effects they have. Otherwise, we're being extremely unwise, and setting ourselves up for serious problems later.
- loeg 7y agoOr you could just do longitudinal studies on the thousands of people who voluntarily consume these things without apparent ill effect. They don’t appear to be immediately toxic so any risk here is fairly long term. Lots of anecdata self-reporting on Erowid.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoAmen. Legal in Canada so I've messed around with a few different types of edible solutions. The whole extract (i.e. using butter and then making brownies) hits way differently than isolated chemicals.
- heed 7y agoThat would ensure the amount of psilocybin is more evenly distributed across the material, but you still wouldn’t know exactly how much psilocybin you’re getting per dose.
- thegabriele 7y agoFair you pointed out but with no implied criticism, those are the exact arguments one should expect from a psilocybin user.
- samanator 7y agoWhy is that? Do you think they are less sensical than non-users? Or are you implying that the author was under the influence at the time of writing?
- throwaway6575 7y agoI think that was just a free dunk on drug users. Sorry for being uncharitable here.
- thegabriele 7y agoSorry for being too dry, i elaborated a little bit under the parent comment. I have no interest in dunking anyone
- thegabriele 7y agoNone of the two, psychedelics are known for the spiritual/naturism effects so no wonder users advocate for a "down to earth" approach. Seems to me that you wouldn't get a similar response from a meth user.
- colechristensen 7y agoThere seem to be a specific cluster of personality traits found frequently in hallucinogen users. Whether a selection of who takes the drugs, who talks about it after, or a common effect of the drugs and how they're taken. Someone presently under the influence would probably say something stranger. What seems likely is that they're very potent tools to change how the mind works, possibly for the better if used in the right way.
- thegabriele 7y ago
- rv-de 7y ago> There are negative side effects from consuming the mushrooms which you don't get from purified psilocybin. > referring to ["mistakes from the past"] without naming any You just did the same, didn't you? > Dosage is important. There isn't a way to test for potency which would ensure a reliable dose. Of course there is. You just have to mix the mushrooms well and then measure potency of a sample. That's equivalent to how drugs are produced by the way. They produce the drug and then mix it with something inert fx. > your anecdotal positive experiences He transparently identifies his a.p.ex. as such. Then it's not a fallacy ... It's an experience. And I like to read about those and do not appreciate condescending replies like yours OTOH.
- msla 7y ago> He transparently identifies his a.p.ex. as such. Then it's not a fallacy ... It's an experience. It's an experience which we have no reason to think is representative. > Of course there is. You just have to mix the mushrooms well and then measure potency of a sample. How is this highly artificial process any better than making a pill? I can tell you one way it's worse: What else is in the mushrooms? How do you know what else is in the mushrooms?
- rv-de 7y ago> It's an experience which we have no reason to think is representative. That's the very nature of "experiences" and some might argue precisely the point of describing those. > How is this highly artificial process any better than making a pill? Never said that. Do you even know what you mean by "pill" in this context? > I can tell you one way it's worse: What else is in the mushrooms? How do you know what else is in the mushrooms? Maybe you should read the article first? "Psilocybin mushrooms have been found to have minimal harmful effects and could potentially benefit those with depression." They want to reproduce a mushroom trip - not a trip based on individual psychoactive substances.
- msla 7y ago> That's the very nature of "experiences" and some might argue precisely the point of describing those. It's also why we need controlled experiments. > Never said that. Do you even know what you mean by "pill" in this context? Of course I do: A pill with a controlled amount of the active ingredients and a neutral binder. > Maybe you should read the article first? Maybe you should stop trying to condescend to me and answer the question? > They want to reproduce a mushroom trip Obviously not. They want to treat mental disorders.
- kaolti 7y agoThanks for listing the technical fallacies in the original comment. Now let us humans get on with the actual conversation.
- colechristensen 7y agoFake thanks are not appreciated, nor are suggestions that it is inhuman to want to have discussions based on sound reasoning instead of irrelevant nonsense. Raise the bar of discussion.
- kaolti 7y agoA discussion is based on the mutual agreement that we'll try to understand THE POINT on what the other person is trying to say. When someone fails to do that and proceeds to pick apart minutia I consider that a waste of time - quite interesting that you consider that the highest standard of discussion and sound reasoning.
- victords 7y agoIf you're pointing out the argument fallacies, you should at least name the negative effects and provide some argument/proof.
- Fricken 7y agoIt's much more fun and easy to tear apart someone else's argument than to build your own.
- mistermann 7y ago>> Why over complicate it by trying to “extract” the psilocybin instead of treating it like marijuana and growing the mushrooms in highly controlled settings and then testing for potency?! > There are negative side effects from consuming the mushrooms which you don't get from purified psilocybin. True. However, are these negative side effects significant enough that purified psilocybin is a necessity, in all cases? If so, what are these negative side effects, and is there significant net evidence (that includes degree of ~harm) sufficient to form a strong conclusion that purified psilocybin is a necessity, that does not also include personal opinions/judgements of persons other than an informed patient? > Dosage is important. Sure, to a degree. However, is there sufficient net evidence that dosage precision (above that which can be achieved via simpler approaches) necessitates the usage of purified psilocybin? If so, can you link this evidence? > There isn't a way to test for potency which would ensure a reliable dose. See above. > Argument fallacies: > * your anecdotal positive experiences When dealing with compounds whose effects are extremely phenomenological and inconsistent/variable between applications, anecdotal experiences seem not only valid, but mandatory for proper scientific study. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychedelic_experience#Basic_phenomenology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychedelic_experience#Basic_p... > * suggesting superiority because something is "from nature" Framing advocacy for traditional, simple, affordable, and well-tested approaches as ~"illogical appeals to nature" is also a fallacy, and can be worse. (Not saying you're personally doing this, just as you aren't accusing anyone in particular for the fallacies you have listed). > * referring to "mistakes from the past" without naming any Perfectly fine. But let's not pretend all sides in debates aren't often guilty of this sort of behavior. > * suggesting superiority that "has been (done) for thousands of years" Implying that a long track record of success is irrelevant is also a fallacy, as is framing a reference to this track record as "fallacious". > Think about why these kinds of arguments are made on different topics which you disagree with and then rethink why you are making them here. I would suggest you rethink whether that accusation is objectively true, based on the literal words written, as opposed to your subconscious mind's interpretation of the words. I would also suggest you rethink the quality and validity of your ~rejection of the parent's relatively innocuous suggestion, and also contemplate whether this level of thinking and discourse is appropriate for the gravity of the topic being discussed, and consistent with the principles of objective rationality and truthfulness this forum proclaims to uphold.
- phkahler 7y agoThe singular of data is not anecdote. This is a common common tactic used to reject people's personal experience.
- ebcode 7y agoThe singular of data is "datum", for those out there wondering.
- ericmcer 7y agoYour argument is logical I guess, but we are not logical creatures and I prefer to make the choice to live in a more magical/spiritual world. Why wouldn't you? We end up in the dirt either way.
- oarabbus_ 7y ago>There are negative side effects from consuming the mushrooms which you don't get from purified psilocybin. Such as? It tastes bad? Mild gastrointestinal effects (which can happen with various psychedelic substances even without ingesting the fungus scaffolding)? > suggesting superiority because something is "from nature" Obviously something being natural does not make it better. Neither does something synthetic mean it's superior. Additionally, this probably comes from marinol/dronabinol - while marijuana has one of the best safety profiles of any substances, extracted THC does not. Organic magic mushrooms have an exceptionally high (physical) safety profile (see Nutt et al, the Lancet 2007) whereas the same is not true for extracted psilocin. It's a bit ironic you're calling him out for fallacies while committing some yourself.