3 ms·
You can compare this philosophy to "Publish or Perish" in academia. Universities tell scholars if you don't "ship" (publish frequently, get citations), we fire
by 29athrowaway 7y ago
You can compare this philosophy to "Publish or Perish" in academia. Universities tell scholars if you don't "ship" (publish frequently, get citations), we fire you.
In that system, quantity is more important than quality. It's about pointless journals, conferences and citation rings, rather than actual research. "Publish or Perish" is about institutions trying to inflate their ranking, rather than fulfilling their original purpose: advance the frontiers of human knowledge.
Another example: When IBM projects paid engineers based on "kilos", or thousands of lines of code added, what was the result? millions of lines of pointless, redundant code. Bloated software that doesn't work and is impossible to maintain.
Another example: Stacked ranking/Vitality curve. The idea is simple: you evaluate each employee, producing a score. Then you rank all employees within a team. The lowest scoring 10% gets fired. Repeat every year... result? teams hire the worst employees they can, because that improves their chance of surviving the next stacked ranking iteration. Repeat for many years and you obtain an incompetent organization incapable of doing anything, full of toxic people.
If you use sprint velocity as your most important metric, the result will be a lot of redundant actions followed by corrective actions to undo those actions. It looks like a lot is getting done, but that's the same as saying that a truck driver driving in circles is productive based purely on fuel utilization, when in reality the guy is not going anywhere.
A perverse incentive, that's what it is. Want to have 0% crime rate? Have a population of zero, problem solved. Want to end elephant poaching? Kill all elephants, problem solved.
What is important is not only when you ship, but what you ship, and how you ship it. Don't upset your customers in the process of releasing changes. And keep the vital aspects of your product working...
https://youtu.be/XXBxV6-zamM?t=4072 https://youtu.be/XXBxV6-zamM?t=4072
- rusticpenn 7y agoMost of these problems can be curbed by pproper oversight and exception handling, however i also find that techniques based on empathy and trust tend to help longterm.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 29athrowaway 7y agoSo there are aspects of development that rank higher than shipping, right? That invalidates the "shipping is #1" credo. Sustained and sustainable growth is #1. Accountability is important, but being forced to ship a broken release is irrational.