3 ms·
The current daily case rate in South Korea has the whole population getting it after about 100 years (the post I saw said 141, I'm rounding). We should probabl
by maxerickson 7y ago
The current daily case rate in South Korea has the whole population getting it after about 100 years (the post I saw said 141, I'm rounding).
We should probably look for mitigations that are not economically harmful and keep them in place. Mask wearing seems to be one of them. Then we can use the time that gives us to look for treatments and maybe even a vaccine.
I wonder if you are giving any consideration of the economic consequences of the virus? Those are going to happen regardless of imposed lockdowns. There's a tweet about reservations at restaurants in Seattle declining 60% prior to the lockdown. That's plenty.
BTW, New York is nowhere near herd immunity. If you assume 1000 cases per death, they would have ~1 million people that have been infected. For a virus this contagious, you want 50-60% for herd immunity, not ~12%.
- ryankemper 7y ago> We should probably look for mitigations that are not economically harmful and keep them in place. Mask wearing seems to be one of them. Then we can use the time that gives us to look for treatments and maybe even a vaccine. Absolutely. > I wonder if you are giving any consideration of the economic consequences of the virus? Those are going to happen regardless of imposed lockdowns. There's a tweet about reservations at restaurants in Seattle declining 60% prior to the lockdown. That's plenty. Yes, I have given consideration to that, and I think your point is an important one. Basically, I draw a distinction between unavoidable economic impact due to covid itself (your example with restaurant reservations) versus self-inflicted economic damage (forcing closures rather than letting businesses decide for themselves, discouraging elective surgery in areas without a huge outbreak which has led to incredible job loss/furloughs in the medical sector) > BTW, New York is nowhere near herd immunity. If you assume 1000 cases per death, they would have ~1 million people that have been infected. For a virus this contagious, you want 50-60% for herd immunity, not ~12%. Right, hitting the "herd immunity" threshold is great, but the important point is that any marginal increase in recovered cases leads to reduced transmission, even if it does not lead to containment the way "full" herd immunity does. Per your point, if we stick with that 1000:1 estimate (which honestly I think is within an order of magnitude of the true number), that implies we're only 2, maybe 3 "doublings" away from herd immunity in New York. (Let me know if you see an issue with that logic). By comparison, in my home state of California, we currently have 1000 deaths which we would expand to 1 million cases using that same 1000:1 ratio, whereas our population is about 40 million, so we have an implied 2.5% herd immunity
- dragonwriter 7y ago> For a virus this contagious, you want 50-60% for herd immunity, not ~12%. We also don't know the degree or duration of immunity previous infection provides; we have both analytical reasons to expect and early expiremental evidence that prior infection provides some immunity in the near term, but one quote I've seen is that the level of information we have isn't enough to give us confidence beyond that it probably usually provides some degree of immunity for some period between 6 months and 60 years after infection, without knowing either the degree of protection or where in that range the usual duration falls.
- remote_phone 7y agoThe only measures that will prevent a large lockdown again in October are plentiful masks and plentiful hand sanitizer. So far I have seen neither. My estimate is that we have until August to get both is such high supply that people can buy them again and stock up, so that everyone wears them all the time and everyone can sanitize their hands at will. I think that may help in keeping the infection rates lower. Also we need real-time mass testing capabilities. Without all of these I can pretty much guarantee that the only weapon we have is lockdowns and there will be another one come flu season, possibly through Christmas until February/March. This is mainly because we won’t be able to tell the difference between the flu and Covid-19 fast enough.
- anoncareer0212 7y agoThere's no reason to expect any seasonal dependency given south Asia's experience, is there another reason you expect it to go away for months and come back later?