8 ms·
The smallest large display would be projected straight onto your retina
- rolph 7y agosomething interesting for the wearables sector. I thought this would go along with it for safety sake: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22634890 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22634890
- User23 7y agoThe prospect of ciliary muscle atrophy (or exhaustion) from longer term use of this is pretty scary. I wonder if they're considering how to abate that.
- krenzo 7y agoHow do you deal with ciliary muscle exhaustion from staring at a computer screen for extended periods?
- User23 7y agoCorrective lenses to abate the resultant myopia. But you already knew that, so can you maybe elaborate to make your point in a more intellectually nourishing way?
- growlist 7y agoI'm glad you said abate and not ablate.
- newsbinator 7y agoI guess the ultimate version of this is figuring out how to get your brain to generate the right image via direct simulation of the visual cortex, without painting anything on your retina at all.
- lucb1e 7y agoIs that just a "that would be cool" or do you know of research into this (even so much as a feasibility study)?
- blhack 7y agoThis is what neuralink is doing.
- enchiridion 7y agoThey are specifically focusing on the visual cortex?
- mhh__ 7y agoI would keep an eye on Valve. I don't think they're anywhere near doing it yet but Gabe Newell heavily implied that he wants to steer Valve in this direction in his recent interview about Half Life: Alyx on IGN.
- willis936 7y agoThere’s lots of stuff on BCI. People have been pursuing it for a decades and technology is maturing into handling the quantity of data. The limiting factor is the (apparently) obvious: skulls are thick. You get a terribly weak signal through a skull. Who’s going to get a sub-skull implant so they can play VRChat 2?
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoI'm not sure if there is a good short primer on Retinal Displays or not, but I don't think this is it. As the article itself outlines, it's been decades of research and we haven't really been able to make any practical progress yet. There are a lot of reasons for this that are as much social as they are technical. At my previous company a few years ago we took a crack at a concept [1], but never got it off the ground because prototype costs were in the millions and there are only a few places that we could source the kind of hardware you need to build these things. Last I checked in 2017, Oculus/Facebook was making the most progress on this but even then were having trouble miniaturizing things. I'm really curious where they are with it. [1] https://pdfaiw.uspto.gov/.aiw?docid=20180131926&SectionNum=1&IDKey=363814FA3947&HomeUrl=http://appft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1%2526Sect2=HITOFF%2526d=PG01%2526p=1%2526u=%25252Fnetahtml%25252FPTO%25252Fsrchnum.html%2526r=1%2526f=G%2526l=50%2526s1=%25252220180131926%252522.PGNR.%2526OS=DN/20180131926%2526RS=DN/20180131926 https://pdfaiw.uspto.gov/.aiw?docid=20180131926&SectionNum=1...
- qznc 7y agoSounds like we wait for some technologies to reduce the prototype cost by two orders of magnitude. What makes it so costly?
- mojomark 7y ago> What makes it so costly? I've seen this question a few times, so I'll try to address... Yes, you can take a bi-axial rastor scanning MEMS mirror (similar to what Microvision uses in their Pico projector, or those supplied by Mirrorcle), shine it into your pupil (at the appropriate) distance and BAM!, you have a point source VRD. However, I would heed the warning on Microvisions Pico projector as those ARE NOT eye safe lasers. It is nit difficult, however, to get your hands on eyesafe laser sources suitable for VRD. However, with this simple device your FOV will be limited by the angular range of your MEMS. Your resolution will be limited by the pulse width of your synchronized laser. Most importantly though is that the exit pupil (eyebox) is very small such that when you move your eyeball a few degrees, the image will start to disappear. So, you need redundant point sources to expand the FOV and also expand the eyebox to permit eye rotation. These point sources must be spaced in a matrix of less than 2mmx2mm (the typical minimum dilation of the pupil in bright ambient settings). That's a lot of point sources, so if you try to just use a bunch of MEMS mirrors, the driving electronics will generally occlude your natural view of the environment. That's not a problem for video see-through displays, but for optical see-through displays that's a deal breaker. So, you're back to trying to disassociate the light beam point sources from the scanning-driver electronics. The typical strategy is to use some sort of waveguide - to transport the light beam (for a given portion to the image) through a transparent material (e.g. glass), then get that beam to outcouple from the waveguide at the precise location, then have that light beam continue to raster scan. Now you need to do that for, a few hundred light beams (per eye!) to fully fill the natural human FOV with a composite image greater than 35 pixels per degree (for text readability) All of the above items are achievable, but it requires precision optics and alignment to get everything working in harmony. Add the component of affordability, and you've got a pretty big engineering challenge on your hand. I'm sure someone can do it. This is just one viable path to truly transformative AR displays, but I think it's the most promising.
- jcims 7y agoSeems like this is something that could eventually be placed onto a contact lens (maybe just the reflective part) to help with alignment. Also I wonder if a lightfield concept could be used to allow the lens in your eye to focus the image so you don't get that weird 'permanently in focus' effect that has to be somewhat jarring.
- gaze 7y agoSo the power from the optical system is spread over the retina by the MEMS mirrors. What happens if the laser stays on and one or both of the scanners stops?
- willis936 7y agoThis is the first scary question that everyone asks with these devices, because the answer is "you burn a hole in your retina". It is an inherent danger in the system, but I would be interested in reading a full risk analysis on this type of system. Industrial processes always have risk analysis and avoidance, with failsafe for all possible failure modes being desired. I wonder what kind of hardware failsafes you could put into this. You never, under any circumstances, want to burn someone's eye. But you also don't want someone's expensive toy to brick itself because they jumped with it on.
- mcguire 7y agohttps://journal.burningman.org/2015/03/black-rock-city/tales-from-the-playa/theres-a-black-dot-in-the-middle-of-everything-i-see/ https://journal.burningman.org/2015/03/black-rock-city/tales...
- krenzo 7y agoThat is a failure that could potentially result in damage to the eye. MEMS mirrors have built-in angle sensors, and when these report that there's irregular or no detected movement in one or both directions, the lasers are turned off. The lasers in a MEMS mirror near-eye display operate in the microwatt range. Low power laser pointers operate in the milliwatt range, and the safety mechanism for those is that your eyelid is expected to shut to block off the laser in less than a second. Therefore, you have more time to shut your eyelids or remove your eye from the MEMS mirror display if there's a failure and the lasers fail to shut off.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoYou close your eyes immediately and take the glasses off, just like when an errant sunlight reflection hits your eyes just right.
- bodhibyte 7y agoVirtual Retinal Displays (VRD) have been around for a while (1). More recently entering the consumer market. I didn't see the article mention the Avegant Glyph (2) 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_retinal_display https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_retinal_display 2. https://avegant.com/video-headset https://avegant.com/video-headset Edit: formatting
- OkGoDoIt 7y agoFor (2), it looks cool but there’s no way to order it and the website doesn’t look updated since it won that award at CES 2017. I’ve seen so many of these headsets over the years that exhibit at CES and then are never heard from again. I’ll believe it when I see it in real life.
- entropicdrifter 7y agoA DLP projector for your retinas. Cool concept. I bet the parts are cheaper than the equivalent laser setup.
- errantspark 7y agoLooks like they're dead, I wonder if the MEMS latency issues killed it.
- russdill 7y agoAvegant just has you looking at a DLP "screen". There's nothing special or magic about it. Each mirror/pixel you look at is either reflecting laser light or not reflecting laser light.
- grawprog 7y agoWhat kind of health issues would this type of technology cause? I can't see it being very good for your eyes to have them focused on lasers being projected directly into them into at extremely close range for long periods of time on a regular basis.
- jjoonathan 7y agoThe dose makes the poison.
- grawprog 7y agoFor acute poisoning. You're forgetting chronic poisoning, such as heavy metal poisoning. Which is more what I was talking about, low exposure levels over regular long term periods. Regular screens and displays cause eye strain and retina damage over long terms as it is.
- jjoonathan 7y agoNo, I'm not forgetting chronic poisoning. The dose makes the poison, acute or chronic. That's especially true for heavy metals.
- banachtarski 7y agoYour eyeballs are being bombarded with photons emitted by the sun and your monitor right now as we speak. Furthermore, you're perpetually bathed in cosmic background radiation. A "laser" just means that the emitted photons are phase synchronized, but says nothing about the intensity. The range is also irrelevant. For a radially emitting source, intensity scales as the inverse squared distance, but assuming you control the output, it's a moot point.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI'd also be concerned about, what happens if something goes wrong? What happens if there's some sort of power delivery issue, and the laser burns far too bright just for an instant before dying? Is that an unfounded concern?
- hnitbanalns 7y agoI found it somewhat ironic that this post is below the post titled, "Ask HN: I'm a software engineer going blind, how should I prepare?"
- entropicdrifter 7y agoI'm surprised nobody's mentioned Magic Leap: https://www.theverge.com/2018/8/8/17662040/magic-leap-one-creator-edition-preview-mixed-reality-glasses-launch https://www.theverge.com/2018/8/8/17662040/magic-leap-one-cr...
- 29athrowaway 7y agoAlternatively, use your optic nerve or visual cortex.
- voltron101 7y agoI would be really interested in the visual correction opportunities offered by this kind of technology. I suffer from a rare cornea disease called Pellucid Marginal Degeneration that results in a very disfigured cornea. It would be amazing to have a pair of glasses that scan your cornea for abnormalities, and then adjust the angles at which photons hit your eye in a way that "cancels out" the astigmatic abnormalities.
- benibela 7y agoThat is what I am interested in too. I have 3 diopters astigmatism. Or more, the optometrists have trouble measuring it, their measurement fluctuates between 2.5 and 3.5 diopters. If the glasses just slip a little, I can hardly read anything. I hope I do not develop anything worse. My father had keratoconus.
- Mizza 7y agoSaying this, I feel a bit like somebody in the 1800s saying they don't want to board a train because they don't want to suffocate, but here it is: I don't want any lasers shone directly into my eyeballs because I don't want to go blind.
- pasabagi 7y agoWell, it is definitely one of those technologies where it doesn't pay to be an early (first decade) adopter. For all those people who wouldn't board a train, there were also people who didn't take their cocaine prescriptions, lick their radium paintbrushes, or take their thalidomide.
- russdill 7y agoExcellent reality check "Lasers Are Not Magic" http://doc-ok.org/?p=1386 http://doc-ok.org/?p=1386 "Can I make a full-field-of-view AR or VR display by directly shining lasers into my eyes?" -- No.
- twodave 7y agoImmediately thought of the Bosch Light Drive[0] product when I saw this. There's been no news since they were unveiled, though, as far as I can tell... [0] https://www.bosch-sensortec.com/products/optical-microsystems/smartglasses-light-drive/ https://www.bosch-sensortec.com/products/optical-microsystem...
- joyj2nd 7y ago"The smallest large display would be projected straight onto your retina" Bosch, yes. I am 100% sure I have read about it before on Ycombinator. https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/consumer-electronics/gadgets/bosch-ar-smartglasses-tiny-eyeball-lasers https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/consumer-electronics/gad...
- SeanFerree 7y agoCool article!
- pensatoio 7y agoI won’t be an early adopter, but this technology has been a source of great fascination and excitement for me, and I look forward to the day it becomes a mainstream reality.
- josephpmay 7y agoVRDs sound great in theory, but the more you learn about them the more you realize that they aren't the right solution for the problem. Compared to other AR optics approaches, they're vastly more expensive, more dangerous, and have more limitations to overcome. For example, a VRD will only display if your eyes are looking in one direction (see the North glasses), so a VRD-based headset would need eye tracking (and vastly more complex optics to move the image around) for basis use. Diffractive optics can achieve much better effects at a fraction of the cost and without any risk.