4 ms·
I'm a Googler in Ads. This is a multi-faceted issue and there are tons of legitimate points on both its criticism and defense but IMO the backlash itself is des
by summerlight 7y ago
I'm a Googler in Ads. This is a multi-faceted issue and there are tons of legitimate points on both its criticism and defense but IMO the backlash itself is deserved, especially for a number of anti-competitive business practices. But probably the exact same criticism can be applied to Apple, Amazon and Microsoft so I consider this to be more of a general tech sector problem where network effects tend to be amplified by its nature and perhaps better handled by regulations.
For privacy perspective, I'm not very satisfied with the status quo, but at least for Ads, privacy is now the top priority with a strict deadline so the situation may get improved. But I still think collecting less (or no) user data solves just a part of the problem; users still don't have understanding on what the real trade-off between their privacy and benefits to themselves/the overall web ecosystem from the ads they're watching is. Without this information, users cannot really make informed arguments and decisions on their privacy and ads. IMO, this is one of the fundamental reason of having significant discrepancies on the ads' perception across many people. But as this is not just a technical problem like 3rd party cookie but more of a subjective issue, this might be a much harder problem to tackle though.
- forsakenharmony 7y agoWhat's your opinion on advertising in general? I kinda consider ads a violation of human rights, given they're literally made to influence your decision making, therefore taking away a bit of your free will
- summerlight 7y agoWell, almost every aspects in human civilization try to affect your behavior and I think a translation of this into a binary question of free will is very likely over-simplification. Historical arguments on free will has been a very complex one and prone to errors, so I wouldn't step into this landmine. Beside of free-will arguments, I'm seeing the huge (both positive and negative) impacts of ads on both societal and economical aspects and there's no real practical way to make it undone, it's pretty important to guide it to the right way. Yes, you can argue that it's better not to have it from the first moment but it's not the reality so the only option is making it better.