6 ms·
I have a point to make that I feel intersects the conversations here. It concerns something I didn't figure out until I was older, that children are brought in
by WarOnPrivacy 7y ago
I have a point to make that I feel intersects the conversations here.
It concerns something I didn't figure out until I was older, that children are brought into existence w/o their consent.
Now I don't believe this is* (edit: fixed) an evil or unethical act; it's simply an unavoidable facet of reality. However, it creates a debt to children so massive, that it can't be fully repaid in a lifetime.
In short, the debt between children & parents only ever runs one way.
Because of this, I have a permanent & total obligation to my kids' well being, while they in-turn owe me nothing for a lifetime of labor on their belhaf (which as a single parent - changing diapers & earning income - has been substantial).
It doesn't mean my grown kids should or shouldn't contribute to my welfare. It means that my responsibility is to continually tip the scales toward the outcomes they desire.
In our case we operate as one household & there are different obligations in play there. But the Original Debt indicates that any shortfalls (in labor, etc) be filled by me, unless & until more practical solutions are worked out.
My reward is that this really efficient mindset solves lots of problems in advance.
- sintaxi 7y agoI think the word you are looking for is duty, not debt.
- jacobolus 7y agoThe words “duty” and “debt” (and “due”) are more or less the same idea, and both derived from the latin "debere". You can think of “duty” as more or less a smoothed out version of “debt-ity”.
- WarOnPrivacy 7y agoThat's elegant.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- normalnorm 7y agoWell said. I believe this to be the fundamental realization that would change the world for the better, if enough people had it. So many of the ills of the world can be traced back to childhood trauma and mediocre education. I think we have been going through a few decades where mainstream parenting values have been mostly narcissistic. Parents seeing their children as indebted to them is both the norm and an abomination. I have some hope that more and more people are seeing things as you do.
- resu_nimda 7y agoIt seems like a lot of people get married and have kids just because it's the thing people do. Which I guess you can't really fault them for, but it is the root of a lot of society's problems as you say. I think it's great that my generation is seeing lower marriage rates and people waiting until later, I optimistically interpret that as a sign that people are starting to bring more intention into those decisions. Here's a hot take: In a generation or two, once the technology matures, we'll start seeing a lot of people opting (themselves or their children) into reversible sterilization, and it will soon become the norm.
- WarOnPrivacy 7y ago> It seems like a lot of people get married and have kids just because it's the thing people do. Which I guess you can't really fault them for, but it is the root of a lot of society's problems as you say. My case would support your supposition because I was distressingly incompetent in my early 20s. I wasn't a prize at 28 (my first born) either but at least I was at a point where I could form better expectations for myself. Past that, I find most young people today to be measurably more balanced & competent human beings than my generation was. I have strong confidence in their abilities to guide little people. To be clear tho, even in my generation I was a terrible outlier.
- manigandham 7y agoFamilies, especially children, also add purpose and fulfillment to life that is otherwise missing for many. On the contrary, it seems the breakdown of the strong family unit is causing most of the problems of society.
- hinkley 7y agoIn my opinion, Sydney Poitier’s rebuke of his father in Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner should be Chapter 1 Verse 1 of any book on parenting. What your parents sacrificed for you should be repaid in kind to your kids, not back to your parents. If you don’t have kids, pay it to society.
- WarOnPrivacy 7y agoThat's a solid philosophy.
- brandnewlow 7y agoThank you for this. Powerful stuff: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTgahyvBMk4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTgahyvBMk4
- duk 7y agoThank you for this. I will watch this scene whenever I act as if I "own" my kids.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- konschubert 7y agoMy kids owe me nothing because I chose to have kids, but they didn’t choose to have parents.
- bing_dai 7y agoPlease help me with the logic here: "It concerns something I didn't figure out until I was older, that children are brought into existence w/o their consent. Now I don't believe this is* (edit: fixed) an evil or unethical act; it's simply an unavoidable facet of reality. However, it creates a debt to children so massive, that it can't be fully repaid in a lifetime." I wonder, why does "my kid didn't consent to be born" mean "I owe him/her?" Is the implication that being alive is a bad thing?
- randoglando 7y agoThe implication is you (the parent) get to decide whether the child being alive is a good/bad thing (for the child). It is in your (the parent's) hands, so you better do the right thing and make it good for that person (the child).
- WarOnPrivacy 7y ago> I wonder, why does my kid didn't consent to be born mean I owe him/her? - From the principle standpoint, the alternatives saddle kids with unearned obligations, that are entirely the result of some adult's choices. This is unethical, while a better perspective is within reach. - From a practical perspective, there are 2 alternatives (to the principle I espouse): 1) No one owes anyone anything. Good luck newborn. Or... 2) Kids are obligated to repay the debt of their own upbringing ("I raised you so you owe me"). I would hope the obnoxiousness of this thinking would be self-evident. Unfortunately, I've encountered it a lot. I've believed it myself to some degree. However, I've not seen any evidence that this thinking benefits anyone in a meaningful way. Instead, I've seen it behind countless adults' efforts to belittle and devalue children - as part of misguided attempts to bully kids into some desired behavior. It's terrible. We need to let it go. > Is the implication that being alive is a bad thing? Not at all. Some events are neither fair nor unfair but come with tons of responsibility. Ultimately the question is who is the best fit to bear that responsibility and to what degree. Considering all possible scenarios, I think the wisest answer is this: The resources of upbringing should be provided by the parents, in total, unconditionally and in perpetuity. Obviously, all parents need help with this.
- darepublic 7y ago
- Waterluvian 7y agoI asked my dad about this. His answer was, (paraphrased) "We don't even come close to even with all the joy you and your brothers gave your mom and I. And now with grandkids you're paying out more than ever!" And I get what he means. I have two toddlers and they're positively exhausting. But I've never before felt joy like this. They give my life very very clear purpose when before I was a bit lost.
- TTPrograms 7y agoInterestingly, this perspective (which I also subscribe to, broadly speaking) resolves one of the core paradoxes with utilitarian philosophies - if you believe the moral value of existing has any positive value with respect to not existing, then you would have a moral obligation to have as many children as possible. This is resolved if you believe that existence is at least capable of having less "moral value" than non-existence for some life experiences.
- triyambakam 7y agoI am Hindu and in Hinduism the perspective is that all beings choose to be born into this world. I just thought I'd offer a common (in terms of Earth population and number of Hindus) counter perspective
- WarOnPrivacy 7y agoI considered this because my faith also believes it. Regardless, I believe the principle stands on it's own. Meanwhile, I'm pondering the apparent conflict. To that end, these are some of the points I'm considering. 1) Children aren't generally able to fully embrace faith on it's own merits until they are young adults. Until then, their faith is mostly proxied thru their parents. 2) Children have no practical ability to repay debts. 3) Faiths that teach pure service as a calling tend to extend it to parenthood. 4) The principle I'm advocating is a principle to family and to society. More 4) In my experience, when a personal or societal principle appear to conflict w/ a religious principle, it's often due to an incomplete understanding of the principles in play. I found it is spiritually & ethically safe to allow those principles to co-exist in disharmony until greater knowledge reframes the conflict in a more solvable way. More 4 tl;dr ver) There is great risk in pushing immature conclusions - much less risk in holding inconsistent ones.
- john4532452 7y agoNot true. The varna system advocated by the vedas the holy books of Hinduism is all about the division of laborers(not labor). Its the foundation for the caste system, where privilege is based on birth and even education is restricted to kings only be allowed to the priestly caste. Only after the invasion of British this has changed. The kings were okay with this because they don't have competition for their place. This hierarchy of social ladder worked because of the privilege one gets by birth over those under the hierarchy.
- triyambakam 7y agoWell firstly, the varna system doesn't change the Hindu perspective that one chooses one's birth. If you believe the mis-information about the varna system (which I explain below), then it just means that you believe you chose to be born into the cast that you are. That still lines up with the core tenets of Hinduism, that one chooses one's birth based on the ripe karmas. However, what you have shared about the varna system is false. The original caste system - the varna dharma - simply means that at different stages of life and different people more naturally express ways of serving society - some are workers, some are business people, some are warriors, some are priests. The Vedas do not declare that this is fixed through one's whole life or even determined by one's lineage. A brahmin (priest caste) does not need to be born from brahmin parents, but people have distorted the varna dharma to mean that brahmins must be from a brahmin family, and that brahmins should be above others in status. All the casts are equal, but they are not the same. The British further abused the caste system and perpetuated this false understanding of it for their own benefit. They encouraged the castes to remain fixed through one's life and be base on lineage. This is not the original way. The Vedas actually tell us that castes are fluid through one's life and not based on which family one was born into.
- javert 7y ago> it creates a debt to children so massive, that it can't be fully repaid in a lifetime. This is just an idea you made up. It has no more grounding in reality than some old rule from the Bible that nobody follows anymore. Like one of those old rules, it's just an arbitrary assertion. When we make moral assertions we need to be just as scrupulous as scientists who can only properly assert something when they have evidence. And for the same reasons. It's a matter of intellectual hygiene. I understand that many parents love their children immensely. But there is a gap between that, and the moral imperative you are asserting. You can spend a lifetime helping your children if you love them that much, and that is perfectly rational. But it does not create this universal moral imperative.
- WarOnPrivacy 7y ago> "it creates a debt to children so massive, that it can't be fully repaid in a lifetime." > This is just an idea you made up. I'd agree that it's a bit on the melodramatic side and it'd be fair to call it arbitrary. However, I offer that the sentiment behind it is honest. It works against the common assumption that kids owe their parents for their upbringing (If you feel I made that up then I can't help you here). I propose that common assumption leads to no beneficial outcome and that it's main purpose is to demean & degrade kids (children & adult) - to bully them into some sort of compliant behavior. That's the core behind the principle. If there's fault in my overall reasoning, this is where I'd recommend you look.
- javert 7y ago> However, I offer that the sentiment behind it is honest. No doubt about that. I think the sentiment behind it is that you love your kids greatly. > I propose that common assumption leads to no beneficial outcome I agree, but your principle is pretty similar to the one you are criticizing. They are two sides of the same coin. Neither principle is grounded in empirical reality. Both can lead to bad outcomes. > If there's fault in my overall reasoning, this is where I'd recommend you look. I mean, to be clear, I think the fault in your reasoning is to try to create a universal moral imperative based on an emotion you feel about your own kids. There is a gap there. That is not a justified move. Universal moral imperatives would have to be better grounded than that (just like scientific claims have to).
- throwaway122378 7y agoThat’s a negative even depressing way of looking at it. Life is a beautiful miracle with a extraordinary low probability that any one person would be born let alone survive. As parents we (in partnership with whatever natural or supernatural being coordinates nature) bring that gift to our children. The rest is spot on. We owe it to them to make this a better world. ... but indebted sounds so negative.
- orestarod 7y agoMany parents do feel as if the kids have a debt towards them. If someone thinks that way, it is as if they think their relationship with their children in a business way. THAT is the negative and depressing way of looking at it. The catch is, even if we are to see the parent-child relationship as business, then the "debt" lies entirely to the parents. In the good occasion, that does not happen, and the relationship is healthy. And if you, yourself, put yourself in debt of your children, it doesn't seem bad things come out of it. It's you making the decision for yourself, after all. Not inflicting it on someone else.
- dennisgorelik 7y ago> I have a permanent & total obligation to my kids' well being Such attitude makes it significantly less likely to have kids in the first place: why would a potential parent want to get in debt? If we want to decrease population of humans, then spreading "parents owe to their kids" attitude is one of the ways to accomplish that.
- WarOnPrivacy 7y ago> Such attitude makes it significantly less likely to have kids in the first place: why would a potential parent want to get in debt? That might depend on how much value they place on their own life and upbringing. >If we want to decrease population of humans, then spreading "parents owe to their kids" attitude is one of the ways to accomplish that. Some things are what they are. This is the reality that's left when the harmful & unproductive assumptions are stripped away. I believe you are right that some less courageous folks will be discouraged when faced with this. That's okay too. Folks who opt out of parenthood shouldn't be thought less of.
- orestarod 7y agoIf anything, people make kids to extract immense satisfaction out of it. But to think people will not have kids because of the "debt" philosophy is unrealistic. The truth is, most people would not even have sex at all, were it not for the massive instinctive drive. It's that much of a hassle to find and hold a partner, even more so have kids, and that's not even taking your relationship with your kids into account. If one is daunted from having kids, their train of thought will not even reach the debt part.
- dennisgorelik 7y agoMost people are at "lukewarm" level with their desire to have kids. If you add the idea of "getting into debt to your children" to the mix -- it tilts the balance to "let's postpone having kids until later" (that "later", usually, does not arrive).
- john4532452 7y agoThat is the philosophy i live by. I am from india and When i was a child i was always made to feel guilty of not studying hard as my parents are sacrificing for me. I never wanted to marry but was forced again guilty trapping.Even compared to other asian countries, in india this mentality is very strong. This is mostly due to the religious conditioning enforcing the belief everybody in a society has a role to fulfill.
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoSounds like because loving children is a crime in USA, you're trying to rationalize it in the form of mercantilism.
- abetterday 7y agoFrom behind Rawls' veil of ignorance, how many children would choose not to be born if given that choice? It is at least as reasonable to say that they've been given a most precious of gifts as it is to say that they were forced in to it. And if they'd really rather not exist no one can take away from them the choice to end their life. That few would say this is really an option should balance the perspective that being born is a forced burden. The perspective of life as an infinite gift gives parents some justification for authoritarianism which some will abuse. The perspective of being forced into it gives children some justification for entitlement which some will abuse. I think it is harder to get children to not abuse a free pass and I think that parents have a better claim overall. But parents using it is a terrible practice that will backfire. Parents need to earn respect and compliance without relying on the trump card of 'i made you'. It is up to the children to decide what obligations they have towards their parents later on. And this should mostly be a function of raising considerate and capable people with maximal possible buy-in. I agree that the bulk of children's debt is to society and their own children. But this requires a sense of fairness to notice the debt and the capability to repay it. Parents have a crucial role to play in developing these.
- novok 7y agoThat is the western way to think about kids I've noticed. In many asian cultures, it's inverted. You owe your parents an infinite debt for bringing you into existence and supporting you. Either way, I think the entire debt concept is toxic, creating guilt on either side. You're family and you help each other in many ways and nobody really has a debt to another.
- dflock 7y ago.. or maybe it's both at the same time - we each owe each other a debt that we can never repay, but they cancel each other out precisely, so we owe nothing.