3 ms·
> All we have is history to go on and the fact that new jobs have always replaced old ones. I've always been a little skeptical of this. We all know that the o
by gwern 16y ago
> All we have is history to go on and the fact that new jobs have always replaced old ones.
I've always been a little skeptical of this. We all know that the official unemployment rate is a bit misleading as it only counts those actively looking for work, but I suspect historical comparisons show that it's even more misleading than we think.
Let's go back to the 1800s, when technology hadn't yet, according to the Luddite hypothesis, put tons of people out of work.
Back then, retirement didn't exist. So bam, now we've got one segment of the population who are employed. Schooling went to high school at most and higher education was only a tiny fraction of the population. So there's another large segment of the population employed, all those who would be stuck in school now. Basically everyone who is now in undergraduate or graduate school would have been out working a job.
And of course, child labor was legal, so that implies an awful lot of jobs there too. And what about all those people with Downs syndrome or other forms of retardation or mental illness? They were all down on the farm helping with the baling or something. (Just counting the kids in special ed, and not all the adults, there's like 6 million of them: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_education_in_the_United_States#Classification http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_education_in_the_United... )
Now surely some of all of that is necessary to keeping a modern economy running rather than an 1800s one. But how much of that is just killing time or keeping people out of the employment market? Thought experiment: if a fairy suddenly granted all the kids and students and retirees an education and credentials to match (all 20 or 50 million or whatever of them), how many years would it take the market to absorb them and match them up with jobs? Would it ever?