4 ms·
Interestingly, if the Chinese reported numbers turn out to be even a little accurate, then I'm changing my mind from natural to lab accident. I'd love to see s
by roenxi 7y ago
Interestingly, if the Chinese reported numbers turn out to be even a little accurate, then I'm changing my mind from natural to lab accident.
I'd love to see some reasonable estimates on how bad the outbreak in China really was. How exactly does a country with no warning of what is about to happen get away with case numbers that aren't in the 10s of millions?
Such a reponse isn't impossible - maybe they were on high alert after SARS - but given what is happening in Europe and the States there are a lot of questions about what exactly happened/is happening in China and what the timeline was. It is difficult to organise against an unexpected exponential process in the time they claim they did.
- kaesar14 7y agoEspecially as the outbreak was happening during the New Year.
- yomly 7y agoWell my anecdotal observation was that the population themselves knew the drill. The second they heard "SARS" they didn't need government permission to social distance or wear masks. My in-laws stayed put and didn't see relatives over CNY. That is madness, imagine trying to cancel Christmas in Europe. There were rule breakers and people who found lockdown difficult and in those instances the CCP tool kit was more adapted to crushing those types of responses: Roads leaving Wuhan were literally dug up, the govt had a surveillance network already operational, and non Wuhan people were encouraged/happy to snitch on people who left Wuhan during the lockdown and its run up and get them sent back. Meanwhile outside of Wuhan, everyone also knew the drill. Before there were even double digit case numbers (detected) in other places, everyone knew to stay in. In policy setting, I'm told a single man is effectively calling the shots wrt the epidemiological response: Zhong Nanshan who is accepted in Asia as being the granddaddy of SARS This is markedly different from my observations of how it progressed in the "Western" world. It has been surreal to see Italy, France, Spain, UK, US and now possibly NZ + AUS follow similar progressions one by one after each other. In the UK, most people have been waiting for authority to tell them what to do, but the government themselves are indecisive and keep trying to place their faith in "evidence based" science - common sense be damned. Having watched this all play out being right but late is almost useless and this debate over mask usage is ridiculous. Meanwhile the NHS is covered in so much red tape that PPE and testing can't reach the frontline staff even when companies are trying to put them in their hands.
- fouc 7y agoCNY was Jan 25. The 1,000 bed wuhan hospitals that were built in 10 days started Jan 24. Lockdown was in effect weeks before.
- paganel 7y ago> Lockdown was in effect weeks before. Lockdown was in effect 2 days before, starting with January 23rd, not "weeks before". Some people in Wuhan knew about the virus weeks or even months before this (start of December), that is correct.
- yomly 7y agoYeah in and out of Wuhan. I came across the term "Wuhan Lung" a couple of weeks before CNY and it was affecting people as far away as in Thailand and a family friend caught it in Dubai around Jan 6th (and has since been tested for antibodies)
- throwaway_pdp09 7y ago> Meanwhile the NHS is covered in so much red tape that PPE and testing can't reach the frontline staff even when companies are trying to put them in their hands. I don't think it's NHS red tape so much as the government being bloody incompetent. They think they can rule by decree and have that shower down helpfully on the minions. Nope, you've got to get your hands dirty. I'm not impressed.
- yomly 7y agoNo I'm told the procurement staff of the NHS themselves are also very slow and very inflexible/unagile
- zizee 7y ago> and now possibly NZ + AUS follow similar progressions Where are you getting this from? All reports I have read show that NZ and Aus governments/people have acted quickly and effectively, and new infections are low in both countries.
- yurlungur 7y agoThis line of reasoning makes no sense at all. You are saying the Chinese response was too good/swift compared to the West and it proves a conspiracy. First issue with that is the Chinese response (lockdown) was not really swift at all. In fact, it was done about 2 months after patient 0, when there were hundreds of confirmed cases and filled hospitals. The impending outbreak was clear to experts including at least one from Hong Kong. If anything it was a rather slow reaction. The worse responses from parts of Europe and US can't prove anything aside from their own incompetence. Other Asian countries were able to contain it with less time, information, warning or help. Also, everyone knows the Chinese reported numbers are wildly inaccurate. Part of that is due to factors such as lack of testing capabilities. Add to that the various cover-ups throughout the process, especially at the beginning of the outbreak. Regardless, it's clear how the containment was able to work. It was by locking down the entire city (blocking roads and all public transit, much more strict than anything practiced anywhere else) when a few hundred cases were identified. Above all, all of that provides zero evidence for any origin theory of the virus. The lab theory was present right from the beginning, which seems unlikely since these viruses don't typically spread without an intermediate host. At the very least, proponent of this theory should be able to provide evidence that bats or viral samples from bats were present in the lab before the outbreak. If I'm not mistaken, this lab isn't really top secret since some American scientist apparently worked there, so at least some paper trails should be recoverable.
- jnbiche 7y ago> At the very least, proponent of this theory should be able to provide evidence that bats or viral samples from bats were present in the lab before the outbreak This is described for both labs that were doing bat research in published, peer-reviewed research in international scientific journals, by the researchers themselves from Wuhan Institute of Virology and Wuhan Centers for Disease Control. Sometimes in great detail. There's a lot of evidence out there. But I agree China's total response and/or numbers aren't really suggestive of either hypothesis.
- yurlungur 7y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5x_pIgvDLcg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5x_pIgvDLcg Is that so clear? This Dr. Peter Daszak, described as a coronavirus expert who apparently worked with the lab, said (4:50~) "There was no viral isolate in the lab, there was no cultured virus (..) anything related to SARS-COV2 so it's just not possible."