2 ms·
Ultimately this is the most important problem of our time, and not only did he not take it seriously, he trivialized it and then got the wrong answer without bo
by epistasis 7y ago
Ultimately this is the most important problem of our time, and not only did he not take it seriously, he trivialized it and then got the wrong answer without bothering to understand what he was dismissing.
It's amazing how strong politics is in our brains; it can override all sorts of rationality.
Fisher was a great statistician, but among many other inexcusable mistakes, he tried desperately to prove that smoking did not cause cancer. He wrote all sorts of junk science down that road. I think we will think of Dyson in similar ways in the future, but I'm not sure if the concepts that Dyson invented will be as long lasting as Fisher's.
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> Ultimately this is the most important problem of our time, and not only did he not take it seriously, he trivialized it and then got the wrong answer without bothering to understand what he was dismissing. Maybe he understood it far better than you or that internet creator Al Gore and his buddy Leonardo DiCaprio? > It's amazing how strong politics is in our brains; it can override all sorts of rationality. Indeed. The way one group clings to a political agenda with religious zeal and demands no one question it is quite astonishing. > I think we will think of Dyson in similar ways in the future, but I'm not sure if the concepts that Dyson invented will be as long lasting as Fisher's. This is why so many people despise the global warming zealots. The absolute pettiness. A better analogy would be the global warming "pro-science" zealots today with the eugenics "pro-science" zealots 100 years ago. 100 years ago, you'd be raising the alarm of how "inferior" races were a threat to humanity and demand eugenics/genocide/etc - all supported by "science" of course. The world didn't end like the zealots of 100 years ago predicted. And in 100 years, people are going to laugh at people like you like we laugh at eugenicists/nazis/etc today. And 100 years from now, people would still know Dyson. When "science" and politics get mixed, it isn't a good thing. Especially when it involves mindless zealotry.