3 ms·
Why isn't there a public open-source fund to finance open projects (ie one to which the donors have no clue or control where the funds will eventually go; they'
by anigbrowl 7y ago
Why isn't there a public open-source fund to finance open projects (ie one to which the donors have no clue or control where the funds will eventually go; they're disbursed on the basis of how widely something is used)?
- burrows 7y agoWhat does “public” mean in this context? And if you want this thing, why don’t you make it?
- samatman 7y agoEveryone knows that there's a huge gap between wanting something to exist, and wanting something to exist, while having the expertise, time, resources, and will, to bring it into existence. Since you know this as well as I do, I want to ask: what is your motive in asking this question?
- anigbrowl 7y agoPublic means non-profit and wholly transparent, explicitly dedicated to the creation and expansion of a software commons. It infuriates me that people who work on important projects like numpy or Tor which are very widely used have trouble paying the bills and keeping a roof over their head. I don't make it because I don't work in the software industry and don't have access to large social or financial capital networks. That sounds a bit like asking why someone who proposes a public policy idea doesn't just run for President.
- burrows 7y ago> It infuriates me that people who work on important projects like numpy or Tor which are very widely used have trouble paying the bills and keeping a roof over their head. Donate money to projects you care about. Persuade your friends to donate. > I don't make it because I don't work in the software industry and don't have access to large social or financial capital networks. What’s the plan for getting the doers onboard? Pay them? Persuade them to work for free? Persuade the government to tax someone else to fund them? Or are we just shouting about things we don’t like? Because let me tell you about low quality leather goods...
- Noos 7y agoThe problem is that this what you get when you make a commons without reciprocity or equality. Reciprocity means the producer/upkeeper and consumer each put something into the commons that balances out mutual needs. if only a few people can create or maintain, the many users must contribute in a lesser fashion to enable them. Equality means that everyone create or maintain, so the burden isn't shared on a small group. If we are all farmers, we can each handle a share of a common field. But this kind of commons is asymmetrical, and that's why you'll never see people pay the bills anywhere near close to the need. This kind of common can really only be noblesse oblige, where people with abundant resources give charity. It isn't, so people struggle.
- burrows 7y agoThe idea of "everyone" owning something, ie a commons, is a contradiction. If everyone owns it, then no one owns it. Assume the thing has exactly one owner. Then "reciprocity" and "equality" are addressed by the owner charging a fee to use the thing. Currency exchanged by consumers compensates the owner-operator's work.
- jzb 7y agoHow many people or organizations are likely to donate to a random project they’ve no idea if it’s something they use or care about?
- anigbrowl 7y agoPromoting free software in general means giving up that kind of micromanagement/ control maximization.
- EamonnMR 7y agohttps://my.fsf.org/donate/ https://my.fsf.org/donate/ https://sfconservancy.org/donate/ https://sfconservancy.org/donate/ https://www.apache.org/foundation/contributing.html https://www.apache.org/foundation/contributing.html https://opensource.org/donate https://opensource.org/donate https://www.linuxfoundation.org/about/donate/ https://www.linuxfoundation.org/about/donate/
- anigbrowl 7y agoThe FSF's total assets are less than $2m. Apache's under $5m. I mean something with billion $ capitalization instead of peanuts.
- mikeg8 7y agoProbably because the players who can amass a billion $ fund would rather put their money somewhere else. You're basically asking why is capitalism capitalism?
- fierarul 7y agoI assume you are aware Apache does not pay for any kind of software development. They only spend money on some minor infrastructure to have JIRA and the mailing lists and build servers running; plus administrative / legal personnel. All the new "Apache" software is written by volunteers, the mirror system is provided free by 3rd parties, code hosting is almost all on GitHub. So, what would they need the extra money for? Another JIRA instance? By comparison the FreeBSD foundation does hand out grants to fix parts of their OS which they deem relevant and in need. Would be nice to see something similar in other foundations.
- chrisco255 7y agoSee Gitcoin: https://gitcoin.co/landing https://gitcoin.co/landing
- anigbrowl 7y agoThis looks promising, thanks!
- throwaway092837 7y agoIndeed donations are far, far from enough. GPS, GSM, fiber optics, Internet, touchscreens, semiconductors, satellites, most of chemistry and aviation - all were researched and developed using taxpayer money. And it took billions. Now all public R&D is being destroyed and yet FLOSS fits exactly in the category. We desperately need large, global, R&D funding not some people throwing some bucks at patreon.