5 ms·
Yes, the NAND flash "decline" (for lack of better words) is sad to see, and it's as you said --- the only marketing spec people seem to care about with storage
by userbinator 7y ago
Yes, the NAND flash "decline" (for lack of better words) is sad to see, and it's as you said --- the only marketing spec people seem to care about with storage is capacity.
TLC and QLC are misnomers, a TLC cell holds 3 bits but has eight levels and QLC likewise 4 bits with 16 levels. You get a multiplicative increase in capacity for an exponential decrease in reliability. The manufacturers have been very obfuscatory with the marketing, since they know the inconvenient truth.
Does anyone still make a reasonably large (>100GB) SSD with good old 100K SLC? I have a 64MB (true 2^26 bytes capacity!) flash drive with 100K SLC; 0 bad blocks when it was new, and still 0 bad blocks a decade and a half later despite plenty of abuse.
- hakfoo 7y agoThis feels like it could be managed in firmware. It's been well established that many modern SSDs will use a large volume of the NAND in a SLC style mode for performance reasons, and only switch to MLC/TLC/QLC mode as the available space to do so runs down. I would be curious what effect that has on reliability-- if an individual QLC flash cell goes bad, is it still typically usable if you're using psuedo-SLC coding? To go a bit further, I'm amazed you don't see a drive manufacturer offering an enterprise-client "firmware builder" tool, or at least as a build-to-order service if you're a big enough client. I could see customers that wanted to respec their 1TB drives as, say, 750GB to ensure an abundance of over-capacity for reallocation later, or the YOLO "I'm gonna run the cheapest drives in RAID0" crowd slashing overprovisioning and getting 1050Gb out of the same unit. If you dialed down the capacity low enough, the drive could presumably stay in "use SLC mode only" mode for its entire duration.
- userbinator 7y agoThe main issue I have with increasingly complex firmware is that it's also a source of bugs; they might not show up in normal usage, but any unusual edge-cases that result in data loss are catastrophic. I'm amazed you don't see a drive manufacturer offering an enterprise-client "firmware builder" tool, or at least as a build-to-order service if you're a big enough client. If they do, you probably wouldn't hear about it --- and I suspect they do, given that there are things like this: https://superuser.com/questions/593303/hitachi-hard-drive-with-apple-firmware-possible-to-install-windows-on https://superuser.com/questions/593303/hitachi-hard-drive-wi...