4 ms·
> I'd like to see a demo like this on snow covered roads, with no lane markings visible. But humans can't drive well in those situations either. Why are you as
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> I'd like to see a demo like this on snow covered roads, with no lane markings visible.
But humans can't drive well in those situations either. Why are you asking for something better than humans can do?
- vardump 7y agoHumans can and regularly do so pretty safely. Ask Canadians, Swedes or any other people living in a location with long winters.
- draugadrotten 7y agoI was once driving on a road I could not see at all. It was at night, in a blizzard on the road from Denver to Vail. It didn't take long until I was following the two red lights of the bus in front of me. As a human, I knew I could drive safely where the bus had been driving seconds ago. A self-driving car would have... tell me.
- rossjudson 7y agoPulled over, like you should have done. I've been exactly where you were, driving the Coq highway in British Columbia at night in a blizzard, following two red dots in front of me. I had (mandatory) snow tires on a rear wheel drive BMW. I also had my family in the car. It was probably the single stupidest thing I've ever done driving a car.
- soared 7y agoYou can’t pull over in that situation unless you want to get your car stuck, be stuck in the cold all night, and potentially rear ended.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I was once driving on a road I could not see at all. It was at night, in a blizzard on the road from Denver to Vail. It didn't take long until I was following the two red lights of the bus in front of me. Perhaps you should have pulled over at this point? Maybe that's what an autonomous car would do.
- ghaff 7y agoPulling over in a snowstorm to the side of the highway can be pretty dangerous too. Once you're in that situation there aren't necessarily great alternatives.
- dev_tty01 7y agoYeah, I think people who believe that pulling over is an easy solution may not have been in one of these situations. It can come up quickly and there may be no exit for miles. Pull over into what? The snow bank on the side of the road? Now you are a hazard for everyone else coming along behind you. Sometimes you just have to make it work as best you can until the circumstances change.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhy is any traffic moving in conditions this bad? Just stop.
- dev_tty01 7y agoAgain, I assume you've never experienced this. Storms can come up fast in the mountains and be very localized. As I, and the previous poster mentioned, it can be more dangerous to stop sometimes.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIf you can't see, then it's always safest to just stop rather than driving on, potentially off the edge of a cliff.
- stale2002 7y agoHow about "Dont use the self driving mode during a snowstorm. Make the human drive". That sounds like it solves the situation nicely.
- 7y ago
- RandomBacon 7y agoAre you sure those two red lights can see and know where they are going?
- Jasper_ 7y agoI lived in Boston for 10 years. People drive on snow-covered roads just fine.
- chrisseaton 7y agoPeople in San Francisco struggle to drive in the rain let alone the snow.
- rootusrootus 7y agoHa, we joke about that in Oregon, too, and it rains quite a lot here. And after a long, rainy winter, it gets a little nuts for a few days when the sun comes out again, because it seems like everyone has forgotten how to drive on sunny days.
- yellowapple 7y agoBecause "something better than humans can do" is the whole selling point of self-driving cars. And plenty of us humans can and do drive reasonably-safely in snowy/icy conditions. It takes practice, like anything else driving-related, but it's something that most drivers north of the Mason-Dixon Line likely have quite a bit of practice with and have to handle a significant fraction of the year. It's not unreasonable to hold self-driving cars to the same standard.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Because "something better than humans can do" is the whole selling point of self-driving cars. I don't think so. 'As good as humans can do' would be useful.
- gambiting 7y agoNope, "as good as a human" shouldn't be allowed on the road or on the market. Errors that are allowed for humans should never be allowed for a machine.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Nope, "as good as a human" shouldn't be allowed on the road or on the market. Errors that are allowed for humans should never be allowed for a machine. I don't understand why you'd have that opinion. If it's no riskier and relieves people from having to drive then that seems like a net benefit to me.
- gambiting 7y agoFor the same reason why when a human pilot makes a mistake it's a mistake, but when an autopilot malfunctions every single plane of that type is grounded until the issue can be found and fixed. Machines cannot be just as good as humans, they have to close to perfect when human life is involved. As another example, imagine if you had a radiotherapy machine, when operated manually it randomly kills 1/10000 patients, but when operated by AI it randomly kills 1/100000 patients. Yet I'm 100% certain even though it's a 10x improvement over a human operator it still wouldn't be allowed on the market.