2 ms·
Sometimes I ponder the fact that so much of the US lifestyle is utterly terrible only because single family homes, individual automobiles, strip malls, lack of
by sneak 7y ago
Sometimes I ponder the fact that so much of the US lifestyle is utterly terrible only because single family homes, individual automobiles, strip malls, lack of mixed-use, and parking minimums are a “this is the way we’ve always done it” meme. Many people there literally can’t imagine any other way of doing it.
There are few or no options for cheap, walkable, high-density city living in the US, and not because people don’t want it, because of what the TLS people call “ossification”: it’s illegal to build it in most places, even if it’s cleaner, easier, cheaper, and more desired by citizenry, simply due to (bad) tradition.
(That and that fact that the upper classes really don’t seem to like living within walking distance of poor people.)
I wonder if it’s possible to build new actual cities in the US. I know that due to things like restrictive covenants, much of the housing in the western half of the country makes it legally impossible to ever increase the density of existing cities. Subdivisions in master planned areas can’t individually decide to allow duplexes or mid-rises or corner stores, as they are sub-sub-subdivisions that are governed by decades-old associations. To build another New York or Hong Kong (in addition to needing 50-100 years) you’d probably need to start fresh; it couldn’t be grafted into an existing sprawl town.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>(That and that fact that the upper classes really don’t seem to like living within walking distance of poor people.) More importantly, you want your children to go to a school in the district with the most affluent parents that you can afford to live near. That's why 20 somethings don't mind living near poorer people in NYC or SF, but unless they can afford to pay for very, very expensive private schools, they will move out to the most expensive suburb they can afford (i.e. the best school district they can afford) when they have kids.
- sneak 7y agoI hadn’t thought of that, it’s a great point. I wonder what sort of workable solutions exist to this problem. Would eliminating all public schools and making a voucher-based system (with oversight/standardization for redeeming organizations) work to solve this? How do we overall reduce the number of everyday routine life person-meters travelled in large percentages of society?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoNo real solutions I can see other than reducing the wealth/income gap (i.e. wealth redistribution which means higher taxes). Anything else is papering over the root cause, which is the opportunity gap between different socioeconomic classes. Even if people deserve to be in lower socioeconomic classes due to their laziness, it hurts society as a whole in the long run if equal opportunity is a goal for children.
- biaachmonkie 7y agoNo, the opposite is likely a better solution. Instead of local funding for schools change it so that all funding for schools goes to a single pool, in the U.S. it would need to be a State pool, and then split it out based on school population. That way we eliminate the "ghetto schools" problem of being underfunded while the "Beverly Hills" type schools are awash in funds. Any donations to schools, also go to the general fund. It totally unfair that where you live literally down to what side of the street can mean the difference between a good or terribly funded school you must attend.