6 ms·
I dislike Uber as a company, I'm still not over susan fowler and the way they skirt the law in most municipalities is definitely criminal. However, I have to a
by dijit 7y ago
I dislike Uber as a company, I'm still not over susan fowler and the way they skirt the law in most municipalities is definitely criminal.
However, I have to agree with Uber here.
I work on video games, if I bring some engine code from my current employer to a new employer that's theft. Anything I made on company time or with company resources is not mine to take. However taking learnings is totally fine (because: of course it is) and that factors into things because it's experience.
If he did this without Uber knowing then he's alone. If Uber knew he might do it or promoted this behaviour then that vindicates my feelings towards them and they definitely should be punished as hard as the law allows.
"Take nothing but memories" applies to more than just nature.
- yokaze 7y agoProblem is, Uber made a contract which explicitly indemnifies him. I'm fairly certain, that is not standard from Uber. From what I heard, what "the guilty engineer" did, was an open secret. Those two things together make it rather unlikely that Uber, or more exactly, the people involved in the decision at Uber at that time, where completely in the dark.
- downvoteme1 7y agoWhat if Uber hired him just so he can bring the code to Uber from Google
- rubyn00bie 7y agoI think that's what Levandowski is trying to say, that Uber hired him very likely for the trade secrets. At the time, Uber was run like it was above the law, so I wouldn't find this too surprising myself.
- detaro 7y agoAnd Levandowski says Uber's review before agreeing to the indemnification clause included reviewing the files he took from Google, and they nevertheless agreed to the clause and did run his defense when it came to it. That's the core disagreement of the case: Uber saying he acted alone, Levandowski saying Uber knew what was going on.
- nostrademons 7y agoThe previously reported court-filings made a pretty suggestive case that Uber knew. Otto wasn't founded until after Levandowski met with Travis Kalanick, and they reportedly had a verbal agreement to sell the company to Uber before the company was formed. The whole thing seemed like a sham to steal Google's trade secrets while creating plausible deniability. Uber also continued to employ Levandowski long after the lawsuit started, until Judge Alsup pointed out that it's very hard to argue that you had no knowledge of your employee's illegal actions and would not condone such a theft while that employee is on your payroll running the division created by this theft at the same time you're getting sued for the theft.
- sp332 7y agohttps://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/04/levandowski-says-uber-must-pay-his-179-million-judgment-to-google/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/04/levandowski-says-uber-m... Levandowski claims that Uber was fully aware of the circumstances of Levandowski's 2016 departure from Google.... Levandwoski says he cooperated fully, giving investigators access to his email accounts and personal files.... Kalanick wasn't concerned. "Uber eats injunctions for breakfast," he allegedly told Levandowski.... Uber's acquisition terms for Otto included a sweeping indemnification commitment for Otto employees, including Levandowski.... Levandowski says Uber specifically promised to protect Levandowski if he was accused of misappropriation of trade secrets or breach of loyalty to a former employer - two of the key accusations Google later leveled against Levandowski. The indemnification clause said that Uber would pay any expenses arising out of a lawsuit from a former employer, including damages.
- khazhoux 7y agoUnclear without additional details. What did Levandowski tell Kalanick? "Travis, I'm sure if you acquire me, Google will claim non-compete, trade secret theft, and all that. Will your legal department cover me?" --or-- "Travis, I'm going to steal trade secrets from Google and bring them with me. When Google finds out, will your legal department cover me?"
- sp332 7y agoYeah, I know. That's why I posted it. It's a response to a comment that couldn't see how Uber could possibly be on the hook.