6 ms·
It's interesting. I played on "veteran" and lost quite badly over ~20 rounds in spite of trying my human best to pick randomly. Then I enlisted my computer's
by Natsu 16y ago
It's interesting. I played on "veteran" and lost quite badly over ~20 rounds in spite of trying my human best to pick randomly. Then I enlisted my computer's help.
perl -e "@a = qw/rock paper scissors/;print $a[int rand 3];"
34 wins, 31 ties, 35 losses
I had assumed there would be more bias in it if it were trying to exploit human patterns and that choosing randomly like this would in turn allow me to exploit it as it looked for nonexistent patterns in my choices.
Apparently there wasn't that much bias to take advantage of or it learned that I was choosing randomly and compensated by doing the same. Or maybe I just didn't choose a large enough sample and got unlucky, I'm not too sure. I will say that I was winning a lot more during the first half, though.
- akjj 16y agoI don't understand what you were hoping for with your random choices: If you choose randomly, you'll win, lose, and tie each one third of the time, no matter what your opponent's strategy is. Your results are consistent with that prediction.
- Natsu 16y agoI was thinking that there should be a non-random variance to take advantage of if they're trying to exploit human non-randomness. But maybe I committed a statistical fallacy somewhere in that line of reasoning, because it sure didn't win.
- kronusaturn 16y agoYes, you're misunderstanding the statistics a bit. If you're choosing your moves randomly, your win rate will always be 1/3 no matter how non-random the computer's moves are... even if it keeps choosing the same thing over and over.
- lkozma 16y agoThere is, but you are not taking advantage of it as long as you choose randomly. Imagine the other tries to exploit your imagined human non-randomness and plays rock all the time. You play totally random, so on the long term you win/lose/tie roughly same number of times. You would be taking advantage if you played paper all the time.
- Natsu 16y ago> There is, but you are not taking advantage of it as long as you choose randomly. You're right. I was just thinking that 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 was the Nash equilibrium and not really thinking the whole thing through. Once I gave it a little more thought, I came up with the same rock example you gave.
- heyitsnick 16y agoIn most toy games you would be right; playing the GTO/nash equil. solution would naturally benefit from an imbalanced/exploitive style on an opponent. It's only in games like rock-papers-scissors where this isn't the game.
- nostrademons 16y agoI just played 30 rounds. 10-12-8. As far as I can tell, it's pretty much random.