3 ms·
OK, so if this is true that towns and suburbs had subsidized construction and that now the cost of full infrastructure maintenance can't be supported locally...
by crazygringo 7y ago
OK, so if this is true that towns and suburbs had subsidized construction and that now the cost of full infrastructure maintenance can't be supported locally...
...then what happens? Do roads just get a lot more potholes but we deal just fine in the end? Or would it get so bad that people wind up just leaving somehow?
It's almost impossible for me to imagine that road etc. maintenance is that expensive that it could mean shutting down entire neighborhoods because there's no other choice. ("Everybody who owns a house, goodbye it's worthless now.")
Is there more likely to be a supply-and-demand thing where a town is forced to massively increase property taxes, people who can't afford it are forced to leave for a cheaper locale, and people with more money come in? (Attracted by the now lower price of the houses which compensates for the higher property taxes.) In other words, existing homeowners will get the shaft, because the deferred maintenance will essentially be paid for in the end by their loss in home equity?
- vharuck 7y agoI lived in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Our whole state has infrastructure problems. For the highways, it's because we're connected to a lot of logistical hubs. But a lot of our towns, including our capital, have big problems with big potholes. It doesn't happen in a single decision or even a single year. It's a slow spiral: people move out, crumbling streets go on the "cons" list of house hunters, the city has a smaller income base, so non-urgent roadwork is less urgent. Repeat. I'm not saying people will flee neighborhoods with bad streets. But they will move out for the usual reasons: family, new jobs, marriage. The problem is new people are less likely to move in.
- ip26 7y agoThe theory is that as the infra crumbles, it becomes unattractive and the affluent move elsewhere. Or, property taxes are raised to fix the roads- and the affluent move elsewhere. Either way it starts a downward spiral of decreasing appeal & property value, and increasing cost. Which leads in to inexorable decay. People still live there, but it becomes a trap for the people who can't afford to get out. Strongtowns argues this fate was inevitable given certain initial conditions- subsidized infrastructure, underfunded maintenance liability, etc.