14 ms·
Apple has not made any significant donations to charity since 1997
- ck2 16y agoAs seen on Reddit. Also: http://philanthropy.com/blogs/social-philanthropy/is-apple-anti-charity/24565 http://philanthropy.com/blogs/social-philanthropy/is-apple-a... http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2010/06/nonprofit-developer-apples-no-donation-policy-is-a-cop-out.ars http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2010/06/nonprofit-develope...
- christo16 16y agoSJ believes that his job is to make shareholders rich and by doing so, gives them the means to be charitable. I would tend to agree with him.
- ck2 16y agoAs a corporation Apple profits massively from society. One might say they owe something back. With the extreme loyalty of it's userbase, they could set some very nice examples. Why Steve Jobs isn't personally charitable with $5B in the bank is a rather depressing mystery.
- nailer 16y agoApple benefits from individuals. Why are strangers entitled to their profits?
- wtallis 16y ago"One might say they owe something back" One could say that they are giving something back, by using those profits to develop ways to make computing more accessible and useful, something they're better at and more willing to invest in than anyone else.
- Johngibb 16y agoI totally agree with this post. Charity does not only come in the form of monetary donations...
- ck2 16y agoLet me repeat that back to you as I understood it. What you are saying is Apple (and their work) is $deity's gift to the world so they don't owe anything else regardless how many billions of dollars they make from it. People in parts of the world that need help to survive or thrive more than a meager existence, aren't helped by Apple's pretty software UI and hardware design.
- nickbp 16y agoOnly to those who can afford it.
- jamesaguilar 16y ago> One might say they owe something back. What, the wonderful computers they make for us are not enough?
- prodigal_erik 16y agoUS society has already decided what Apple owes back each year, via the IRS. I don't see why it's fair to expect them to dispose of more of their shareholders' money than some other companies in the same position. It's not as if their shareholders would reach a consensus about an unrelated social problem to solve, much less make an empty gesture towards solving (charities can't fix the free rider issue, which is why they almost never get enough resources to actually succeed and shut down).
- ck2 16y agoAs a massive corporation, I am sure Apple doesn't pay very much taxes, mostly because all their manufacturing is outside the US. Note that some large corporations pay next to nothing. http://www.forbes.com/2010/04/01/ge-exxon-walmart-business-washington-corporate-taxes_2.html http://www.forbes.com/2010/04/01/ge-exxon-walmart-business-w...
- joelrunyon 16y agoPersonally charitable & publicly charitable are two different things. Unless you know something the rest of us don't, I would be careful passing judgement on someone you only see in keynote speaking environments.
- benologist 16y agoWhat a silly excuse to give nothing back - both Apple and Jobs individually are sitting on ridiculous amounts of money regardless of what their shareholders do with their own money.
- forza 16y agoSeems like a trickle-down economics type of excuse to me. If they really wanted to do that they really could do it like Buffet used to http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/1997ar/shcontri.html http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/1997ar/shcontri.html
- Muzza 16y agoGood. Charities usually squander their money.
- ck2 16y agoNot sure who downvoted you instead of explaining this: There are plenty of popular "knee-jerk" charities like the Red Cross that squander their donations. However there are also plenty of smaller, more focused charities that give a huge percentage of their donations directly to their causes and are extremely efficient. The catch is you have to research a charity before donating and most people cannot be bothered. These days with the internet, there is no excuse for not researching: http://www.charitynavigator.org/ http://www.charitynavigator.org/
- Johngibb 16y agoI think it's at least reasonable to concede that it's possible that Apple does more good in empowering not-so-tech-savvy-individuals than it would in donating money to charities. As a case-in-point, my girlfriend and I recently gave her old MacBook to my grandmother. Ever since - she's been more engaged with facebook than anyone my age - and it shows in her mood and general well being. I can't help but glow every time I get off a FaceTime call with her!
- maxharris 16y agoCharity is morally neutral. I believe that being good means making the most of your own life. If you want to help someone, or even a lot of people through charity, that's fine, but it should not earn you any moral credit. Moral credit should only come from what you've truly achieved, and that means creating value somehow (invention, scientific discovery, beautiful art, and honest work of any kind). Anyone can give away fifty million dollars, but not many can actually earn the same sum in their lifetimes.
- OpieCunningham 16y agoCharity is not morally neutral. One part of being good means making the most of your own life. Another part of being good means helping other people. No one can give away fifty million dollars that they don't have. There is no inherent moral good in earning fifty million dollars (Bernie Madoff, Goldman Sachs, AIG, your local arms dealer, etc. etc.) There is often significant moral good in earning far less than fifty million dollars (teachers, nurses, etc).
- maxharris 16y agoBernie Madoff did not earn anything. He stole. You cannot justly equate a destroyer of value (Madoff) with a creator of value (Jobs).
- nickbp 16y agoThose who would be benefited by a charity are unlikely to be impacted by Jobs' computers. What Haitian can afford or would be helped by a MacBook?
- maxharris 16y agoThe question, rephrased is: does anyone have a right to exist as a free person when there is suffering anywhere in the world? I say yes. Need is not a valid claim on anyone else's life. I didn't make them poor. My moral responsibility lies with making my own life the best. In doing so, I'm not harming anyone, because it's not in my interest to sacrifice others to myself (just as it is not in my interest to sacrifice myself to others.) Instead of begging or stealing, I advocate trading.
- DuncanIdaho 16y agoIs Steve Jobs an disciple of Ayn Rand? There sure seems to be a number of indicators pointing in that direction. If he is - then you can't really blame him can you? He could hardly justify charity as moral.
- Tycho 16y agoThat doesn't follow. Objectivism has no problem with charity (Rand: 'it's good and proper'), just with this moral-blackmailing/guilt-tripping schtick. I think many Objectivists believe that (private) charity would be larger overall in the sort of society Rand envisioned.
- Irfaan 16y agoOne of the things I liked about Microsoft was the company's gift matching policy - they'd 100% match your donation to a charity up to <SOME LARGE NUMBER>. I found myself being more generous because of it, what with each of my dollars worth two. I'm surprised Apple doesn't have a similar policy - sure, it didn't make or break my decision to join MS, but it was an awfully nice compensation bonus.
- glenra 16y agoApple does have a similar policy.
- SeanNieuwoudt 16y ago"Give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day, teach him how to fish and he'll eat for a lifetime". Apple owe's you nothing, they are entitled to do exactly as they please with their profits.
- WordSkill 16y agoThe headline is completely incorrect - Wikipedia does NOT say that "Apple has not made any significant donations to charity since 1997". What it actually says is: "Jobs has not reinstated a philanthropic division at Apple." So, he hasn't hired a bunch of people to sit in an office, giving someone else's money away and feeling pretty good about themselves. I'd say that is A GOOD THING - you don't need full-time staff in order to give money to good causes, that's just more overhead that stops money getting to the people who really need it. Jobs also got rid of the Apple Museum when he returned to Apple in 1997 .... because it was irrelevant ego bullshit and completely unnecessary. Wikipedia says absolutely nothing about how much money Apple has donated and I know for a fact that it has aided progressive causes that other corporations would be too nervous to assist for fear of conservative backlash. I hope that the submitter of this, ck2, realizes that, with one rotten headline, he is now part of what is wrong with media reporting - distorting the truth in order to sensationalize.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- glenra 16y ago> Wikipedia says absolutely nothing about how much money Apple has donated and I know for a fact that it has aided progressive causes For instance, Apple does tie-in promotions such as the Product(RED) iPods that support the Global Fund to Fight AIDS: http://www.apple.com/ipod/red/ http://www.apple.com/ipod/red/ They also provide grants and recognition to teachers and schools: http://www.apple.com/education/apple-distinguished-educator/ http://www.apple.com/education/apple-distinguished-educator/