5 ms·
Also, look at rural communities... They manage to maintain a mile or more of roads to most isolated houses.
by londons_explore 7y ago
Also, look at rural communities...
They manage to maintain a mile or more of roads to most isolated houses.
- hylaride 7y agoTo be fair, rural roads are almost always heavily subsidized from higher levels of government. The sparsely used road users aren’t bearing the full cost.
- rsync 7y ago"To be fair, rural roads are almost always heavily subsidized from higher levels of government." This is generally true - typically, paved rural roads in the US are county roads. Nicely maintained gravel roads are typically county roads as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 7y agoWhen people look at the tax base and where federal dollars are spent, the Red areas usually end up getting anywhere from $103 to $110 in federal dollars for every $100 collected in federal taxes, and much of that comes down to roads and highways. Without the highways most of these areas wouldn't be able to buy or sell goods to the outside world. (Aren't trains cheaper? Maybe we should be building more track and fewer lanes)
- jatone 7y agothe assumptions going on here are all about costs. when in reality current transportation infra funding from federal government is about military defense. its the same reason electricity lines, highways, and train rails don't occupy the same space. there is no reason they couldn't and would reduce costs overall. but it also means a single strike can disable all 3 systems. in today's world I think its a pointless effort and we should resolve those issues to reduce the overall costs. but here we are.
- yellowapple 7y ago> its the same reason electricity lines, highways, and train rails don't occupy the same space. They sometimes do, though. Namely: if you're going through the mountains, there are only so many mountain passes, and therefore only so many places where these things can get through the mountains. I-80 in the Sierra Nevada mountains is a perfect example of this; between Colfax and the 80/20 interchange (if not all the way to Truckee) they're very much occupying the same space because there's nowhere else to go (thankfully that power line's pretty minor compared to the one following 49 to the north, but the one following 49 also happens to be colocated with rail). The more viable solution - and indeed, if you look at a map of our energy infrastructure¹, the one that we use - is to make the connections as redundant as possible. This has plenty of peacetime benefits, too (for example, if I-80 and the adjacent railway both shut down because of a blizzard or avalanche, trains and trucks can route around it, albeit with delays). ---- ¹: https://www.eia.gov/state/maps.php https://www.eia.gov/state/maps.php
- mike50 7y agoA dirt or gravel road wide enough for one car. Also lacking lights plowing or a sidewalk.
- 0xB31B1B 7y agoMost of those roads are 1) city or county highways and also serve a commercial purpose 2) are bad quality and have been left to decay 3) have been crushed and turned to gravel roads
- wutbrodo 7y agoModeling rural communities as remotely self-sustaining economically is a fantasy. They "manage" to maintain these roads through heavy subsidization by more economically-productive cities. Obviously dense cities (in their current form) aren't completely self-sustaining either, given that they need food. But this is universally-understood, while for some reason many people seem to be unaware how much of a closed-loop rural communities _aren't_ when they talk about the sustainability of sparse living patterns at modern standards of living.
- jimmaswell 7y agoSounds like farm towns could self-sustain with a sacrifice in some luxuries and tax money from cities, but cities would starve.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jonathankoren 7y agoLuxuries like what? Roads? Fire departments? Police? Schools? There’s a floor, and often they don’t generate it, instead relying on state and county funds. The economics at the state level, play out just like how they do at the national level. The high population, economically vibrant parts generate tax revenue, which is redistributed to the sparsely populated, economically depressed areas, of which are not self sustaining, no matter how much the net receivers think they are.
- jimmaswell 7y agoCompared to food and water those things are luxuries. Obviously both types of regions need each other to maintain the modern style of living as mentioned, but in some kind of societal collapse situation you'd probably rather be on some isolated farm that could theoretically sustain itself. And I feel like if those areas chose to go on with less subsidy money they could do so, but it's not a bad trade for food and everything else that comes from them. If one really wanted to hold the other hostage the one with the food would win.
- sunflowerfly 7y agoI live in rural KS. We afford our roads in rural areas by purposely not paving them. Maintenance of gravel roads in the East and dirt roads in the West is accomplished by running a road grader down them every few months. There are paved county roads every 5 to 10 miles. These are generally only chip and sealed every 3 to 5 years, not repaved, and are not smooth. Every 15 to 25 miles there is a paved state road. Even many of them lack shoulders, leaving nowhere to stop in emergencies and causing semis to roll when they catch the edge of the road. Even for those of us in town, UPS and FedEx packages are generally coated in dirt upon arrival. The one benefit is the low cost of maintenance. Long term, the cheapest roads are in older towns that still have brick streets. Some are a 100 years old and have nearly zero maintenance. They are slick and noisy. On a side note, we have hundreds of miles of gravel roads to bike. We even have an internationally attended event called the Dirty Kanza.