4 ms·
> The entire economy is based on the idea of never ending growth, infinite leverage, and assets that always inflate without increasing utility (homes for exampl
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> The entire economy is based on the idea of never ending growth, infinite leverage, and assets that always inflate without increasing utility (homes for example). It works, until it doesn't.
Humans want better lives. More living space, more free time, faster cars, whatever. Humans will not stop wanting this for as long as there are humans. There are two ways to get it.
One is creating more stuff. This is growth.
The other is taking somebody else's stuff. This is war.
Growth is better.
But zoning restrictions that inflate housing prices? That's not growth, it constrains growth, which implies...
- gowld 7y agoThere's a third way: Living better, not bigger. Engaging in social, intellectual, and aesthetic activities, not ever-increasing consumerism.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThis is what people say when their basic needs are met and they have enough free time to engage in "social, intellectual, and aesthetic activities." Tell the people who don't that growth isn't necessary and see if they're happy for you to have that but not them.
- rsync 7y agoI hope you will consider - both from a biological perspective and an economic one - that catabolism is also possible. Which is to say, depending on your environment, you can create a "better life" (by your definitions) by catabolizing existing resources. You can't catabolize forever, of course, but it's an immediate and obvious refutation to your claim that "better lives" can only be pursued through growth or war.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThere isn't a separate thing called catabolism which can increase available value by neither creating nor transferring it. Converting one resource to another at an overall net gain is growth. Converting one resource to another when the original resource was equally or more valuable net doesn't improve lives, it's either completely neutral or net harmful. Note that there are a lot of growth metrics out there that inappropriately fail to account for this, e.g. they measure sale price but not consumer or producer surplus (which are harder to measure because there is no market pricing information available). If someone invents a cheap way to turn farm waste into motor fuel and then suddenly gas is $1/gallon, that's growth -- there is a surplus being created -- even if there is a net reduction in GDP because oil companies are making less money while most of the surplus goes to the consumer. (Though in most cases the reduction in GDP doesn't happen anyway because then consumers have more money in their pockets and spend it on something else.)
- mindslight 7y ago> Humans want better lives. More living space, more free time, faster cars, whatever More free time implies translating productivity gains into less time working, rather than the current economic policy of pushing everyone into working full time such that productivity gains just create more waste.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoI'm not sure "pushing everyone into working full time" is an existing economic policy goal so much as what happens as a result of artificial scarcity. If Alice and Bob want to buy the same house as Carol and Dave and nobody works full time but Alice and Bob currently have more money, Alice and Bob get the house. But Carol and Dave can get the house by each taking a full time job. Until Alice and Bob do the same thing, and then you're back to square one except that now everybody has to work full time. The solution is obviously to build a second house so they can each have one instead of being locked into a bidding war that requires everybody to run faster just to stay where they were. Which is growth. Elimination of artificial scarcity enables growth. Artificial scarcity is a method of war/theft and its prevalence is the source of the trouble.
- mindslight 7y agoYour thought experiment assumes cheap credit. Imagine with no credit - Carol and Dave could still start working more to close the gap in their funding, and Alice and Bob could still follow suit to stay ahead. But as soon as the houses were sold, the competition would end and all of them could stop working extra. Only with cheap credit are the four put into the situation of bidding away their futures. Moderate interest rates are on the continuum between the two extremes wherein parties would be disincentivized from bidding far beyond their current means, by a significant down payment and resulting compound interest.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoCheap credit matters more as to how much of the money goes to the bank vs. the original property owner. When interest rates are higher more of the money goes to the bank, because the monthly mortgage payment each household can afford is the same but now more of it is interest. Even eliminating banks entirely wouldn't fix it, because if Carol and Dave could pay the equivalent of the higher mortgage payment in rent every month by taking full time jobs, a rich landlord would pay the higher price for the house and then rent it to them, which means they would still get to live in the house by both working full time, until Alice and Bob do the same. The only real way out of it is to have two houses for two households so they don't both have to bid on the same one.