2 ms·
Using extreme scenarios to plan for normal life has long been the recipe for bad policy. This may make sense where hospital beds/ICU/medical professionals to c
by dmix 7y ago
Using extreme scenarios to plan for normal life has long been the recipe for bad policy.
This may make sense where hospital beds/ICU/medical professionals to capita ratio is low such as in low income neighbourhoods and countries but otherwise it’s mostly just useful for emergency planning.
The proper solution tends to be higher amounts of hospitals, mental health centers, supplies, preparation for outbreaks, etc. The actual hard stuff.
Otherwise this mostly amounts to doctors trained to use a generalized but dangerous hammer in worst case scenarios, in the face of what looks like a terribly difficult situation with no other solutions, and finding out more refined soft procedures like proning and flipping people on their sides works better for certain types of epidemic viruses.
I’d be wary to practically apply this beyond the next viral epidemic.
- ethbro 7y agoIf you read through the Red Dawn email chain NYT pieced together through FOIA requests [1], which gives an overview of initial professional thinking (January / February), there's a great insight in the first few emails. No other emergency grows exponentially. Nuclear detonation, dirty bomb, power outage, hurricane, tainted food, etc. At worst they grow linearly at a high rate. Consequently, highly contagious pandemic response must be fundamentally unlike any other response. There are references to this bearing out in their prior wargaming of scenarios. All players (mistakenly) escalated linearly based on intuition. When in reality you're talking about needing 10x resources every week, ceteris paribus. [1] https://int.nyt.com/data/documenthelper/6879-2020-covid-19-red-dawn-rising/66f590d5cd41e11bea0f/optimized/full.pdf#page=1 https://int.nyt.com/data/documenthelper/6879-2020-covid-19-r...
- Ericson2314 7y agoI don't want Patriot act thinking—we agree there—but the US is so used to assuming it's rich/powerful beyond belief and then getting poor outcomes. We have general efficiency and cost disease issues that emergency planning can absolutely teach us how to address.
- dchichkov 7y agoA patient coming to a doctor, in the similar condition, is 4 times more likely to come out with a prescription in the United States when in Europe. Why? Because it is profitable. What is the result? Well, life expectancy in the United States had been going down. Ref. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02686-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02686-2 This epidemic might be an opening to shift the current equilibrium of over-medication and over-use of expensive treatments with questionable efficacy. The proper solution could be changing the incentives structure in the medical system. From profit and executive compensation aligned structures that over-sell services and drugs into something that is connected with long-term public health.