7 ms·
Mystery of two-million-year-old stone balls solved
- 205guy 7y agoThe stone ball tools in question are from the Qesem cave in Israel and dated to 400 to 200 thousand years before present. The 2 million in the headline must refer to other similar tools dated to earlier times but whose use couldn’t be determined. The cave was discovered in 2010 during roadwork. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qesem_cave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qesem_cave The article describes how the researchers made replicas and used those to crush bones, which they did better than unshaped stones of similar size. The replicas also had marks after use similar to the original artifacts. I really like when scientists do this kind of validation. This article taught me about ancient humans; I did not know we had such archaeological evidence from them. I had heard that anatomically modern humans have been around for 100 thousand years, so art in Lascaux caves from 17,000 years was made by people like us (just pre agriculture and civilization), but I had no idea about humans 200,000 years ago using tools. For perspective, this cave was used (likely intermittently) by humans for 200,000 years, so 100 times the Christian Era or 40 times the span recorded history (oldest writing dating back to Egypt around 3rd millenium BC). But then it was unused, probably covered up and undiscovered for the same length of time until present.
- wallflower 7y ago> but I had no idea about humans 200,000 years ago using tools. You might be interested in Sapiens. https://www.amazon.com/Sapiens-Humankind-Yuval-Noah-Harari/dp/0062316095 https://www.amazon.com/Sapiens-Humankind-Yuval-Noah-Harari/d...
- travelbyphone 7y agoI’m just finishing reading Sapiens. Highly recommended!
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoOur genus has been using tools, or at least one particular kind of tool, for at least 2.6 million years. Check these out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_axe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_axe
- 205guy 7y agoYes, when I thought about it, early humans must’ve been using tools for much longer. I think what impressed me here were the details they were able to deduce: storing tools in a common place, how they probably used them, perhaps the pre-historic equivalent of a butcher shop. Also, it’s not as if exactly 100,000 years ago, humans turned modern. It was a long drawn-out transition, and perhaps some qualities came much earlier. Which makes me wonder what archaeologists consider as modern and how they arrived at that date. I’ll have to look for the Sapiens book recommended in the other comments. And thanks for that link, it’s really interesting. I particularly like the linked pages for John Frere and thunderstones, about how stone axes were found and considered in modern times. I find such historiography fascinating: the stone axes were thought to be from gods or fairies at first, then some early scientists started to make more rational guesses about their origin—another approach to deep time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderstone_(folklore) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderstone_(folklore) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Frere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Frere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_time
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoWhat boggles my mind is that this particular stone tool, it's so attached to our genus that you could argue that it's a central part of our heritage. For almost two million years this particular tool was made, in similar ways. In some ways it defines us as a species. And yet we lost the knowledge only 10-20,000 years ago. I find that kind of sad. I wouldn't mind learning how to make one.
- 205guy 7y agoWhen I went to the Maker Faire 5+ years ago, there was one small group of exhibits about making flint tools and other Stone Age implements (fiber cord, then you can make a bow drill and make beads, etc.). They were really trying to revive the ideas and methods hat you are talking about. I don’t have any contact info, but it should be on google somewhere. Somewhat related for the Bronze Age is the Clickspeing YouTube channel where the guy create bronze-working tools by hand and then uses them to re-create the Antikythera Mechanism. It is surprisingly complex, but he is meticulous and perfectionist with incredible results. Unfortunatel, he stopped posting halfway through, so I’m not sure what happened.
- akiselev 7y agoI believe the oldest writing comes from Sumerians, not Egypt.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoSubject to the caveats that (1) we can't necessarily identify something as "writing" or "not writing"; and (2) it's hard to establish accurate dates for things that happened 5-6000 years ago, they're roughly contemporaneous.
- 205guy 7y agoIt seems to go either way, depending on the source, the consideration of “proto-writing,” and interpretation of date ranges: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_first_written_accounts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_first_wri...
- irrational 7y agoIt still blows my mind that a human that lived 100,000 years ago was anatomically modern. I take that to mean that we could've taken one at birth and raised it in a modern home and it could've grown up to receive a physics PhD. In other words, a human 100,000+ years ago was 100% capable of understanding general relativity, or how to design and construct the Saturn V rocket, or any other modern STEM topic. What were we doing for all those years banging bones with round rocks? There must've been a lot of intellectually frustrated people.
- anon73044 7y ago>What were we doing for all those years banging bones with round rocks? Surviving! Man's conquest over Nature is a fairly recent occurrence.
- theelous3 7y ago> There must've been a lot of intellectually frustrated people. This is funny. As if they were just hanging around with the luxury to want to be challenged. They didn't live very long, their lives were harsh, they were probably banging out kids at an unbelievable rate. There's something just fantastically out of touch about your statement here. Very silver platter. Even now, there are much more intelligent people than you or I with no time or resources for intellectual pursuits, and following that, no particular drive either. If you're hungry and your living conditions are risky, you probably don't care about lacanian this or knot topography that. Much too busy.
- throwaway_pdp09 7y agoYou make a good point that too many current humans have the same problem, or lack motivation, but the silver platter/out of touch barb wasn't necessary. > banging out kids at an unbelievable rate That's not actually helpful. Some stats would be good. I did a quick search for number of offspring for the yanomami but found nothing.
- lolc 7y agoI remember this little theory where in some ancient cultures children would be weaned around age six and the mothers would only become fertile again after that. I'm not sure how established the mechanicas are, but the theory says that hormonal pathways where breastfeeding causes infertility are activated by scant nutrition. It sounds like an effective way to adjust births to the available resources.
- d0mine 7y agoAnimals can use tools https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals
- droithomme 7y ago> For nearly 2 million years, ancient humans crafted stones into hand-size balls, but archaeologists were unsure why. Wait, for nearly 2 million years ... humans? Starting and ending when? Do we have human remains from more than 2 million years ago? Turkana Boy is 1.5 million years old and close to modern physiology, once you get back to 2 million isn't it australopithicus and such? > That changed when Assaf and her team came across a cache of 30 stone balls in Qesem Cave in Israel, where humans lived from about 400,000 to 200,000 years ago I wonder if 2 million is a typo for 200 thousand? > these stones "might have helped enhance human caloric intake and adaptation in the lower Paleolithic period," (2.7 million to 200,000 years ago), at Qesem Cave and possibly beyond, the researchers wrote in the study. Whew, OK, so 2.7 million years ago is their starting point on this. That's interesting. Who was shaping stones that far back? An interesting other site is the Cerutti Mastodon site in San Diego with 130kYBP mastodon bones possibly crushed with similar stones which were found at the site. https://www.nature.com/articles/nature22065 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature22065
- slsii 7y agoLearning about stone "industries" is probably one of my favorite wikipedia dives I've ever had the pleasure of experiencing. Check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldowan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldowan You can see in the sidebar that you can traverse the industries in time (Preceded by and Followed by links). Amazingly, these span _species_, since stone tools were in use before Homo sapiens were on the scene.
- oh_sigh 7y agoIt's really incredible that at that point humans(or whatever homo species) could 1) invent novel techniques for tool making and 2) train others, who could train others, etc etc until the technique traveled flawless across the accessible world. The weirdest part for me though is how flawless transmission of the techniques happened over a relatively short period of time, but (1) was so infrequent that each technique lasted for tens or hundreds of thousands of years. Yet not so infrequent that it never happened, or it only happened once.
- hirundo 7y agoHere's a video of a capuchin monkey demonstrating the technique on a nut: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mvt9ZZis3GY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mvt9ZZis3GY So this is more of a simian tool than a human one.
- mkl 7y agoThe monkey didn't create its tool by shaping an appropriate rock to suit the purpose.
- gumby 7y agoInteresting: whoever edited that article miscorrected "cobble" to the likely more familiar but incorrect "cobblestone". I've seen a huge increase in such errors over the past decade, both in terms and tense. I don't know how to explain it but it is discouraging. Sometimes the errors are quite confusing until you realize what happened; this one is quite minor.
- theli0nheart 7y agoCould you please explain to the linguistically challenged amongst us what the error is?
- owyn 7y agoIn this case I think cobblestone is correct? They tested natural stones (Merriam Webster: cobblestone - "a naturally rounded stone larger than a pebble and smaller than a boulder") vs the hand made stones for this particular task. "cobble" is more frequently a verb in my experience, to "cobble something together". The dictionary does say cobblestone as a noun = cobble as a noun though. So although they seem to be equivalent I think the original objection is that in some dialects / regions it probably just flows better in a sentence? Probably another subtle british vs american english thing. (I'm american) -- edit My brit friend says it's a stone until it's in a road, then it's a cobblestone.
- snowwrestler 7y agoCobble is what a geologist would call a medium-sized water-rounded piece of rock if it was free or embedded naturally in a matrix (like glacial till or sediment). They’d only call it a cobblestone in the context of like, paving a street or driveway or something. However, I don’t think that makes it wrong for people / other disciplines to call it a cobblestone.
- gorgoiler 7y agoI think the traditional difference between cobbles and a cobblestone something is the same distinction as pebbles vs a pebbledash something. A pebble is of course a small rock. Pebbledash describes the decorative finish — which is made of pebbles and other material like cement or concrete — on some physical thing. You would say “my new house has pebbledash walls” or just by itself as a shorthand where it implies an unsaid word: “the pebbledash [finish] on this property gives it a delightfully vintage feel!” So historically speaking, cobblestone describes a type of surface finish made of cobbles, and the two words have been quite separate. Aerial is a fun one too. An antenna has components such as bolts and fixtures and junction boxes, but most prominently it will have a wire or other metal object that is thrust into the air: that is to to say a component that is aerial, or the aerial component. Once I learned that distinction, saying “aerial” instead of the more precise “antenna” seems very quaint, like saying “wireless” for radio or “pianoforte” for piano. It’s not exactly the same as cobbles being used in cobblestone finishes, but they are interesting examples of nouns and adjectives merging into each other.
- yashwanthcp 7y agoFrom South India here. Round stone ball (like the one in the pic) is still a very common tool in the kitchens here. We use it to quickly grind spices like pepper or make paste of ginger or garlic.
- mncharity 7y agoI saw a paper years back, which I now fuzzily recall as having people select which size stones felt good, felt right in their hand, and then comparing that with their biophysics parameters like arm length, with a hypothesis that people like the feel of stones which are optimally sized for them to throw. So among thoughts of "innovation", perhaps include "thinking with your hands", and even beaver-style slapping mud on trickling noises "just because". Mens et manus (MIT's "mind and hand" motto).
- jhoechtl 7y agoI wonder if anybody of those experts ever tried to model a stone. With tools available 2 million years ago which means: another stone. Crafting stone balls to reach the marrow? Any other stone would do.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoConfused: How long did it take scientists to figure out, stone balls were used to hit things? Why didn't they simply ask Australian Aborigines? Oh they did, in 1912: http://www.aboriginalculture.com.au/stone_tools3.html http://www.aboriginalculture.com.au/stone_tools3.html