2 ms·
I wouldn't even go so far as to say that the mobile experience is a downgrade. The issue is one of respect for the medium the program is executing on. On a tab
by Jtsummers 7y ago
I wouldn't even go so far as to say that the mobile experience is a downgrade. The issue is one of respect for the medium the program is executing on.
On a tablet, MS Teams would be (mostly) adequate. The tabbed interface is somewhat natural:
+----------------------------------+
| |search/command field| |
+---------+--------+---------------+
|Activity |Person1 |Chat Files Org |
|<Chat> |Person2 +---------------+
|Teams | |Some stuff |
|Calendar | | |
+---------+------------------------+
Select the main thing you want in the left column, select a sub-activity in the next column, then another, or interact with files/chat/whatever.
It actually works well as a model for how to do chat/collaboration with a tablet. It makes good use of space (the first two columns take up almost as little space as needed). It's touch-friendly. If it launched files into their own editors, it'd be a perfectly reasonable tablet application.
But on the desktop, I'd really like to chat with more than one person at at time. I'd like to view the files and chat with whoever sent it. The desktop computer offers one of the most flexible GUI systems we have, don't force users into a singular mode of use unless you're running on a kiosk.
---
I'm picking on MS Teams, but look at Slack and Discord as the things it's imitating (or all are imitating each other). Restrictive single-window applications neglecting what makes the desktop so flexible/capable and distinct from tablets, which their present UIs are more suited for.
- anthk 7y agoA touch interface for a chat application is the worst thing on usability happened on IT ever. Physical keyboards as a cover should be a must shipped item on every tablet. A tablet is a consumer/broadcasting device, like the smartphone. You are not producingwith it. You are either consuming media, or sharing it. It's the perfect ad device. And zoomers are blindly embracing it as if it was better and more "modern". They are not right.
- Jtsummers 7y ago> A touch interface for a chat application is the worst thing on usability happened on IT ever. That's a strong opinion, not one I'd agree with (except for the how touch-device interfaces have spilled into desktop interfaces).