4 ms·
It seems that there is an easy solution here that is being overlooked. Allow any country to nominate their ccTLD for conversion to gTLD, and make that automati
by jedberg 7y ago
It seems that there is an easy solution here that is being overlooked.
Allow any country to nominate their ccTLD for conversion to gTLD, and make that automatic when a country dissolves.
Hold an auction for the gTLD for anyone who qualifies under the existing gTLD rules, and the highest bidder gets to run the gTLD. The proceeds of the auction go to the country that owned the ccTLD.
A lot of small countries would probably gladly put up their ccTLDs for auction for the one time cash infusion, and in cases like this, if the country does get turned back over, the acquiring country would probably be glad to have the money.
This solution seems like an everyone wins scenario. The TLD continues to exist and some government gets a small cash infusion.
- koheripbal 7y agoI'm not sure everybody wins. What happens if a malicious country buys the tld and then appropriates the domains and/or redirects traffic?
- jedberg 7y agoThe gTLD transfer rules already supposedly prevent this. But this is a risk with the transfer of any gTLD.
- dmurray 7y agoWhat's the difference between this and the current situation where countries can also sell or lease their ccTLD to the highest bidder? Are the gTLD registrars held to stricter standards when it comes to continuity of service?
- jedberg 7y agoIt's functionally the same but removes government control for a one time cash infusion, so it makes the incentives a bit different.
- swiley 7y agoReally? I'm not so sure about that. Many countries make a lot of money just renting their ccTLD out. Sure many would probably do it but I don't think it's 1) good, it's nice that we have eg gov.uk Even if you don't live in the UK. 2) Economically beneficial to most countries that would elect to do it in the long term.
- jedberg 7y agoFor the countries that derive benefit from the current arrangement, they would just maintain the status quo. But this gives an option to existing countries who need a cash infusion now, as well as a streamlined process for dealing with countries that no longer exist.
- mrmanner 7y agoThis works until the BIOT becomes part of Mauritius and the eastern part of Ohio declare sovereignty under the name Inner Ohio and get the ISO code IO :)
- jedberg 7y agoPresumably the entire point of this is that if Mauritius no longer wanted to run the .io domain it would automatically go up for auction. Also, you can't reuse ccTLDs.
- DeathArrow 7y agoI won't be surprised if there is a Free Ohio movement in some obscure corners of the Internet with its members all different personalities of its glorious leader.