3 ms·
Not dumb at all. As best as I can interpret from the FAQ they’re simply looking for a transparent process around any ownership change, at least for now.
by macintux 7y ago
Not dumb at all. As best as I can interpret from the FAQ they’re simply looking for a transparent process around any ownership change, at least for now.
- brandur 7y agoYep, it's not totally clear yet from their website. My personal hypothesis is that given an alternative recipient for the .org registry that's better in every respect except for the amount of money they're able to pour into the pockets of ICANN / Internet Society (ISOC), it'll be more difficult for these parties to pretend that the .org sale is about anything except graft. As we've see from previously, morally flexible members of these organizations (e.g. Richard Barnes [1]) have claimed that the sale of .org to Ethos is really in the interest of the public good! As details continue to come to light, these arguments are going to get continually more difficult to make. I'm not sure it's realistic the CCOR succeeds in gaining control of .org (although fingers crossed, it sounds like they'd be a far better than owner than ISOC or Ethos), but worst case, they'll force some additional transparency into the process. --- [1] http://www.circleid.com/posts/20191127_why_i_voted_to_sell_org/ http://www.circleid.com/posts/20191127_why_i_voted_to_sell_o...
- mikeliys 7y ago"morally flexible" - cute phrase :) I like it.
- cryptonector 7y agoThey're essentially saying "we have a lot of firepower, you go through with this and we'll be a thorn in your side at court". Now options include going forward as planned, going forward but without doing anything else to raise anyone's ire, going forward with a commitment to governance that makes stakeholders more comfortable, backing down, and maybe other options too.
- jtl999 7y agoBig if it happens. I was going to ask how much "teeth" do they actually have.
- a1369209993 7y agowikipedia.org, archive.org, mozilla.org, and whatever Packet Clearing House runs stop serving content in favor of a splashpage explaining that .org has sold to a criminal^Wour lawyers say we aren't allow to call then crimials organization, linking to their respective new non-.org domains, and urging everyone else to do likewise. A TLD like .org is only worth it's reputaion, and half of that could be made to evaporate overnight.