3 ms·
I keep wondering if planes could benefit from the new materials developed by SpaceX. If they really have a stainless steel that's significantly lighter, it coul
by phkahler 7y ago
I keep wondering if planes could benefit from the new materials developed by SpaceX. If they really have a stainless steel that's significantly lighter, it could be a game changer.
- jonnycowboy 7y agoNot in this case. With SpaceX they also need high (de-entry, Mach heating) and low temperature (cryo fuel & oxygen) resistance but in the case of Boom the surface won’t heat enough to need high temp materials. That said, I’m not sure their choice of materials is the good one for a startup.
- starpilot 7y agoCF prices have come down rapidly in the past 20 years and it's becoming the standard structural material for original airframes. It's more workable and less exotic than it was before. I think most, if not all, aviation startups are using it, like the Icon A5.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> CF prices have come down rapidly in the past 20 years and it's becoming the standard structural material for original airframes. No and no. CF can mean anything, but typically you end up with structural members that are heavier than aluminum when all is said and done. Also, CF is used for sub-subsonic (actually sub-transsonic) skins, which SpaceX found out the hard way. > It's more workable and less exotic than it was before. No. > I think most, if not all, aviation startups are using it, like the Icon A5. Composites are used for subsonic planes and interiors. And the Icon A5 is a toy. The one good thing about composite (as in the Diamond Aircraft models) is that it's hail resistant up to a certain diameter and intensity, around 1 inch. That has been helpful with some storms in Florida, for example.
- ghaff 7y agoAs I understand it, they are using 300-series stainless steel instead of carbon composites. Which relates to some novel techniques in manufacturing parts from stainless [1]. But they don't have a lighter stainless steel, which mostly doesn't make much sense because any steel is basically iron in terms of weight--plus or minus depending upon the additives. Some steels are lighter or heavier than others but within a relatively narrow range. [1] https://everydayastronaut.com/stainless-steel-starship/ https://everydayastronaut.com/stainless-steel-starship/
- phkahler 7y agoThey are supposedly developing a new stainless steel alloy. I've seen indications it will reduce weight on starship. If its stronger, you can use less of it which is effectively lighter. But I haven't seen real info on what they've developed yet.
- starpilot 7y agoYou are not going to get SS with the strength/weight of carbon fiber. Just no way. SpaceX is using SS for its favorable thermal properties that CF doesn't have.
- jandrese 7y agoThe entire 7 meter wing assembly weighs like 230kg. No way in hell you're getting that with stainless steel with any sort of rigidity.