3 ms·
A PKI provides us with a globally trusted answer about identity only. If there is no global consensus about identity then you don't actually have a network. If
by tialaramex 7y ago
A PKI provides us with a globally trusted answer about identity only. If there is no global consensus about identity then you don't actually have a network.
If you don't agree that this is news.ycombinator.com and believe instead it's 4chan or Reddit, then the Web PKI can't help you, and "improving" the Web PKI to some people decide this is Apple and others that it's PornHub is pointless. If you want other names, go build your own network.
In RPKI the identities aren't DNS names like in the Web PKI they're number resources - IP addresses and Autonomous System numbers. Again though, if you can't agree with everybody else about global identity you can't participate in the network.
If you believe maybe 1.1.1.1 is the IP address of your PC and everybody else thinks it's a distributed DNS service run by Cloudflare, there's no purpose to trying to allow us to "agree to disagree". We're right, and you're wrong, go away.
Having global agreement about identity doesn't magically mean we all agree on who to trust, just because I agree with you that Reddit is Reddit, doesn't mean I agree about how much faith to put in a post you saw there.