2 ms·
> invention has an element of arbitrariness or choice in it that discovery does not Yes, I can understand how someone could reach this conclusion. I used to b
by lisper 7y ago
> invention has an element of arbitrariness or choice in it that discovery does not
Yes, I can understand how someone could reach this conclusion. I used to believe it myself. But if you think about it you will realize that this appearance of "arbitrariness or choice" is an illusion. Take the airplane for example. Was it invented or discovered? Is there a relevant distinction between the "invention" of the airplane and the "discovery" of the principles of aerodynamics? What is it?
Even the arts can be seen as a process of discovery, specifically, the discovery of what processes and artifacts produce favorable reactions in human brains.
It's really a matter of perspective, of what dramatic narrative you choose to apply. Any story of invention can be re-cast as a story of discovery.
- pdonis 7y ago> if you think about it you will realize that this appearance of "arbitrariness or choice" is an illusion. I don't think that's the illusion. I think the illusion is that something as complex, for example, as "the airplane" has to be pigeonholed as either an invention or a discovery, instead of being a complicated process in which both invention and discovery were involved. > Any story of invention can be re-cast as a story of discovery. I think this depends on how far you are willing to stretch the meaning of the word "discovery".
- lisper 7y agoNo, it's an observation that there is no sharp line between invention and discovery. If you want to dispute that, you'll have to tell me how I can distinguish between the two.
- pdonis 7y ago> it's an observation that there is no sharp line between invention and discovery This is true of pretty much any human categories, yes. That does not mean the categories aren't valid or that they should all be collapsed into one.
- lisper 7y agoFair enough. But notwithstanding, I contend that my claim is not vacuous. I would say that this particular failure of categorization actually reveals a deep truth, namely, that computation is universal.
- pdonis 7y ago> I would say that this particular failure of categorization actually reveals a deep truth, namely, that computation is universal. I agree that computation is universal, but I don't see drawing a distinction between discovery and invention as denying that fact. In "computation is universal" language, the distinction is just the observation that there are different kinds of computations--moreover, there are different kinds of computations in the category "human mental processes". We don't need to say they're all the same to recognize that they're all computations at bottom.
- dorgo 7y ago> "arbitrariness or choice" is an illusion after reading a little about quantum mechanics I'm not so sure any more. >Even the arts can be seen as a process of discovery, specifically, the discovery of what processes and artifacts produce favorable reactions in human brains. That assumes that the artists test their work against real audience and adjust their style accordingly. Maybe they do, but I'm sure that there are artists out there who just create art.
- Balgair 7y ago>> "arbitrariness or choice" is an illusion >after reading a little about quantum mechanics I'm not so sure any more. Even Brownian motion would suffice, a chemical phenomena we've known about for millennia.[0] The jittering of sodium and potassium ions between neurons can be enough to trigger spike firing in a 'random' way[1]. At the end of the day, we are just complicated salty sacks of stochastic processes trying to reproduce, not much more. [0] yes, it's 'quantum mechanical' in cause, like all things are. I'd say it's more statistical mechanics than quantum though, but to each their own: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brownian_motion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brownian_motion [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principles_of_Neural_Science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principles_of_Neural_Science