Point being that if they can scrape the web and collect and correlate PII, under a claim that’s basically “finders keepers!” and sell that information, that any

Point being that if they can scrape the web and collect and correlate PII, under a claim that’s basically “finders keepers!” and sell that information, that anyone else gaining unrestricted access to that same information can make the same claim of it being publicly available and thus fair game to do with what they will.