3 ms·
If B follows from A via logic, but A is invented, isn't B invented as well then? Just to take a recent example which was mentioned here, Geometric Algebra[1].
by magicalhippo 7y ago
If B follows from A via logic, but A is invented, isn't B invented as well then?
Just to take a recent example which was mentioned here, Geometric Algebra[1]. There you assume you have some objects which aren't numbers but which when squared equals a given number. By doing that a bunch of nice results have been discovered.
However to me the basic premise, take some objects which aren't numbers but which square to a number, feels very much like an invention. So as such wouldn't the nice results be inventions as well?
[1]: https://bivector.net/doc.html https://bivector.net/doc.html
- lmm 7y ago> If B follows from A via logic, but A is invented, isn't B invented as well then? Not really, because you have no choice about B - it's true (or rather it follows from A) whether you want it to or not. You could have picked a different A, but once you picked A then B was fixed.
- magicalhippo 7y agoYet if I pull the trigger we say that I killed someone, not that the bullet did.
- lmm 7y agoPeople invented the electric chair because people discovered that high-voltage electricity can kill people. You might invent a particular axiom because it has an interesting mathematical consequence (e.g. the axiom of choice was invented to allow Hilbert's basis theorem to be proven), but what you invented was the axiom, not the consequence.
- analbumcover 7y agoIt sounds to me like you are giving special precedence to "numbers" in your considerations, as well as drawing your intuition for "square" from working with the integers or the reals. A square is just the result of a binary (product) operation where both of the operands are equal. The operation can be defined on an algebraic object with much richer structure than the integers or reals, and the operation itself can be much more complex than, say, integer multiplication. So the geometric product of geometric algebra is just one animal in the zoo of examples. You might call the specifics of the geometric product operation an "invention," but not because the square of a non-number can be a number.
- magicalhippo 7y agoWell if one would consider numbers and their product "discovered", then my point was that introducing the objects which have the property that they are not numbers but square to numbers seems to me like an invention. At least if there is to be any meaningful distinction between a discovery and an invention.