6 ms·
I am not sure of the implications. Does it even matter if Math is invented or discovered? Maybe it's both, and it isn't a contradiction between invention and di
by DeathArrow 7y ago
I am not sure of the implications. Does it even matter if Math is invented or discovered? Maybe it's both, and it isn't a contradiction between invention and discovering?
We describe things having a certain radiation wavelength as having the color yellow. In that sense, yellow it's an invention. That doesn't mean the radiation doesn't exist.
But to complicate things a bit, some things don't exist unless we observe them. This is the case with states of particles described by quantum mechanics.
Math is more than a science, is the sciences upon which most other sciences and tech are founded. You can model anything in a computer and running on a computer using math. You can describe logic, natural language, technology, biology using math.
In that sense, being the building block of other sciences, math is more akin to a language. Two physicist use math in almost the same way two people use English to describe things and communicate ideas.
But math has building blocks, too. Set of axioms upon which any mathematical object and theory can be constructed. The most popular as of now is Zermelo set theory. There are more such fundamental theories, sometimes very different between them.
So, to see if Math is discovered or invented, the easy thing to do is to see if a set of axioms can be discovered or is invented.
- goatlover 7y ago> Does it even matter if Math is invented or discovered? It matters for philosophical inquiry. Does philosophy matter? It matters for people who find it valuable, the same way art, music or literature matters.
- guerrilla 7y agoYou think logic, the art of making distinctions, the study of critical thinking and the foundation of mathematics only matter in the same way art does?
- inopinatus 7y agoI’d say they don’t matter nearly so much as art. The most cosmically significant export of humanity to date is Voyager’s golden record.
- guerrilla 7y agoGood thing the founders of modern science, mathematics, ethics and political theory didn't share the same opinion.
- inopinatus 7y agoRidiculous hubris, to claim to speak on their behalf, to claim to know the opinion of so many and diverse minds, and in such a crude misdirection to boot.
- guerrilla 7y agoGood thing they wrote volumes about it which have debated and summarized to the hilt.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- inopinatus 7y agoThe summary is that without art, humans are cosmically uninteresting.
- iovrthoughtthis 7y agoI would like some stuff to read on this if possible.
- guerrilla 7y agoSEP contains dense summaries of every major thinker with extremely high quality references. Random example https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/leibniz/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/leibniz/
- DeathArrow 7y agoWhile art is certainly very important, I believe it doesn't have the same impact upon our lives as math has. And if you believe art is about creativity, you can find beauty and art in in mathematics and other sciences. Many great mathematicians were also art lovers, they appreciated music, they appreciated paintings and other forms of art. I don't think there's a dichotomy between art and sciences.
- ukj 7y agoIt's the same kind of activity - creation. The significance of the creation (if it has any at all) is not necessarily the concern of the creator. Some people do Mathematics for its sheer beauty.
- guerrilla 7y agoYou could say the same about structural engineers.
- ukj 7y agoIf you buy into Wittgenstein's rule-following paradox. You could say anything about anything. > no course of action could be determined by a rule, because any course of action can be made out to accord with the rule If I had my own way of (mis?)interpreting him, I think he was alluding to what we now call "strict evaluation" in Programming Language Theory. A diligent rule-follower.
- guerrilla 7y agoStructural engineering the same kind of activity - creation. The significance of the creation (if it has any at all) is not necessarily the concern of the creator. Some people do structural engineering for its sheer beauty.
- ukj 7y ago[Scientific discoveries|Mathematics|Ethics|Political science] are the same kind of activity - creation. The significance of the creation (if it has any at all) is not necessarily the concern of the creator. Some people do [Scientific discoveries|Mathematics|Ethics|Political science] for its sheer beauty.
- guerrilla 7y agoYes, that's my point. It applies to anything that is creative and dismisses the original point through abstraction.
- iovrthoughtthis 7y agoYou think that art does not?
- morelisp 7y ago> the art of making distinctions, the study of critical thinking and the foundation of mathematics only matter in the same way art does? A major movement (or several, depending on how you slice it) in modern philosophy takes aesthetics as first philosophy - so yes, arguably they matter exactly the same way art does.
- voldacar 7y agoyou think too poorly of art
- guerrilla 7y agoI just think our quality of life would be much lower without the forementioned than without art. We'd be much worse off without any of them. My point is not to dismiss art but emphasize the utility of philosophy.
- andreareina 7y agoI think not the whole of logic, but this particular distinction -- what changes in the world if one is true versus the other? Is there even a difference that is manifest? It's like the question of what underlies quantum mechanics -- is the Copenhagen interpretation correct? Everett? Some flavor of deBroglie-Bohm? If there's no way to tell the difference, does it matter? It matters as far as the philosophy of it matters to you, but the concrete consequences of one way being true versus the other could very well be nil.
- miscPerson 7y agoCopenhagen requires an extraneous assumption — which may turn out to have practical implications. At the very least, we know it isn’t parsimonious, though that wasn’t clear until after it was developed (and the philosophical inclination to preserve locality was reasonable).
- Tainnor 7y agoThere is a distinction between logic, which is just the study of formal systems where you can prove theorems as in any other area of mathematics, and the philosophy of maths and particularly of mathematical logic. The same applies for set theory. The first one can assert that (in classical first order logic) e.g. there are uncountable models of the natural numbers; this is irrefutable. The second one asks things like "is classical first-order logic even true and/or adequate in an epistemic sense" (this is different from the more pragmatic question of "is classical FOL useful for the problem at hand")? Similarly, something like Gödel's incompleteness theorems are unequivocally true but the question of what they "mean" deep down is nothing that really affects mathematicians' work in general.
- guerrilla 7y agoIrrefutable and "unequivically" true if you take some classical FOL as a productive method of producing knowledge, a philosophical assumption. Philosophy came first, mathematical logic is just a formalization of that and the reason it was formalized at all and not somethimg else is epistemological. Your entire argument attempting dismiss philosophy is philosophy.
- Tainnor 7y agoI didn't dismiss philosophy. I said that as soon as you fix some axioms (such as those of classical FOL), the conclusions are irrefutable. This is where mathematics begins. The question where those axioms come from or whether they are "true" are philosophical. The two disciplines are related, but separate. Lots of mathematicians have different "foundational" beliefs from each other; some have studied or deeply thought about the philosophy, others may just speak to their intuition. However, this doesn't change the fact that they all come to the same conclusions from the same premises. E.g. a constructivist wouldn't be able to claim that a classical proof is "wrong", only that it's non-constructive and therefore unacceptable for some (philosophical or practical) reason; in fact non-constructive proofs can be seen as constructive proofs of some meaningless strings (e.g. the constructivist will maybe dispute the fact that there are discontinuous functions, but they will certainly accept the existence of a first-order derivation of the string representing "not all functions are continuous" from the axioms of set theory), the constructivist would just dispute that there is any meaning to these strings...
- DeathArrow 7y ago>It matters for philosophical inquiry. I was thinking more of tangible implications. Maybe there are some.
- keiferski 7y agoPhilosophical implications are perhaps the most tangible implications there are: they shape the conception of reality and society that you live in. They only seem intangible because they are subtle and pervasive.
- moron4hire 7y agoOne could replace "Philsophical" in your statement with "Artistic", "Musical" and "Literary" and still have a correct statement.
- moron4hire 7y agoThe construction of your statement implies that you do not think art, music, and literature matter in the same was as philosophy.
- thomasahle 7y ago> Does it even matter if Math is invented or discovered? It impacts whether mathematics should be patentable, since patents generally covers inventions, but not discoveries.
- pron 7y agoPatents cover inventions that are applications of knowledge. For example, chemistry is certainly discovered, but applying the use of a certain molecule as a glue or as a drug is very much patentable. Physics is also discovered, but a special lever system that is a direct application of Newtonian mechanics is patentable. The knowledge that a certain mathematical formula could be written and has certain properties is not patentable, but a device that employs that formula as an algorithm for, say, predicting stock prices, is (in certain countries at least).
- analbumcover 7y agoI don't see how you are distinguishing between inventions and discoveries. The "discovery" of a mathematical proof is just an application of knowledge, why aren't they patentable? The "invention" of the light bulb, on the other hand, is just the discovery that putting various particles together in a certain configuration produces light in a predictable manner, why is this patentable? I don't see how a clear delineation between the two can be made.
- pron 7y agoI'm not. I'm saying that devices whose function is derived from mathematics (algorithms) have the same status as devices that derive their function from physics or chemistry. In either case, "application" doesn't mean some intellectual use but commercial use. The purpose of patents is to protect commercial applications in exchange for sharing the knowledge that led to their creation. The knowledge itself is never protected. When the lightbulb was patented, everyone was free to learn, study, and disseminate the physical knowledge of how a lightbulb works. What you couldn't do is build one and sell it. Whether mathematics is invented or discovered, the knowledge itself is never protected, but if some non-obvious algorithm has a commercial application, it can be patented so to protect building devices that apply that knowledge for commercial use.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoIf it is discovered, then it means there exists math which we don't have to 'invent' and can simply be found like some buried treasure.
- DeathArrow 7y agoI am not sure discovering is easier than inventing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zelos 7y ago> But to complicate things a bit, some things don't exist unless we observe them. Is this intepretation of quantum mechanics still the canonical one?
- fsflover 7y agoThis is a philosophical question. "No experimental evidence exists that distinguishes among these interpretations." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mechanics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mec...
- red75prime 7y ago[0] Proposal for an experimental test of the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics I can't judge whether this proposal makes sense, but there's that. 0: https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9510007.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9510007.pdf
- weego 7y agoIt matters because what if you can't actually describe the underlying foundations of the universe and reality with absolute accuracy as a mathematical equation. We get very close, but if we're always off even by ten to the minus whatever, have we really 'solved' it. Maybe there is some other conceptual framework that we've not or are not able to cognitively express that underpins things.
- sorokod 7y agoto see if Math is discovered or invented, the easy thing to do is to see if a set of axioms can be discovered or is invented A math theory arises from the axioms it is based on. You just rephrased the question and added the word "easy". Put it another way, starting from a set of axioms we get a simple ( by some semiobjective definition of simple ) pure math theory that predicts reality to a rediculous level of precision. Those initial axioms, were they discovered or invented?
- roywiggins 7y agoMath is only sometimes done that way. Often an interesting field gets axiomatized later. Calculus, arithmetic, geometry, algebra, all existed productively for centuries before axiomatization. Same way you can build a programming language without a formal spec. Yes, you might find an ambiguous piece of code later, or paint yourself into a corner. But you can do quite a lot without axioms.
- sorokod 7y agoCalculus, arithmetic, geometry, algebra, all existed productively for centuries before axiomatization. and now, in the year 2020, have the axioms been invented or discovered?
- tim333 7y ago>Does it even matter if Math is invented or discovered? I figure reality is part of math so if it was purely invented we wouldn't exist.