13 ms·
Climate-Driven Megadrought Is Emerging in Western U.S., Says Study
- LatteLazy 7y agoAka human driven.
- smitty1e 7y agoOverpopulation: who can understand it? I was at Mesa Verde a decade ago and asked the Park Service person explaining the cliff dwellings what the ancient population of the Southwest was. One estimate, I was told, put it at 30k.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hnarn 7y agoThe era of fossil fuels will go down in history, if any history is preserved, as the point where human ignorance was no longer held back by lack of capacity. We are so doped up on carbon-based fuel that we are completely oblivious to the total dependency our way of life has on it. A simple thought experiment by the way of "what does it take to produce a pencil"[1] will give anyone insight in this. Sometimes I feel like we just don't have the collective mental capacity to handle mega-issues like these. And in the end, just like an addict, unless we kick the habit we are collectively, as a species, going to walk hand in hand into oblivion. [1]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2153998.I_Pencil https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2153998.I_Pencil
- Ygg2 7y agoI don't think it's that special. When there are large benefits to humans and no apparent downsides, humans will pollute as much as Earth capacity allows. Just like any other organism before.
- hnarn 7y agoHumans aren't single cell organisms. We are self-aware organisms, arguably more intelligent than any other organism we ourselves have ever encountered. There are very apparent downsides to the benefits we are reaping, but for some reason we are incapable of acting as one in the interest of all, and instead seem to prioritize acting for ourselves, seemingly incapable of making the connection that the detriment of all will, in the end, also be the detriment of ourselves.
- loopz 7y agoThe economy functions in order to provide services to as many people as possible. In fact, with the marriage of state and business of today, the output is optimized to extract as much as possible and distribute to people beyond what can be realistically consumed. Our metric is growth of economic activity alone, and thus to detriment to long-term sustainability, prudent management of resources and effective outcomes of economic output.
- zpeti 7y agoJust for a second, try and imagine what world you would be living in without fossil fuels in the last 200 years. Would you have the computer or phone to write on? Would you have the internet to connect? Your house? Your food? That's not to say it's not a good idea to change this, and to wean ourselves off fossil fuels. But to say this period was a period of human ignorance and "doped up"-ness is an extremely naive reading of human history.
- hnarn 7y agoDescribing the era of fossil fuels as "doped up" is not a way of saying that the progress that was made was not good: it's a way of pointing out that it was unsustainable, and irresponsible. There's no reason to believe that computers or phones could not have existed in a different reality where fossil fuels were used in a more restricted manner, owing to their inherent dangers when over-used. Not only could the use have been restricted, we could also have compensated for the usage earlier, and made less irresponsible choices in how we perform our agriculture and industrial endeavors. The insight into climate change is not new, it's not something we're understanding just now. We just didn't care until now. There's a reason people get hooked on drugs, it's a very pleasurable experience, while you're still using it.
- loopz 7y agoWhen the enemy is invisible, nobody cares until the cat's out of the bag. With climate change, the enemy is here already.
- xtian 7y agoI would be careful about blaming "human ignorance" because, case in point, a great many of us are aware of the climate crisis and feel the need to do something about it. In the US, for example, most of the component policies of the Green New Deal poll quite well across party lines. The problem is that the climate crisis demands large-scale collective planning and decision making, and our systems for doing so have been completely co-opted by powerful economic entities. The actions available to the average citizen amount to putting aside everything in one's life to become an activist (which most people don't have the luxury to do), occasionally voting from a menu of pre-selected corporate-backed candidates, or making ultimately insignificant lifestyle changes (and even that has been subverted by economic powers through "eco-friendly" consumer products). It's always helpful to look at a problem through the lens of power relationships before blaming "people" for being stupid or ignorant. Certainly some people are, but that doesn't mean it would solve the problem if they weren't.
- dyadic 7y agoIt is ignorance though, both willing and unwilling. It's ignorance at the bottom, ignorance at the top, and ignorance at every level in between. Even our "solutions" are ignorant. Every improvement in energy efficiency we have ever made has resulted in more energy use, but we still cling to the idea that if we can make everything just a bit more efficient then that will do it and our problem will be solved. It's a lie and it's a scam. A green new deal isn't the solution and it's our ignorance that makes us believe that it is. All it does is greenwash all of the toxic things we are already doing. We can't solve industrialisation with more industrialisation. We can look outside of our windows now and see the solution. It's doing less, it's working less, it's not polluting the world, it's consuming less and producing less. Radically so.
- clarry 7y ago> We can look outside of our windows now and see the solution. It's doing less, it's working less, it's not polluting the world, it's consuming less and producing less. Radically so. And this requires revolution because our whole economy is built around constantly working (and thus producing and consuming, if not rent-seeking, but we can't all be rent-seekers), even if all our basic needs were already met.
- rezeroed 7y agoThere's a take on I, Pencil but with a computer. I'm not sufficiently motivated to look for it, but it's out there somewhere, and was enjoyable.
- crispinb 7y agoI understand your sense of grievance, and often share it at an emotional level. But what makes you think it would ever have been different? Any creature which evolved the behavioural flexibility to outrun curbs on its pullulation would eventually overtax its environment. It just so happens that human spread has been so extensive that our environment is the whole globe. It is only natural, in the strictest sense, that we will damage it, probably to the point of making it inhospitable to us (at least in current numbers & consumption levels). To think that we (merely a bright hominid, evolved for small-group social interactions) might transcend our biology to manage an entire planet is, well, wishful thinking at best. It was a pleasant fantasy, with religious origins. That's all.
- Kaiyou 7y agoIf the cure is worse than the illness, why take the cure? Who are you going to save the planet for? I don't particularly mind humanity ending a few years after I've died of old age.
- Loughla 7y agoThis strikes me as Luddite thinking, at best; 'I like things the way they are, so why change' type of thing. At worst, this comes across as short-sighted, selfish, and hateful. Please explain yourself, so I can understand what you're saying.
- Kaiyou 7y agoLuddites were people that went out destroying the machines that replaced them in the workforce. Obviously their efforts were futile. Please explain how this applies to my thinking. I'm not opposed to technology, I welcome technology. Isn't it very much like the Luddites to advocate for "scaling back" with our "pollution"? The motives are different, but the objective seems identical. You can call me all the adjectives you want, but I do not care if earth explodes after I die. I just don't. I care for my benefits during my own life. I've said this before and I say it again, I do not have any moral problems with sacrificing other peoples benefits for my own benefits and neither should you. Doing this is insanity. Would you starve yourself to death so you can feed other people? Why should I care for other people? It's a silly notion. Maybe I'd care a little bit if I had children, but I don't.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThe cure could easily be better than what we have right now. We don't have to throw away civilisation or the good life to solve this.
- Kaiyou 7y agoWhat do we have to do, then?
- growlist 7y agoI'm a small c conservative, and as part of this I care about the environment, and from my perspective there are a number of ways that the environmental movement don't do themselves any favours. Firstly there are those amongst them that come across far too preachy, in a way that can be a turn-off. Nobody constantly wants to hear bad news and moralising and be told they are personally responsible for all these problems, when most are just trying to get by in a system they didn't create, and have little real influence over. Secondly some of them oppose even the suggestion of technical solutions, preferring instead to emphasise that a kind of hair-shirt existence of drastically poorer lifestyles is all we have the right to expect, as if we've committed some kind of moral crime and only penance will suffice. Thirdly and related to both of the first two points, some (most?) of them are tightly bound to leftist political movements - sometimes tending to the extreme - which both immediately alienates people like me, and makes me suspicious that they are merely using the green movement as a vehicle for ulterior concerns, and indeed some of them are actually completely open about this: 'I’m here to say that XR isn’t about the climate. You see, the climate’s breakdown is a symptom of a toxic system of that has infected the ways we relate to each other as humans and to all life. This was exacerbated when European ‘civilisation’ was spread around the globe through cruelty and violence (especially) over the last 600 years of colonialism, although the roots of the infections go much further back.' https://medium.com/extinction-rebellion/extinction-rebellion-isnt-about-the-climate-42a0a73d9d49 https://medium.com/extinction-rebellion/extinction-rebellion... 'Greta Thunberg: Climate crisis "not just about environment," but also "colonial, racist, patriarchal systems of oppression"' https://disrn.com/news/greta-thunberg-climate-crisis-not-just-about-environment-but-also-colonial-racist-patriarchal-systems-of-oppression https://disrn.com/news/greta-thunberg-climate-crisis-not-jus... I could go on to point out the myriad inconsistencies in the positions of these groups e.g. pro-environment/pro-migration, pro-environment/anti population control, but I'll leave it there. If I think about it for too long it makes me angry because I think these groups are doing more harm than good, and I question whether they really care about the environment at all.
- pcmaffey 7y agoNot sure how you can care about protecting the environment while explicitly ignoring investigation into what’s harming the environment? Unless you believe human activity is not driving climate change, then of course environmentalism is linked to anti-globalization sentiment.
- aww_dang 7y agoHow can we assume that the proposed solutions or diagnosis of the problem can escape the trap of 'human ignorance'? Human nature is largely static. The fallibility of man is a constant.
- roenxi 7y agoProbably a more relevant point - war, famine, plague and chaos are still things that happen in 2020. It would be helpful if the population at large accepted that bad things happen in prosperous places and prepare for them. The climate-driven thing is topical, but you don't need climate change to have a 1 in 1,000 year drought. JIT production would have doomed any society up until around 1800AD and it really hasn't been tested all that well in the last 70 years in wealthy and peaceful nations.
- addHocker 7y agoI always wondered, if there is a way to geoengineer clouds to refill those aquifiers. Find out the main windband going there, go over the ocean, create a artifical thermic (via solar) and produce lots of moisture (ultrasonic foggers driven by solar?), creating rainclouds in a synethetic way.
- swebs 7y agoI don't know why this comment is dead. It's an interesting idea.
- dyadic 7y agoCloud seeding exists already. It works by distributing particles (I forget what of) in the air that water can coalesce around into clouds and then raindrops. There are ethical and geo/political consequences though, since doing it is effectively stealing rain from another area.
- adrianN 7y agoI'd guess that it's more efficient to desalinate water and distribute it via pipelines than to go the extra step of getting it up to cloud height and then letting it fall down again.
- symplee 7y agoExactly. I wonder how feasible it would be to repurpose oil pipelines and send desalinated water back inland.
- netjiro 7y agoIt's all feasible, if you have cheap enough energy. The installations themselves are not that expensive. The energy required is very expensive. And unless it's 100% 0-Carbon it will only exacerbate the situation.
- flooddthvalley 7y agoUltrasonic foggers would also increase the amount of salt in the air, so you’d have to run them far out in the sea. Instead, flood Death Valley with ocean water: 1. Massive evaporative potential. 2. Moisture trapped by tall mountains replenishing the aquifer and making lush surroundings. 3. Massive hydro potential 4. Displaced species not seriously harmed since the moisture gradient would be large (are P. 2) 5. You could harvest the salt prolonging the suitability of the project (anyway measured in centuries if not millennia) Basically you’d have the lushness of the surroundings of Salt Lake City (compared to the desert anyway). Except there would be a lot more moisture (lower salinity wrt it Salt Lake, moisture better trapped) You could do the same thing in Egypt at the Qatara depression, except with potentially global benefits. Here the half of the Sahara could be turned into productive farm land.
- m0zg 7y agoThis is all wonderful but could someone explain why scientists, who claim they can predict when (and if) a drought would start, at the same time can't predict when (and if) it would end? Case in point: nobody predicted that CA drought would end, yet it did.
- noelwelsh 7y agoI don't like seeing the kind of belligerent ignorance you're peddling going unchallenged. The claim, in the first paragraph of the article, is: "a megadrought as bad or worse than anything even from known prehistory is very likely in progress" Note it is "very likely". This is not the same as being certain. Note the drought has already started (quoting Science Mag: "the period from 2000 to 2018 was the driest 19-year span since the late 1500s and the second driest since 800 CE"). As for the CA drought ending, the state is currently 35% in drought (https://www.drought.gov/drought/states/california https://www.drought.gov/drought/states/california). The rain that ended the drought seems like it was fairly inconsequential against the long term trend.
- m0zg 7y agoYeah, I think I'm done believing models where the authors reputation is not on the line if the model turns out to be dead wrong. You can call it "ignorance", I call it "common sense".
- Ididntdothis 7y ago“CA drought would end” In my area we are at 50% of average this year.
- aww_dang 7y agoPerhaps they simply can't make accurate predictions. The rest of their behavior can be easily explained in terms of self interest. While this may be overly cynical, I think it is worth keeping Occam's razor handy.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoWhat would be an example of a non-climate-driven drought? Drought is a variety of climate.
- DagAgren 7y agoDrought is definitely not a variety of climate. Drought is a shortage of water supply, which can be caused by climate, or, for instance, a change in the flow of a river.
- gshdg 7y agoDrought is a variety of weather. Climate change makes drought more common in some areas.
- dredmorbius 7y agoEpisodic or seasonal droughts; nthe El Niño Southern Oscillation / La Niña Pacific Ocean cycle,[1] the Indian Ocean Dipole,[2], changes in weather due to vulcanism,[3] or more cataclysmically, asteroid impacts,[4], seasonal wet-dry cycles such as monsoons,[5] predictable megacycles such as the precession of Earth's apses (Milankovitch cycles),[6] and even large-scale changes in vegitation -- growth or decline of forests and wetlands can affect both micro- and regional weather as well as global weather patterns.[7] Other possible factors are changes in ocean behaviours (especially currents) which themselves may be driven by other climate-related changes, or by changes to seabed (landslides, vulcanism), or joining or parting of landmasses (tectonics, sea level change). Changes in terrestrial hydrological patterns: mountain formation (usually geologically slow, sometimes not), changes to river courses, formation and draining of inland seas and lakes, ice-dam formation and flooding (eastern Washington's badlands are a stunning example). It's complicated. ________________________________ Notes: 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Niño https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Niño 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Ocean_Dipole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Ocean_Dipole 3. https://scied.ucar.edu/shortcontent/how-volcanoes-influence-climate https://scied.ucar.edu/shortcontent/how-volcanoes-influence-... 4. http://ehso.com/climatechange/climatechangecauses-meteorites.php http://ehso.com/climatechange/climatechangecauses-meteorites... 5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsoon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsoon 6. https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2948/milankovitch-orbital-cycles-and-their-role-in-earths-climate/ https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2948/milankovitch-orbital-cycl... 7. https://globalforestatlas.yale.edu/climate-change/climate-change-and-tropical-forests https://globalforestatlas.yale.edu/climate-change/climate-ch... touches on this. One theory is that the decline in Native American populations following European contact, and epidemic disease, lead to a growth in forests in North America, with a resulting decrease in global atmospheric CO2.
- theferalrobot 7y agoGenuine question: Isn’t global warming supposed to cause more rainfall?
- gshdg 7y agoIt’s expected to change the distribution of precipitation.
- theferalrobot 7y agoSo more rainfall globally but possibly less in some regions? Do we know why that is exactly instead of just generally more rain?
- daddylonglegs 7y agoRainfall will be different. There will be more or less rain, at different times of the year, with a changed susceptibility to droughts and/ or floods. So yes, there may be more rain overall but - just as some places may get cooler - local climatic changes will be in multiple directions on multiple axes. It won't be a smooth change to the new conditions either; there will be centuries of instability and infrastructure and agriculture will have to adapt to obsolescence every few decades. I'm not a climatologist but I do know some of the reasons why: The thermal gradient between the equator and the poles (a major driver) will weaken - the poles will heat up more quickly. Ice at the poles drives some ocean currents. Temperatures at different heights in the atmosphere will be affected differently. Increased evaporation from oceans but higher ambient temperatures will change cloud formation unevenly. Nights will cool down more slowly due to the 'blanket' effect of CO2. The overall effects are interconnected of course, which is why there is so much work on modelling and so much work still to do. Edit: I forgot to mention the effects on vegetation and landscape that will also feedback unevenly into the climate. e.g. rainforests depend on and generate a lot of rain; a rainforest may hit a tipping point where it is no longer viable and rainfall will then collapse over a large area.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DennisP 7y agoDrought like this, driven by global warming, was predicted in the book Six Degrees by Mark Lynas, published in 2007. He read 3000 peer-reviewed papers on the effects of climate change and summarized them, one chapter per degree, with extensive references. Massive drought in the western U.S. was in his chapter for one degree of warming, right where we're at now. Given what's in his later chapters, I'm not too happy about seeing him accurate so far.
- sails 7y agowhat's in his later chapters?
- DennisP 7y agoIt's been several years since I read it, but up through two degrees, things were a terrible mess but life goes on. By three degrees, the South American rainforest burns to the ground, and some major agricultural regions dry up because they depends on dry-season melt from glaciers that don't exist anymore. Hundreds of millions of refugees. After that it got bad. I forget the details but by four degrees it looked to me like modern civilization would have a hard time staying viable, and by six it was hard to imagine our species surviving.
- growlist 7y ago> by six it was hard to imagine our species surviving I suspect before we got near extinction point there would be plans for the last few tens of thousands to survive underground/underwater/in domes/at high altitude/latitude etc. We have people talking seriously about a colony on another planet, after all.
- take_a_breath 7y agoSounds like that would require significant planning and building. Who decides who “the last few tens of thousands” will be? What will everyone else think about that? People talk seriously about a lot of things, doesn’t mean they are viable or realistic.
- yters 7y agoIt'd be interesting to hear plans for viable ways forward, instead of one side saying there is no problem, and the other side saying there is a problem and the only solution is X (which is a tragedy of the commons type solution). It'd also be interesting to hear the potential upsides (along with the catastrophic downsides) with what is going on. And, if there are absolutely no upsides and everything is going to end horribly no matter what we do, then how can we make the best of our remaining time?
- coldpie 7y agoThis information is available if you go look for it. Start at the latest IPCC reports and branch out from there. It's a very large topic, your summary of the "sides" is wildly uninformed.
- epistasis 7y ago> other side saying there is a problem and the only solution is X (which is a tragedy of the commons type solution). You may want to broaden your sources, I can't imagine how you got the impression of "only solution is X." There are all sorts of mitigation plans, all sorts of energy transition plans. Nobody know what will work in the end, what new unforeseen technologies will be developed, and how the costs will change as industry scales technologies, so there's a huge variety. If your X == "stop emitting greenhouse gasses," well, there's tons of ways to do that. Many of which will massively increase economic productivity. There are occasional large reports that spell out various routes to stop emitting GHG. There are resources like Project Drawdown that investigate these potential of a hundred different climate interventions. There are focused news media like GreenTech Media that focus on technology interventions. There are an abundance of governmental reports on ways to meet our climate goals, on all sorts of particulars, for example I was reading a great one last night about electricity of buildings in California or using renewable natural gas [1]. There's soooo many books, forums, advocacy groups, policy wonks, podcasts, news outlets, etc. focused on exploring what you say you want to hear. So many that it's hard to even suggest a starting point. Imagine if somebody said "I'd be interested in hearing more about computers and the internet," how would you start pointing them to the general resources for something so broad? [1] https://ww2.energy.ca.gov/2019publications/CEC-500-2019-055/CEC-500-2019-055-F.pdf https://ww2.energy.ca.gov/2019publications/CEC-500-2019-055/...
- grandinj 7y agoHmmm, I would think the massive sucking dry of the aquifers by farms and cities using massive pumping schemes would be more to blame. Once you pull the aquifer down far enough, the surface starts to dry up, plants stop holding the soil together, the microclimate changes, which reduces the water capture, etc, etc.
- twojacobtwo 7y agoFrom the other end of the equation, if the aquifer is primarily surface fed and does not receive input from rainfall, the aquifer will drop regardless of the withdraw rate.
- michaelbrave 7y agoA lot of the western US has been in drought nearly my entire life. They have been using the underground rivers nearly to depletion (Kansas) or importing water via massive pipelines from other states (California). It's been completely mismanaged even down to choice of crop (I.E. Almonds aren't drought friendly and should not be grown in places that have them). I imagine if things get even slightly worse it could help lead to a collapse.
- symplee 7y agoAre these repurposed oil pipelines? Or dedicated fresh water pipelines built specifically to replenish water supplies? I'd imagine as oil declines, the pipelines from the gulf might be able to send desalinated water back inland. Not sure how feasible this would be, thoughts?
- readmodifywrite 7y agoThe issue there is desalinating the water in an environmentally responsible way. It's hugely energy intensive.
- symplee 7y agoThere have been some encouraging results recently. For example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22269115 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22269115 In any case, the time frame we're talking about is 10-20 years from now. Lots of time for even more breakthroughs.
- gdubs 7y agoI recently posted a link to Bill Mollison’s “Introduction to Permaculture”, which is available to borrow digitally on the archive.org [1] One critical aspect of permaculture is water management. It’s usually one of the first things you consider when designing a home, a farm, a town, a city — even a whole region. The crazy thing is, despite all the drought, most of our land is engineered to “ditch” water — get it off the land as quickly as possible. This is because too much water can cause it’s own set of problems, and the flip side of drier summers can be flood-like rain in the wet months. What permaculturists like to do is find ways to capture rain in a non-destructive way, through “swales” (winding excavations that slow the water as it moves through the land, distributing it from the valleys to the ridges, sometimes small ponds), and deep rooted perennial prairie grasses and trees that break up the hard pan souls and allow water to penetrate deeply. The overall aim is to recharge the underlying aquifer. There’s lots of secondary benefits to this kind of whole-system approach, but at minimum we should be re-engineering our landscape to make better use of what we’re given every year. 1: https://archive.org/details/introductiontope00moll/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/introductiontope00moll/mode/2up
- wtdo 7y agoI'd love to see more innovation in farming practices. I'm a huge fan of aquaponics. Uses around 10% of the water of current farming techniques. I've got my own setup in my backyard. Right now I'm working on getting it started, but I'm planning on experimenting with growing wheat, and if I ever get a large enough system, I want to try growing trees, like almonds, which are traditionally pretty water intensive. These aren't generally worth growing at a small scale, but I figure if it can be done then maybe it could scale up. I really want to try making a combine harvester for wheat that runs on rails along the aquaponics grow beds to help in the automation.
- Fjolsvith 7y ago> The crazy thing is, despite all the drought, most of our land is engineered to “ditch” water — get it off the land as quickly as possible. Which land are you talking about? In western Kansas, fields are terraced and capture rainwater to soak into the ground water table. Since they've done the terracing, gully-washers have been non-existent and most of the time streams are dry.
- hindsightbias 7y agoReading some of the comments on this thread, would like to ask if anyone knows the right term to research something that has long bothered me. There are of course people who disagree on science, data and facts. What I'm curious about is people who claim or are science and data-driven but believe that only certain scientific fields are engaged in organized collusion or mass delusion. For instance, a biologist I met who thought archeologists are covering up young Earth, an astronomer who thinks the NIST/ASCE 9/11 Study was complete fabulation (although they admitted they'd never read it), and engineers I know who insist climatologists are all just in it for the money. While I understand why the general populace may hold such views, I'm curious as to if there have been studies concerning how a population of those who believe in scientific method can so strongly believe their peers in selective (usually other) fields are so differently motivated.
- coldpie 7y agoSounds like you basically got there yourself in your last paragraph, but I think a term that might lead you down some fruitful reading is "motivated reasoning." It's often about maintaining some other desirable property (e.g. being accepted by their community; keeping a particular friend group; holding a belief system), and rationality takes a backseat to maintaining that property.
- milesvp 7y agoThis one can be quite complicated, but I wonder how much of it is actually related to the quote that goes something like “science progresses one death at a time”. Which is talking about a bigger problem in science, which is that tenured scientists have either too much invested in their careers or too much vested in their models to allow the spread of upstart scientists’ ideas. There’s often a generational aspect (though don’t confuse this with age, since someone new to a field at 70 would be a younger generation) where newer scientists pick up on some thing that older scientists ignored and they start spreading it’s importance, then 20 years later, once the last of the old guard leave the field, it’s no longer downplayed and science can ‘advance’ (there is some risk that said thing wasn’t actually important, but for hard sciences data tends to trump all else). So then the question to your question becomes more, are these contrarians representative of some new wave? As a trained economist, I’ve been trained to be skeptical of entrenched establishments, usually people will fail to believe that which threatens their paychecks. So the other question is, are there big incentives to encourage the established field to continue believing what it believes? I will say there are a lot of crackpots out there, and novices tend to be wrong a lot, so the way science is currently done isn’t such a bad thing. But it would be wise to at least listen occasionally to cross discipline contrarians. They will often bring up arguments that are strong from their primary field, without being weighed down with baggage from the other field. You get an occasional Eli Whitney, or if you’re really lucky a John Nash. One last thought. Hard sciences are hard for a reason, reality keeps them in check. And experiments allow for falsifiable hypotheses. There are a lot of sciences that rely primarily on observation, with little to no experimentation. This makes falsifiability tricky. This also means you’re going to see more general dissent associated with these fields (and if you don’t see it within the field that might be a red flag).
- mark_l_watson 7y agoSad but true. I live in the mountains of central Arizona. This year has been good (8 inches so far, our yearly average is 18 inches for the entire year). Last year was also good. But, long term, the whole southwest is in a long term worrisome position.