3 ms·
If you pare it back to the basics; the government has two actual powers: 1) Send in the police and have people imprisoned 2) Send in the army and have people k
by roenxi 7y ago
If you pare it back to the basics; the government has two actual powers:
1) Send in the police and have people imprisoned
2) Send in the army and have people killed
In practice they have a lot of much softer options because they leverage the basic powers into more subtle ones, but government is fundamentally about who controls the army and the police. Feinstien, like all people in the US Congress, has made decisions that ultimately involve some really, truly horrible outcomes for other people. She lives in a world where horrible things do have to happen sometimes to keep order, even in the more optimistic models of government.
It is unlikely, so say the least, that the implications around civil liberties escape any long-serving politician. The enforcement of laws necessarily sits on the edge of abusing civil liberties. It is more likely she just doesn't want to talk about that.
- zlaaa 7y ago3) Fine you with some made up sum. If you don't pay, you lose you credit score, your home and everything else. This is rarely applied to members of the government, the rich or corporations. It is the favorite instrument to keep the middle class work horses under control.
- roenxi 7y agoAnd how will the government deal with a fine non-payer who keeps their wealth in physical form? Say they have no money in the bank but keep gold bars in a stack under their bed. They barter for everything they need. At some point it devolves to burly men with or without guns making people do things. Or women in this enlightened age. In practice it hopefully isn't a common thing but there has to be a level of physical compulsion backing up everything that communities don't enforce among each other anyway. A major job of people in Congress is to work out exactly what does happen when people refuse to comply and at some point it gets physical (quite quickly if someone is really bent on being uncooperative). Issues like that would be close to the top of every politicians's mind.
- raidicy 7y agoIt is possible to confiscate physical wealth if it's "assumed" to be obtained by illegal means.