10 ms·
How the coronavirus is driving new surveillance programs globally
- saagarjha 7y ago> Governments need information to create containment strategies and know where to focus resources. At the same time, governments have a way of holding onto tools that undermine citizens’ privacy long after the moment of crisis has passed. I wonder if it’s worth governments’ time trying to come up with automatically expiring bills for “emergency” uses such as these.
- lkramer 7y agoIn Denmark, most (all?) of the emergency measures have come with a sunset clause, typically a year from inception.
- a_imho 7y agoWhy a year? Emergency measures being valid for the duration of the emergency would be pretty straightforward.
- Lewton 7y agoI think it's because it makes them able to react much quicker if hit by a second infection wave
- openfuture 7y agoYou are forgetting to factor in complacency. When is the second wave? when should we stop waiting for it? that just depends on how useful the law is for those in power.
- johnr2 7y ago> Emergency measures being valid for the duration of the emergency would be pretty straightforward. Deciding when the emergency is over is less straightforward than a fixed time period. A government that wanted to extend the measures indefinitely would just claim there's still an emergency.
- BWGB 7y agoFor example the Patriots Act in USA, signed into law after 9/11 attacks. The sunset was in 2005, but it's still in force.
- gmueckl 7y agoBut the cooperation of legislators is required because of the fixed deadlines. If the government would be allowed the right to extend the provisions on their own, they probably would try to do that in perpetuity. With a legislative branch that actually cares about civil rights, the former is the much better option.
- goto11 7y agoNot straightforward - somebody would have to decide when the emergency is over, which then becomes a political question. And even if the emergency is not over in a year, it makes a lot of sense to reconsider if the measures (which were decided very quickly) are actually appropriate and necessary going forward. Hopefully a lot have been learned in a year.
- Tainnor 7y agoI would also assume that the GDPR would impose severe restrictions as to the allowed duration of data collection for contact tracing purposes (in the sense that it shouldn't be legal anymore once Coronavirus ceases to be a major threat), but IANAL, so I could be wrong.
- m4rtink 7y agoThat's quite a long time - the state of emergency here in Cze Republic can be only 30 days, after which the parliament needs to confirm any extension. Which it already did & for less than the extra month originally requested by the government.
- netcan 7y agoThat's a good thing, but lingering emergency laws are not the full extent of the risk. The risk is largely related to changing perceptions and standards for what is normal, beyond the pales & such. Once something has been done widely and publicly, it becomes more normal and less scary.
- alacombe 7y agoIn Canada, the Government tried to pass broad emergencies measures giving it essentially unlimited power without parliament oversight... until December 2022.
- shakna 7y ago> I wonder if it’s worth governments’ time trying to come up with automatically expiring bills for “emergency” uses such as these. The Patriot Act has a sunset clause, but has been repeatedly extended, which no obvious sign of it ever not being extended. The ability to change laws makes it easier for government's to sell these sorts of changes to their constituents ("it's only temporary") whilst knowing that it probably won't turn out to actually be temporary, because they can change something that is temporary into effectively permanent.
- wtdo 7y agoThat can be fixed by making sunset clauses automatically require a few things: 1. Must be voted on alone. That is, no sneaking it into another bill, or into the budget votes. 2. Each renewal requires a higher percentage of yes votes than the last time until 100% is required. To my recollection, there's never been a time when the Patriot Act received 100% approval.
- shakna 7y agoOn its face, this sounds great. However, there is nothing to prevent a later amendment then removing one of these requirements, as unreasonable or outdated because of the new way the law is being used. To law makers, nothing about a law is immutable. Which is the crux of the problem, really. You can't prevent bad actors from messing things up unless you don't do it in the first place. There are benefits, clear and strong, for several of these laws when they are first prepared. It's the fact you can't rely on anyone down the track not to abuse it that's the problem.
- malandrew 7y ago“Nothing is so permanent as a temporary government program” – Milton Friedman
- crocodiletears 7y agoSunset clauses aren't reliable mechanisms (patriot act). Beyond special interests, I wouldn't blame legislators if they were a little afraid to deny an intelligence service some of their toys if they've gotten comfortable using them.
- hutzlibu 7y agoBut that is up to the people to pressure for change. As long as most fear the ever dreadful terrorist and as long as the ever going war on terror creates new terrorist, there is an everlasting accepted need for the patriot act. And here with the new surveilance against corona, we will probably find out, that to fight new more dangerous deseases and of course terrorism, crime and pedophiles, we cannot really give up on these tools. There is no alternative, like my chancellor merkel says with everything. And when enough people believe it, it is true.
- watwut 7y agoPeople don't vote on causes. Majority of people wanting something does not mean it can pass at all.
- hutzlibu 7y ago"Majority of people wanting something does not mean it can pass at all." Depends. It does not matter for example, if the majority wants to have nice weather, no. But if the majority would insists on mandatory privacy, for example, then yes, it would pass. But they do not. Most give up privacy voluntarily for all their "free" apps and services.
- watwut 7y agoIn contemporary America, there are host of issues where polls consistently shows majority wants x, but it does not matter in actual politics. Two parties mean that average person opinion on this or that issue does not matter all that much. Same if other countries I am sure, but America is the topic.
- lukeplato 7y agoAlthough it's still considered a fringe/conspiracy theory, I've heard some interesting claims on the use of digital ids and immunity certificates for verifying who has been vaccinated. - https://id2020.org/ https://id2020.org/ - https://youtu.be/-aR7cz30chE?t=145 https://youtu.be/-aR7cz30chE?t=145
- triyambakam 7y agoIt's not a theory, recently Bill Gates did an AMA on Reddit [1] and verified that ID2020 would indeed be used to verify who has been vaccinated. The conspiracy theory aspect is whatever one wants to expound on from there... [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fksnbf/comment/fkupg49 https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fksnbf/comment...
- krapp 7y ago>The conspiracy theory aspect is whatever one wants to expound on from there... Let me guess... Mark of the Beast, rise of the Antichrist, New World Order, FEMA death camps, blah blah blah. Same stuff, different decade.
- dreamache 7y agoWrong. Money, power & control. If you limit what one can do if they don't have a vaccine, you create an artificial demand for the vaccine, thus driving profits through the roof. Basic economics there. I won't be getting my "ID" card if they ever make one.
- tobylane 7y agoWhat if it’s a non profit who use Western profits to subsidise third world efforts? This already happens in other areas of medicine, far more so in the for profit sector. Limit what one can do without a visa, up the artificial demand to useful levels of herd immunity, and use the profits to fund doing the same in Africa.
- 7y ago
- CoronaBasedGod 7y agoThese protests we are seeing would be significantly more powerful if they didn't mention politics. Instead people are quick to say "it's just the other political party and those people are stupid".
- phendrenad2 7y agoYawn. Every crisis, someone says "governments will use this crisis to expand the surveillance state!!!". Okay, how many more crises before their surveillance state is complete? Because by my count, they could have built it 99 times over. Also, since no one ever seems to care, and the surveillance state measures are enacted without (much) resistance, I don't know why the governments have to wait for a crisis to incrementally ratchet up the surveillance state. Maybe they haven't caught on yet. Shh, don't tell them.
- wil421 7y agoSometimes the Western Governments test the waters during a crisis (or the threat of a crisis) to see if there is a public outcry. Lots of people protested the Patriot Act and other post 9/11 stuff but the majority of people at the time were fine with it because it was to find the terrorists. Not sure if they ever found a terrorist on America soil but now we have TSA screens, Homeland Security, and a boat load of other extensions of federal power.
- tobylane 7y agoThere’s also the Patriot Act renewals which happened at a relatively quieter time.
- wolco 7y agoEach event adds a new layer of the surveillance state. 9/11 had the patriot act.. can hold you forever without a lawyer loss of freedom. So far we've seen google give away location data on millions of people. Ditto for providers. The government used it to determine who was away from their homes over the weekend. It's not one event but a series of events that changes a society.
- buzzkillington 7y agoDo you know why there are no Jews left in Holland? They had the most efficient census of any European country. So when the Nazis came in and replaced the moderate Democratic Monarchy all they had to do to round up all the Jews was to select the column for religion on the IBM punch cards from the last census. It's a travesty that next to no one knows the fact that the holocaust was the first large application of computers and the atom bomb was the second.
- Tainnor 7y agoI think the article should more clearly distinguish between approaches that indeed gather lots of unnecessary data (that is often of questionable importance) vs. more decentralised (e.g. bluetooth based) approaches that can help with contact tracing while still allowing to be implemented with privacy concerns in mind. Also, (as a non-American) I think the patriot act is a horrible thing, but I also think that in particular, the threat of terrorism has always been massively overstated (and even if not, many of the subsequent changes e.g. in airport security, are terribly ineffective). By contrast, I think that Coronavirus is a very serious threat and a recent study does seem to indicate that app-based contact tracing solutions could really help. I'll repeat that it's possible to do this in a privacy-conscious manner and it really should be done like that (not just because otherwise people will refuse to use it).
- DennisP 7y agoIn the U.S., the Supreme Court decided[1] in 2018 that the government couldn't access cell location data without a warrant. However, they made an exception for public safety: > Such exigencies include the need to pursue a fleeing suspect, protect individuals who are threatened with imminent harm or prevent the imminent destruction of evidence. Fighting a pandemic arguably falls into this category, since an awful lot of people are threatened with imminent harm. So we already have a constitutional standard for rolling back pandemic-related surveillance measures. Also, something this article overlooks about the Apple/Google system is that it does a pretty good job of protecting user privacy. Contacts are discovered by direct bluetooth contact, and central servers don't get any information from people except that they tested positive.[2][3] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/22/us/politics/supreme-court-warrants-cell-phone-privacy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/22/us/politics/supreme-court... [2] https://ncase.me/contact-tracing/ https://ncase.me/contact-tracing/ [3] https://github.com/DP-3T/documents https://github.com/DP-3T/documents
- II2II 7y agoPrivacy discussions often gloss over or outright ignore the many factors that affect perspectives on privacy. Quite often this will make a stance that is perfectly reasonable to one person look like raving lunatic to another person. Trust is one factor. Even if an individual agreed that the approach being suggested by Apple and Google is a good one, they are unlikely support it if they do not trust those businesses. Even if that individual trusts the motivations of a party, it does not imply that they trust their competence. Social change is another factor. Whether we acknowledge it or not, there has been an enormous change in attitudes towards privacy over the past quarter century. If you took anyone from 1995 and showed them the technology of today, they would likely be amazed by our access to information and horrified by other people's access to our own information. Keep in mind that was an era when the Internet was just starting to reach into homes and the typical phone call was made from a landline. On top of that, most devices were siloed by necessity so that phone call was between you, the recipient, and the phone company. You did not have to worry about a social media company trying to mine your contact data with an app installed on your phone (because phones did not support apps and barely supported storing phone numbers). Even though we have had decades to adapt to those changes, some people are more likely to embrace their benefits while others have held on to their old values.
- at_a_remove 7y agoNever let a good crisis go to waste.
- m-p-3 7y agoI think the part that worries me the most for privacy and how far-reaching it could be is this https://coronavirus.medium.com/apple-and-google-join-forces-to-track-spread-of-coronavirus-fc2c68fda0ea https://coronavirus.medium.com/apple-and-google-join-forces-... I know Apple is marketing themselves as pro-pricacy, but I doubt they can anonymize the data in a way that preserves privacy while still achieving the goal of tracing contacts. It just seems like a convoluted way of making a gigantic knowledge graph of interactions between individuals under the pretense of public health.