3 ms·
> there is a very specific issue before the court at the moment. It may seem arcane and procedural, but the back-and-forth arguments between Amazon and the gove
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> there is a very specific issue before the court at the moment. It may seem arcane and procedural, but the back-and-forth arguments between Amazon and the government raise a key question of principle and fairness that should matter to us all. Namely, should a company—like Amazon—that bid high and lost, now get a do-over, especially now—as the IG’s report makes clear—Amazon received additional proprietary information about Microsoft’s bid that it should never have had.
Actually, I don't really see the problem. There are two hypothetical models:
1. Everyone gets to bid for the work once, and if they get it wrong, too bad for them. What's right and what's wrong? Depends on your point of view. What matters is that everyone got the same single chance to bid for a government contract.
2. Everyone bids for the contract. If their bid isn't being accepted, they're free to adjust it. What matters is what the terms ultimately are, not what they were at the start of bidding.
You may recognize that second model as the normal way everything is sold everywhere. What's supposed to be wrong with Amazon quoting a price for something, not getting a sale, and then lowering the price? We should hope they do, and that Microsoft responds by lowering their price even more.
- roel_v 7y agoOf course you can construct an argument for anything if you can just make up things. The fact here is that there is only one reality: your option 1. Those are the rules for any closed bid procurement processes. Who is going to bid for anything if they know they will be in a race to the bottom even after spending all their time on the initial bid?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoPeople who expect to be able to turn a profit at their quoted price will bid. Just like everything else. Who's supposedly benefiting from these rules? Why would we be interested in following them?
- partiallypro 7y agoIsn't the point though that Amazon knew about Microsoft's bid and other proprietary elements and STILL bid high (while Microsoft was blind to Amazon's?) They already had the advantage of information. #2 has already effectively happened.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> #2 has already effectively happened. What? #2 is a process, not a point event.
- belltaco 7y agoI don't think Amazon knew about Microsoft's bid before the result was announced. Looks like the DoD folks did not redact a bunch of things properly while disclosing the winner information to Amazon.