3 ms·
> I don't think anyone claims that nuclear is safer than solar This branch of the comment thread started because arcticbull claimed, with two separate sourc
by roenxi 7y ago
> I don't think anyone claims that nuclear is safer than solar
This branch of the comment thread started because
arcticbull claimed, with two separate sources, that nuclear is safer than solar.
The major examples of nuclear being less safe than solar involve invoking nuclear plants designed in 1967 (Fukushima) and 1972 (Chernobyl). At the dawn of the nuclear industry [0].
People are claiming that nuclear is safer than solar and they are accompanied by statistical evidence that nuclear is absurdly safe. The evidence is also considerable that by 1975 they'd figured out how to design a safe reactor.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nuclear_power_history.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nuclear_power_history.svg
- na85 7y agoI believe the claim was that it's safer per terawatt-hour, not that it's absolutely safer. Those are different metrics.
- roenxi 7y agoWhile technically correct that isn't a useful interpretation of "nuclear power is safer than solar", because it implies that nuclear is infinitely safer than using solar energy in a country that doesn't have any nuclear plants but has some solar panels. I don't think anyone would care about that fact in practice. Deaths per unit power is much more important unless you have a thesis that it changes with the amount of power produced.