2 ms·
> He might have chosen to not disclose his discussions with other people. Including the SEC? > He might have meant it in earnest. You can be as earnest as yo
by FireBeyond 7y ago
> He might have chosen to not disclose his discussions with other people.
Including the SEC?
> He might have meant it in earnest.
You can be as earnest as you like and still be capable of making statements that are factually incorrect. As to your previous point, one would presume that an absolute defense against the SEC's charges about making materially false statements would be to show that said statements were not, in fact, materially false. That didn't happen though.
> For fraud, surely he must have had the intention to profit from it personally at the expense of shareholders?
You mean the hope that the share price would go up, with him as a large shareholder. "At the expense of shareholders" would include "shareholders who may have bought, sold, or changed their strategies, or not, based on Mr Musk not making said statements as a matter of fact, that weren't".