3 ms·
Hmm I need some schooling please: "The TDP for the latter part is 35 W while the i9-10900F is listed at 65 W, but being an Intel desktop processor that just re
by nottorp 7y ago
Hmm I need some schooling please:
"The TDP for the latter part is 35 W while the i9-10900F is listed at 65 W, but being an Intel desktop processor that just reflects the TDP for the base clock, with much higher energy demands required for higher clocks (e.g. maximum PL1 has been recorded at 170 W)."
So where do I find the actual maximum power consumption on recent desktop CPUs then? Do I set a limit in the BIOS? Do I read each and every review to see what they measured?
Pointers to relevant links very much appreciated, thankee sai.
- rowanG077 7y agoYou can't find it. Intel has obscured the measurement too much. AMD is guilty of this as well but on a much smaller scale then Intel.
- nottorp 7y agoSheesh. So the only way is to settle on a few cpu models and search for reviews that have measured the actual power consumption?
- leeter 7y agoEven that is specific to that chip/mobo/PSU/Case/CPU cooler setup. So unless you match what was used in the article your mileage will vary a lot.
- sharken 7y agoSad but true, 35W should translate to less power usage than 65W. Still waiting for Lenovo Yoga Slim 7 which appears to be at the sweet spot for battery life, power and size.
- rowanG077 7y agoI don't think reviewers measure it. It's essentially just an average power draw under real-world load at this point.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- leeter 7y ago> So where do I find the actual maximum power consumption on recent desktop CPUs then? Unfortunately you do this by putting it on a motherboard and and generally putting an amp meter on the 12v EPS rail. Either that or just power from wall. The CPU vendors have worked really hard to hide this. Mostly because for most people it's largely irrelevant these days as the CPU will scale to cooling and power delivery. There are some limits though.
- derefr 7y agoYou'd think "power consumption for prolonged 100% all-cores workload" would be the most relevant thing when selling server chips specifically, though, since it translates directly into OpEx. And yet even on those data sheets it's nowhere to be found.
- leeter 7y agoSo for that it's "Easier" because you check the VRM spec for the socket for server. That's the maximum draw the manufacturer expects any CPU for that socket to ever pull. Then generally most of the higher end parts will vary clock speed vs cores etc to stay on that line. This works because server motherboard manufacturers only ever build to that spec and not one iota beyond it for cost reasons. But yeah... average expected draw is going to be interesting and most manufacturers won't give a number to avoid getting sued.
- jandrese 7y agoYeah, but the mobo manufacturer has to plan on you putting in the thirstiest chips on there, when you might be putting lower end chips on because your workload is mostly memory or PCI channel constrained and you are looking to max out the density in the rack. Of course you also have to consider the cooling capacity of your chassis. 170W in a 1U form factor needs a hell of a lot of airflow to avoid thermal throttling, especially on a dual CPU motherboard. Plus you gotta fit the power supply and everything else in there.
- 7y ago
- kllrnohj 7y agoYou look at measured draws for the relevant workloads. Anandtech has a good intro to the various states that an Intel CPU can be in here: https://www.anandtech.com/show/13544/why-intel-processors-draw-more-power-than-expected-tdp-turbo https://www.anandtech.com/show/13544/why-intel-processors-dr... For Intel specifically the TDP is what you need to dissipate to sustain the base frequency. If you want to run beyond base frequency (the "all core turbo"), then you need to handle more. How much more isn't officially documented, nor are the turbo charts either annoyingly (aka, this: https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/intel/core_i9/i9-9900k#Frequencies https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/intel/core_i9/i9-9900k#Frequenc... ) So for a 9900K looking the official numbers are 95W for 3.6GHz of all core load. But it'll turbo with all cores loaded up to 4.7GHz, for which you'll need some amount of cooling. How much? Well more than 95W that's for sure, but that's all you really officially know. So then you look at reviews and you find that under full load the 9900K pulls down ~170W if it's not hitting thermal limits: https://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph14605/111362.png https://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph14605/111362.png
- SomeoneFromCA 7y agoHere is a link to a test of 101 different processors, with corresponding power consumption figures. Alas it is in Russian. https://www.ixbt.com/platform/101-cpu-platform-test-2017.html https://www.ixbt.com/platform/101-cpu-platform-test-2017.htm...
- nottorp 7y agoOh that's helpful, thanks. Don't need to read the text. It's also a bit insane how far they go with the marketing lies.
- SomeoneFromCA 7y agoHere is the graph you are looking for: blue = low CPU load yellow = medium red = maximal load They measure the whole system consumption, so you need to subtract roughly 25-30 watts, to get raw CPU consumption.
- SomeoneFromCA 7y agoI apologize, did not link the graphs: power consumption: https://www.ixbt.com/img/x780/r30/00/02/26/21/31power_334783.png https://www.ixbt.com/img/x780/r30/00/02/26/21/31power_334783... power effciency: https://www.ixbt.com/img/r30/00/02/26/21/33ee_794961.png https://www.ixbt.com/img/r30/00/02/26/21/33ee_794961.png